Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Rosa

From the beginning of his time as showrunner of Doctor Who, Chris Chibnall made an obvious effort to increase diversity in front of and behind the camera: two of his three seasons in charge have a regular cast split evenly between white actors (Bradley Walsh and Jodie Whittaker) and actors of color (Mandip Gill and Tosin Cole); Malorie Blackman, Vinay Patel, and Charlene James were all the first writers of color to work on the show; and Mark Tonderai was the first non-white director since Waris Hussein all the way back in 1963. These are unambiguously good moves and deserve all the praise they’ve been given.

‘Rosa’, as a piece of television, remains one of the strongest Doctor Who stories in its era and one of the most daring. As I wrote in my original review from 2018, “Having Ryan get attacked, face repeated racist comments throughout the episode, and have an uninterrupted conversation with Yaz about what it’s like to be a person of color in the UK in 2018 are all things a white writer couldn’t have managed.”

And I stand by that statement. You can feel Blackman, as all writers do, putting a bit of herself into the words of Yaz and Ryan, and it’s powerful stuff. Equally powerful is the climactic scene in which the Doctor and Graham are actively forced by the narrative to remain seated. As white people, both of them benefit from the privilege that comes with that, and they know it. They aren’t happy about it, of course, but they still benefit. The narrative refuses to let the Doctor, a white woman, be the hero. She has to sit there, on that bus, and be complicit.

I will admit, I am reluctant to engage in substantive criticism of this episode’s handling of race for one very simple reason: in real life, I am white as fuck. This episode gives voice to a group of people who, shamefully, are rarely heard in mainstream science fiction television, especially historically white Doctor Who, and I am not comfortable with critiquing a story by a person of color about another person of color. It is simply Not My Lane.

What I can do, however, is critique the guy on the other side of the writing credit. Because while the episode’s handling of race and racism is superb, other aspects of the story’s politics are more muddled, and I feel Chibnall himself is the primary reason.

I came across a phrase the other day that I feel perfectly describes this era’s problem with diversity and inclusion: The Aesthetics of Representation. That comes from an article by Ritesh Babu, in which they describe their problems with how the X-Men character of Trinary is portrayed in recent comic books. Babu explains that the character of Trinary, who doesn’t even get a name of her own, is not actually a true representation of a character from India. No work is done to make her feel like a real person; she is the Indian Character, written by a white person for a primarily white readership. To quote them directly:

But there is no actual meaningful representation happening in the pages of Red, or the books that pick up on it and Trinary afterwards, all written by White writers. No, what’s happening, and what we’re being presented with is The Aesthetics Of Representation. It’s not actually about authenticity, about putting in the work, about really thinking stuff through, about having sensitivity readers or consultation, it’s not about getting it right. What it is about is a lot of people think and believe it is meaningful, honest representation. But it isn’t.

Trinary isn’t us. Trinary isn’t my friends. She isn’t me.

Trinary doesn’t even have a name.

Trinary is explicitly how White people see us.

Trinary doesn’t need a name, and her codename/role is enough, because she is Tech Support: The Character. She is a stereotype dressed up as meaningful progress or truth, when there’s nothing but an empty shell of assumptions inside. She is a construct made in our image, that depicts how they view us, as they pat each other on the back for representation, diversity, and progress.

She is The White Lens upon my people made manifest. A construct to represent only their vision of us, but not actually us.

Ritesh Babu, ‘Trinity and the Aesthetics of Representation,’ Comics XF

That is this era in a nutshell, right here. Chibnall puts more work into defining Graham than any other character in the main cast, including the Doctor, because Graham is just like him: a straight, cisgender, middle-aged white man from northern England. That in and of itself is not an inherently bad thing. Steven Moffat does it all the time in his various TV series, up to and including his last three seasons on Doctor Who, and my ongoing run of Thirteenth Doctor fics have a companion that is literally me but with a different name.

The problem is that Graham’s existence and Chibnall’s obvious comfort in writing for him versus the other three credited regulars leads to uncomfortable aftereffects. Ryan’s grandmother is the one who gets killed in ‘The Woman Who Fell to Earth.’ Ryan’s known her all his life and was raised by her, yet Graham’s the one with the emotional character arc. Her death is framed primarily as his loss. He gets the big goodbye scene in ‘It Takes You Away’; all Ryan gets is a half-baked “arc” about calling Graham his grandfather and then, in ‘Resolution’, an even more half-baked “arc” about reconciling with his absent father which dives into a completely different set of racial stereotypes regarding Black people.

Ryan, in other words, is absolutely generic. Even his dyspraxia, which we’re told is a big problem for him, is only sporadically mentioned after ‘Woman’ and sometimes forgotten about altogether. It bears no impact on the plot of any story and, like Ryan himself, only seems there to check a box. It’s the Aesthetics of Representation, plain and simple.

Chris Chibnall, I’ve noticed, is a very methodical screenwriter. He approaches writing a script like he’s building a piece of furniture. His characters exist to fill particular roles: a Black character, a South Asian character, an older white character who makes witty asides. Their jobs are described like character traits: Ryan works in a warehouse, Yaz is a cop, Graham’s a retired bus driver. They take turns spouting Lucasian dialogue. They don’t feel like real people as Davies’ and Moffat’s companions did; they feel like script components. The Doctor is a wooden frame, Ryan and Yaz are nails, Graham is the upholstery. They’re defined just enough so they can fill their role and not at all beyond that.

Admittedly, that approach to character design is something that’s existed for the majority of the show’s life. Characters like Ian, Barbara, Jo, and Sarah Jane are well remembered primarily for how much work William Russell, Jacqueline Hill, Katy Manning, and Elisabeth Sladen each put in to defining those roles beyond what the script called for. But in the new series, which thrives on character development, a stripped back approach like the one Chibnall’s been taking sticks out like a sore thumb.

Alongside ‘Woman,’ ‘Rosa’ is a rare episode where Ryan and Yaz actually feel like people rather than script mechanics. Surprise, it’s co-written by someone who understands how to make characters feel real and who brings her own experiences of being a Black person in the white supremacist society of contemporary Great Britain into a story about the white supremacist society of 1950s Alabama. Chris Chibnall doesn’t know how to write a non-white person, so he doesn’t really try.

One person who does try is Sarah Dollard, writer of ‘Thin Ice’ from Series 10 in 2017. Her story is set in England during the last of the Great Frost Fairs. And until ‘Rosa’ arrived, it was by some distance the best handling of race relations in the history of the series. Although that isn’t saying much considering ‘The Talons of Weng-Chiang’ was not only allowed to exist but is still considered to be a good story by large parts of the fandom instead of what it actually is: a racist pile of steaming hot garbage that should have never been made.

But I digress. While ‘Thin Ice’ is not exactly about race to the extent that ‘Rosa’ is, it is still a crucial element of the story, since the Doctor is traveling with a Black woman, Bill Potts. The story’s most well-remembered scene has the Twelfth Doctor and Bill visit the house of a noble, Lord Sutcliffe:

SUTCLIFFE: Doctor Disco, from the Fairford Club! Obviously, one aspires to membership, but to actually be considered for—

(Sees Bill.) 

SUTCLIFFE: Who, who let this creature in here? On your feet, girl, in the presence of your betters!

(The Doctor taps Sutcliffe on the shoulder then punches him on jaw very, very hard.) 

DOCTOR: He’s human. Thirty one years of age. Low on iron. 

BILL: Yeah, that was pretty convincing racism for an extra-terrestrial. 

DOCTOR: My thoughts exactly. 

‘Thin Ice,’ wr. Sarah Dollard, Doctor Who Series 10

I simply can’t see the Thirteenth Doctor doing something like that. Half the reason is because of her gender: a woman punching a man, even a racist one, would play very differently than a man punching another man. This is probably why her confrontations with Krasko don’t really go beyond verbal ones.

The other reason is ideological: the bulk of ‘Rosa’ is spent with the TARDIS crew working feverishly to ensure the show’s historical record matches what we all learned in grade school. In isolation, this is a sensible move, since it seemed in 2018 as if Chibnall was aiming to move the show back to some version of Sydney Newman’s original intention for the series: an educational program about science and history. Having Rosa Parks fight alien Zogs from the planet Zog would be in poor taste [ED: their names are Zig and Zag, and they’re not evil, they’re just little rascals]. (There is never actually a scene where Rosa interacts with Krasko; the only alien she meets is the Doctor.)

But taken together with what this Doctor does in other stories, the conflict in ‘Rosa’ begins to take on an uglier meaning. In the very next story, she lets a Trump analogue wander offscreen after he murders a spider, and then does it again when he returns in ‘Revolution of the Daleks.’ ‘Kerblam!’ infamously ends with her declaring the system, meaning both the robots that run the place and, apparently, capitalism in general, are not the problem – it’s the extremists who are the problem. She sics Nazis on a South Asian Master in ‘Spyfall,’ then brings in Davies-era Daleks to defeat their iPhone-esque human knockoffs so she can then swoop in and “save” Earth from getting caught in the crossfire she put it in.

Add in the Doctor’s actions to ensure history goes as it’s supposed to during ‘Rosa,’ and it’s clear that this is not a Doctor who is even remotely capable of tearing down oppressive systems. This Doctor is a defender of the status quo. Her grand pronouncement about “sorting out fair play throughout the universe” felt centrist to me at the time. But after three years, twenty-two episodes, and two hugely important elections in America and Britain, I’ve come to realize that it’s only as centrist as Keir Starmer’s Labour party or Joe Biden’s Democratic Party: not at all. This is a conservative show hiding its true ideals behind a smokescreen of vaguely leftist trappings like a diverse cast and crew.

And all conservatism gets you in this day and age is fascism. And to talk about fascism in Doctor Who, we have to talk about Daleks. Made in 1988, ‘Remembrance of the Daleks’ is the first story of the classic series’ penultimate season and is well-remembered for, among other things, the Doctor tricking Davros into destroying Skaro, the revelation that one of the reasons the Doctor went to Earth in November 1963 was to hide the Hand of Omega, Ace annihilating a Dalek with a baseball bat, and, most importantly for our discussion, Daleks not being the only fascists in town.

In the course of the story, the Doctor and Ace meet up with the Intrusion Counter-Measures Group, a kind of UNIT forerunner. In their midst is Mike Smith, a seemingly ordinary sergeant whom Ace is briefly attracted to… except his mom’s bed and breakfast has a NO COLOUREDS sign in the window, and Mike himself is an out-and-out neo-Nazi. The story’s novelization has him meet George Ratcliffe (another fascist) as a kid, and by 1963, he’s a full-fledged member of Ratcliffe’s Association group and allied with the Imperial Dalek squadron. Sure, Mike and Radcliffe were fictional, but the ideology they were a part of is very real.

At this point, the reader is probably wondering, “How could there have been Nazis in Britain during the Sixties? World War II was still pretty recent!” Yeah, it was, but here’s the thing about Nazism: it’s always going to sound good to someone. I mean geez, look at the way Mike phrases it when he tries to explain himself to a very angry Ace: “I never really wanted to hurt anybody. It’s just you have to protect your own, keep the outsiders out just that your own people can have a fair chance.”

Rhetoric like that should sound very familiar to my fellow Americans, since it was being spewed from the mouth of Donald Trump before, during, and well after he won the presidential election in 2016. It’s not accidental that the KKK and various contemporary American neo-Nazi groups all loved his campaign and enthusiastically supported him as President. And just because he’s gone doesn’t mean the movement he inspired is dead. The Republican party in general has gone full fascist. Name an ‘outsider’; chances are they’ve done something to hurt them, and if they haven’t yet, they will soon.

Here’s the thing about living in an authoritarian nation-state: if you’re not part of the ruling club, you’re considered an outsider, and that means you’re going to get hurt. Or killed. Or both. The day ‘Rosa’ aired, The New York Times revealedTrump’s regime was aiming to narrowly define gender “as a biological, immutable condition determined by genitalia at birth,” allowing the government to take from us those rights that Thomas Jefferson (a slaveowner) described as “inalienable” when he wrote the Declaration of Independence: life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Trump was bad enough, but I have no doubt in my mind that the next Republican president will probably be even worse. (President Hawley, anyone?)

Which brings me back to ‘Rosa’ and the conservatism inherent in its era. Yes, Rosa is a Doctor Who story unlike any other: it explores racism against people of color without sugarcoating it or hiding it behind allegory. The non-white regulars are in very real danger during the story’s events. Of particular note is the scene where the Doctor and Graham confront a Birmingham cop while Yaz and Ryan are just outside hiding. It forces the Doctor to be complicit in a historical atrocity, and Jodie Whittaker acquits herself spectacularly. Anyone arguing she’s miscast really needs to take a look at the smoldering fury on her face during the bus scenes. But the conservatism I mentioned earlier affects it too.

Krasko repeatedly refers to Rosa’s protest as the first domino that brought about the successes of the civil rights movement, something the Doctor doesn’t correct him on. If anything, she agrees with him, making the claim that if Team TARDIS doesn’t ensure everything happens as it does in our history, the entire movement would never have happened. That might have been the case had the show decided to tackle Claudette Colvin, but not here. The scene where Ryan meets Fred Gray and Martin Luther King Jr was supposed to mention Colvin, who had also been arrested for refusing to give up her seat on a bus to a white person, but that dialogue was cut for time. Ironic, since Colvin’s case is almost never discussed either. (Said the real Fred Gray in 2005, “If there had been no Claudette Colvin, there would have been no Rosa Parks. And if there had been no Rosa Parks, the world might never have been introduced to Martin Luther King Jr.”) So, if Rosa Parks didn’t get on that particular bus on that particular night, then details might have changed, but the overall story would’ve been broadly similar to real life.

And then the story ends not with Rosa being taken away in handcuffs but with the Doctor and friends heading back to their police box so she can show them a fucking space rock with Rosa’s name on it. Which, aside from cheapening the preceding 47 minutes of television, does jack fucking shit to address the realities of what it’s like to be Black in America today. Black people of all genders continue to be murdered by police. Republicans across the country are passing bills in state legislatures explicitly designed to restrict voting rights so they can’t vote. They continue to face fear and suspicion and continue to be treated like second-class citizens. Yes, the gains made during the civil rights movement are real and worth celebrating, but they’re also being eroded before our very eyes.

I talked earlier about the Trump administration’s actions against transgender people. Those actions hurt all of us, Black, white, and beyond. Republicans around the US have been busy passing bills banning trans kids from school sports and medical care, Missouri (my home state) had NINE of the fucking things get introduced this year, and the only reason none of them passed was because the fucking clock ran out on the session!

Tiny actions have their place, I’m not denying that, but you know what really gets the wheels moving?! When the fucking people in power – and in this case, I’m referring to the cisgender white people in Congress – get off their fucking pasty asses and decide to do something decent for a change and help the people who can’t help themselves because we’re not in power!

Quick example: per Axios, twenty states have introduced bills criminalizing gender-affirming care for trans kids, and two states have passed such bills: Arkansas in April (the governor vetoed it but the legislature overrode that) and Tennessee on May 19th. I’m writing this on the 21st. THAT WAS TWO MOTHERFUCKING DAYS AGO. TWO.

And the feds? They’ve done jack fucking shit. Oh, don’t get me wrong: Congress has been trying to pass the Equality Act, which would render such state-level bills null and void. Except that bill in its current configuration has been around since 2015 and has yet to be taken up by the Senate, partly because of Mitch McConnell being the world’s biggest jackass and partly because, thanks to Democrats having only nominal control of Congress, they’d have to get 10 Republicans on board to pass it since non-budget related bills can be blocked via the Jim Crow filibuster, as Cori Bush calls it. And until someone pulls Joe Manchin’s head out of his own ass and gets him to vote to kill the damn thing, trans kids will continue to have a target painted on their backs. (God help us all when the GOP are back in power.)

All of this is to say that Chris Chibnall can take his cutesy fallacies about tiny actions leading to bigger things and shove them where the sun don’t shine. I don’t expect Doctor Who to magically come up with the solution to systemic racism, transphobia, or creeping authoritarianism in alleged democratic nations, but I damn well expect it to try a little bit harder than talking about a fucking space rock.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑