Wolf Trek: Transfigurations

Captain’s log, stardate 81558.3: The Enterprise rescues the lone survivor of an escape pod who has lost his memory. Crusher soon discovers not only is the alien recuperating with incredible speed, but is mutating as well.


Welcome back, folks! If you’re reading this on WordPress, then you haven’t missed anything because the last written post only came out a week ago! But for me, it’s been a long several months as I’ve spent much of the first half of the year working on About Space, and I wasn’t able to finish the Wolf Trek backlog in time. But now that the first draft of that book is done, I am finally able to focus and write about Trek on my own terms!

So! “Transfigurations” then. The penultimate episode of the season, and featuring an amnesiac alien who seems to be undergoing a strange transformation involving lots of golden light. No, this isn’t a crossover with Doctor Who, but anyone who is primarily familiar with the recently-cancelled 2005 revival series can be forgiven for, at first glance, thinking that’s what’s happening.

As it turns out, what’s actually happening is John Doe is becoming an energy being, kind of like the Organians from the TOS era. When he completes his transformation, it does look kind of like Time Lord regeneration, but isn’t. (Interestingly, that scene was actually shot on a special film that allowed the orange suit John Doe’s actor was wearing to glow. The magic of practical effects!)

The medical drama is interrupted by the arrival of some adversarial aliens, because who doesn’t love a good bit of spaceship combat? Then we learn this, per Memory Alpha’s summary: “Allegedly, [Doe] is a dangerous criminal who is disturbing the normal order of society on Zalkon and deserves death. Sunad demands that the Enterprise leave the Zalkonian system and return John Doe to them. He gives them two hours to make their decision before he fires.”

Picard and crew, naturally, are not about to put up with this shite and good for them. Sure, they end up suffocated because Sunad is a paranoid asshole, but still! Their refusal to turn on Doe is admirable, and it’s what saves all their lives during the episode’s final act: “Sunad insists to Picard that Doe and his kind are a severe danger to society, but Doe tells Picard the truth: the Zalkonian species is on the verge of an amazing evolutionary change, but Sunad and their society’s other leaders, fearful of something they don’t understand and perceiving a threat to their authority, have decried the changes as “evil” and been murdering any members of their society who exhibit them.”

It reminds me a bit of the Discovery episode “The Sound of Thunder.” That episode dives deep into the world of the Kelpiens (Saru’s people) and the Ba’ul, their predators, and the mysterious Vahar’ai biological process. We are first led to believe that Vahar’ai is some form of madness brought on by the disappearance of Kelpien threat ganglia, but in “The Sound of Thunder” we learn the truth: 2,300 years earlier, the post-vahar’ai Kelpiens actually greatly outnumbered the Ba’ul, driving them to the verge of extinction. The Ba’ul were originally the prey species… which meant that the evolved Kelpiens had been the predators.

Sunad and his group, in this analogy, are the equivalent of the Ba’ul in the Discovery episode, while John Doe is more or less the equivalent of Saru, minus the whole “becomes a belligerent jerk every 10 minutes” thing. They are afraid of the truth and they’ll go to any lengths to stop their evolution from coming to pass… but there’s nothing to be done about it, because such changes are inevitable, just as it was for the Kelpiens.

Outside of the John Doe plot, there’s a number of things about this episode that I find quite interesting. This is the first time in several weeks that Gates McFadden has had an episode with her as the focus character, and unlike “The High Ground,” we get to see her be a doctor over the course of a storyline that unfolds over several weeks. As Darren Mooney notes in his review of the episode, “This creates a sense that this what happens between all the big missions featuring the Enterprise, a glimpse at business as usual.”

Then there’s the unexpected religious angle, where John Doe is taken as an extended metaphor for Jesus Christ. To quote Mooney again: “The episode doesn’t hesitate to cast John Doe as space!Jesus. “He apparently has the power to heal injuries with a simple touch,” Picard proclaims. “And even to reverse death itself.” Doe dresses in white as soon as he is recovered from his injuries. Even his polite rebuke of Beverly’s advances feels like a shout out to the fascination with the relationship between Jesus Christ and Mary Magdalene that was the fixation of so much pop culture discussion in the wake of The Last Temptation of the Christ.”

And like Jesus, John Doe experiences hatred and fear from the other Zalkonians, as we’ve noted already. In Mooney’s reading, “Sunad feels like a rather aggressive commentary on the more extreme elements of the religious right – those very vocal radical religious organisations that seem to have very little time for values like tolerance or temperance or compassion. As such, John is cast simultaneous as a religious figure and as the victim of religious persecution.”

Remember that this episode went out in 1990, over 20 years after evangelical Christians successfully merged with the Republican Party to create a new version of the GOP that was nominally Christian in nature, but regularly preached “values” that were the polar opposite of everything Jesus stood for and talked about during his lifetime, and whose noxiousness has only increased in the decades since this episode originally aired.

Right-wing Christianity, like other forms of authoritarianism, exists on the premise that there must always be an Other for the “majority” to oppress – anyone who is visibly different from the perceived norm is a sin against God and must be treated as an enemy – this is how you get to, say, known Christian nationalist Pete Hegseth deciding to significantly curtail the number of faith codes used by the US military’s chaplain corps from an inclusive list (created during the first Trump administration, no less) to an exclusive one, where Christian denominations make up the majority… and even then, some get ignored.

In Mooney’s reading, John Doe is plainly fleeing discrimination for something – he notes that writer René Echevarria, who also wrote “The Offspring,” has a habit of including very heavily veiled LGBT allegories into his Trek work, and the episode makes explicit the plot point that Doe’s mere existence is offensive to the Zalkonians, similar to how right-wing Christians enjoy painting the existence of transgender people as a crime against their God. (The episode is called “Transfigurations” and centers around a character undergoing a transition into a new form! Reading trans themes into this is not hard!)

Is it a perfect comparison? No, because Doe completes his transformation and disappears, never to be seen again. But it’s still interesting all the same: Both in the culturally conservative early 1990s and in the 2020s, when cultural liberalism is being actively strangled by a resurgent Christian right, René Echevarria’s script feels like a necessary reminder of everything that Star Trek should stand for in such bleak times.

It’s easy for people to get hung up on TNG’s “preachiness” and ignore the content of the lessons being taught in favor of obsessing on the method of delivery. But I would suggest that both then and now, sometimes being blunt is the only way to make sure your message can be heard. Trek at its best has always stood as a mirror for our contemporary times, and while I wish I could say that the message of this particular episode has become dated, it really hasn’t.

To quote a media critic I used to like: If the secret of alchemy is material social progress, what is it called when a society actively regresses instead?

Putrefaction.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑