‘Arachnids in the UK’ is a story that I kind of liked upon transmission, but I’ve soured on it significantly in the three years since. I was never, for example, overly fond of the idea of a Trump analogue played for comedy, let alone one who is allowed to walk off-screen and face zero consequences whatsoever for his crimes. It’s bad enough when it happens in real life; to have it happen in fiction is just depressing.
What it isn’t, however, is surprising. A recurring theme of this era is that it’s very much politically centrist; yes, we have a vaguely left-wing emphasis on Diversity And Inclusion, but the actual content of the stories leans more to the right than most people seem to realize, and in a time where The Right is essentially synonymous with authoritarian autocracies, that leads to some deeply unfortunate subtexts.
So, ‘Arachnids in the UK’: I want to look at this story’s flaws from two different directions: the Doctor and how she’s portrayed in the story and the story’s conception of wealth as personified by Jack Robertson, Chris Noth’s weird anti-Trump presumably-Republican politician who’s also a Trump clone.
I’ll start with gender: in September 2018, news broke that the scripts for the upcoming eleventh season of the revival had originally been written for a male Doctor, as had been the precedent. The writing staff for that season, it seemed, hadn’t been told about the Doctor’s gender change until Jodie Whittaker was officially unveiled as the next Doctor in 2017.
This makes a certain amount of sense: a change as significant as this is about on par with the original transition from Hartnell to Troughton in 1966, so it’s understandable that Chris Chibnall wanted to tread cautiously. In the immediate aftermath of the announcement, Jodie herself even felt compelled to address any unspoken fears or uncertainties in a statement to the press:
I want to tell the fans not to be scared by my gender. Because this is a really exciting time, and Doctor Who represents everything that’s exciting about change. The fans have lived through so many changes, and this is only a new, different one, not a fearful one.
Any trans person will tell you that coming out to someone for the first time usually winds up including some similar assurance. Regeneration as a process can already be taken as a sci-fi metaphor for our transitions, since when regenerating around an established companion, the new Doctor has usually been careful to promise them that they are still the same person inside despite the change in appearance.
Of course, not all regenerations, and not all coming-outs, go smoothly. Some companions react with shock or horror to the change, and some parents or other family have done likewise to their trans loved ones, my own included. In several more cases, parents have even reacted with anger, claiming that their child will always be the gender assigned to them at birth for one reason or another.
So again, having been through a disastrous coming-out myself, I can understand Chris Chibnall’s desire to play it safe. Making it clear to viewers that the Doctor’s new gender changed nothing at the core of the character’s ethos was sound. The Doctor is still a hero, new pronouns aside.
And while the majority of the fandom was overjoyed at the casting news (Colin Baker, memorably, was the first of the former Doctors Who to react to the news, and he was very enthusiastic) there were other people who loudly and vehemently protested against the change. The good news is, such people are a minority in the fandom and the show has surely steered clear of even the faintest whiff of pandering to the right, hasn’t it? And Jodie’s casting is a clear win for feminists everywhere of all stripes, right? Nothing has gone wrong! Right?!
Well, not exactly. Because, while I’ll laud Chibnall for pushing the show forward, I don’t believe Whittaker’s casting is as much of a win for feminism and gender equality as it initially appears. And when I say that, please understand I’m not trying to say that the act of casting a woman is not, in itself, a win. Because it very plainly is. Kris Marshall was floated as a potential replacement for Capaldi as late as April 2017, though only according to entirely baseless “sources” from infamous British gossip rag The Mirror. If Chibnall had wanted to play it safe, he would’ve gone with Marshall. Going with Whittaker suggests he has at least some ability to take risks. (That they had worked together on Broadchurch, the show that landed him the Who job in the first place, was certainly a factor in his decision as well.)
No, what sticks in my craw about the Thirteenth Doctor is a concept I touched on in the ‘Rosa’ essay: the aesthetics of representation. That phrase was coined by Ritesh Babu, and it applies as well to gender politics as it does to race. Yes, the Thirteenth Doctor is a woman, and Series 11 does acknowledge that in dialogue, but her gender does not significantly affect the plot of any one episode, nor is any attempt made to reckon with that change. And I think that was a mistake.
Because here’s the thing: women, cisgender and trans, experience the world differently than men do. Making the Doctor a woman could have been a good time to interrogate the show’s biases from within, to help it grow and change into something better, but instead we get an ineffectual center-right girlboss who shops at Amazon and has no qualms about calling in the genocidal fascist cops if it means “saving the day.” Hardly feminist at all in my view.
That previous sentence is worth unpacking a bit; what do I mean when I say “feminist”? I’m glad you asked! Very basically, I support the rights of women and femme-aligned non-binary people in society; we all deserve to be paid equally for performing the same work as men, we deserve to have an equal voice in government, we deserve to have our voices and ideas heard and taken on their own merits rather than dismissed because of our gender. I believe that transgender women are women and that we have just as much right to the above as cisgender women do.
So what about my characterization of the Thirteenth Doctor as a girlboss? That relates to where I stand on economics: I’m not a capitalist, I’m a socialist. I believe that capitalism, since it relies on placing a particular group of people above another group, reinforces and exacerbates the tensions created by the patriarchy that feminism is fighting against. Human society tends to elevate men and exclude women, so in capitalist societies like the United States, that leads to things like only 7% of Fortune 500 CEOs being women.
The Thirteenth Doctor, as we’ll explore when we get to ‘Kerblam!’, is a staunch capitalist. Her response to the CEO anecdote would be “MORE WOMEN SHOULD BE CEOs!” and not “Why do we even have privately held companies in the fucking first place?” Thank goodness she wasn’t in ‘The Happiness Patrol’, because her solution to Helen A’s dictatorship would be to spirit her away to some other planet in the hopes that she might be less fashy there.
All of this, in my view, is a betrayal of everything the character of the Doctor has stood for since approximately ‘The Dalek Invasion of Earth.’ The Doctor should always be the person working to tear down unjust systems, not fighting to keep them afloat. In ‘Arachnids,’ she entirely fails to do anything at all to stop Robertson from wandering off to go run for president. And then she does it again in ‘Revolution of the Daleks.’ Why does she do this? Who knows. Maybe she only cares about fascists when she can use them to “save the day.”
So – starting from the assumption that, through no fault of Jodie Whittaker, the Thirteenth Doctor is entirely unsuited for her historical role as the anarchist rebel, who do we have in the show’s past who can play that role instead while still respecting the obvious step forward in regard to the character’s gender?
Let’s start, perhaps, with the most obvious forerunner to Thirteen: Clara Oswald. Once called the Impossible Girl, she was the woman who dived into the Doctor’s timestream to save them from the machinations of the Great Intelligence and was forever changed as a result. She became increasingly Doctor-like throughout Series 8 and 9, culminating in the closing scenes of ‘Hell Bent,’ where she steals a TARDIS with a broken chameleon circuit from Gallifrey and goes to travel the universe (sure, she’s dead, but death is for other people).
There was, of course, a lot of pushback from certain corners of the fandom regarding this move. This particular group of fans loudly complained about the show becoming ‘Clara Who,’ deriding former head writer Steven Moffat for having the absolute audacity to begin breaking down and repairing the show’s demonstrably unhealthy gender dynamics. In the minds of these people, a woman’s place is in the Security Kitchen.
First in the list of stories those people hate is ‘Flatline,’ a 2014 episode from Series 8 (fittingly, it aired October 18th, the day after I turned 20). In the story, Clara is tasked with becoming a substitute Doctor while the definite article is stuck in a shrinking TARDIS. That would be difficult enough without the strange two-dimensional beings murdering people.
Aside from having a truly brilliant idea for a monster design (it’s the kind of thing the Scribble Creature from ‘Fear Her’ wishes it could be), it’s also a brilliant turn for Clara, and Jenna Coleman by extension, as she gets to carry the sonic and psychic paper. She even gets a companion and introduces herself to him as the Doctor… but Rigsy can call her Clara.
By this point in her development as a character, Clara’s known the Doctor in all his regenerations, so she knows exactly how to emulate him in order to get herself into the plot. She knows how to poke around and ask questions other people wouldn’t think to ask, how to get people to run when she tells them, and, of course, she knows about Rule One: the Doctor lies. She lies to Danny about why she’s not at lunch, lies to the Doctor about Danny, lies to Rigsy and the other community service workers so they’ll follow her and have a better chance at survival than they would otherwise.
But none of that is what makes Clara an excellent Doctor. She gets two key scenes in relatively quick succession toward the end of the story. Rigsy hijacks a train intending to sacrifice himself to buy Clara time so she can stop the Boneless, but Clara doesn’t let him. Instead, she throws a hairband over a switch (rendering his presence aboard moot) and points out how pointless his sacrifice is:
“And I really like that hairband, but I suppose I’ll just take it, will I? And every time I look at it, I’ll remember the hero who died to save it. Come on. You’re not getting off that lightly. There’s work that needs doing.”
The subtext is obvious: ‘We can only get through this if you’re here to help us.’
And true enough, Rigsy’s presence is key to the next scene, wherein Clara comes up with an idea to charge the TARDIS back up and bring the Doctor back into the fight. She has Rigsy paint a door on the back of a poster hung on a wall, knowing that the Boneless will try and restore it to three dimensions, and hides the shrunken TARDIS behind it. It’s a brilliant plan on her part, based as it is on sound deductive reasoning. Small wonder the Doctor calls her exceptional! (And, it bears pointing out that this is the exact kind of trick that you see in Looney Tunes shorts with Wile E. Coyote and the Roadrunner. And it works!)
All of this stands in marked contrast with what Chibnall has the Doctor do in ‘Arachnids.’ Thirteen is a very different Doctor from both Twelve and Clara. Unlike either of them, at no point does she use an enemy’s power against them to save the day. Instead, her “solution” to the spider problem is to lock the spiders in a room and starve them, a decidedly un-Doctorish move that Steven Moffat spent the entire climax of ‘The Beast Below’ deconstructing.
She’s also very passive; at no point does she lift a finger to stop Robertson from shooting the mother spider. All she does is scold him for firing Yaz’s mom and glare at him as he walks off-screen. And what’s more, the narrative also never critiques her choices, unlike in ‘Flatline’ where Twelve constantly made comments regarding Clara’s handling of the situation. His statement of “You were an excellent Doctor, Clara. Goodness had nothing to do with it” suggests he sees in her the flaws he has in himself.
This new passivity in the face of obvious evil would be a problem even if Kris Marshall had been the Thirteenth Doctor. But making the first true female Doctor passive when the show literally just had a companion who could have served as a model smacks of classic, garden-variety sexism.
Yes, I said it: Chris Chibnall was being sexist when he decided to write the Thirteenth Doctor as an ineffectual centrist with no consistent moral compass and an apparent lack of ability to save the fucking day. Sure, he cast Jodie Whittaker, but he seems pretty profoundly uninterested in letting her be the Doctor at all, never mind in the way that Clara was. And ‘Arachnids’ was the point at which this became a fact.
Let’s shift gears a little and talk about billionaires and their wealth. ‘Arachnids’ gives us Robertson, a property developer from New York with a worldwide chain of hotels and assorted other properties, with the newest one being built in Sheffield as the episode begins. Later on, it’s revealed the Sheffield hotel is being built atop a toxic waste dump (as are all of his other properties, I think). The episode tells us that’s a Horrible Thing… and then that’s it. Nothing is ever done regarding the toxic waste, beyond that it’s responsible for the spiders mutating.
Back in the ‘Woman Who Fell to Earth’ post, I described the Doctor as being more put out with Tzim-Sha cheating on the hunt than anything at all regarding humans being kidnapped and used as trophies. Here, it’s happening again the Doctor’s anger is focused entirely on the spiders, never mind Robertson’s status as a billionaire also having a role to play. Her line in next season’s ‘Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror,’ in which the title character is described as someone who “should” have been a billionaire, indicates to me that she’s actually perfectly fine with obscenely wealthy people polluting the planet!
What an about-face that is from our third story we’ll be looking at, 1978’s ‘The Pirate Planet.’ Broadcast as part of the classic era’s sixteenth season and written by Douglas Adams, it sees the Doctor and his companion Romana continue their quest for the pieces of the Key to Time. They intend to visit the unpleasant world of Calufrax to go looking for it, but when they get there, they find another planet called Zanak has taken its place.
Zanak, as the Doctor tells us, is a planet-sized economic miracle; the citizenry are all obscenely wealthy, because every so often, the lights change in the sky, and the Captain declares a New Golden Age of Prosperity For All, filling the planet’s mines with new diamonds and rubies and gold and more besides.
However, economics is still economics. According to James Goss’ novelization of that story, this is what happened when the first Golden Age was declared:
When it had first started to rain gold from the skies, it had mostly fallen on the slopes of the mountains and out in the fields. By sheer fluke, not too many people died, but, for some reason, the crops died overnight. Consequently the cities had suddenly been overrun by farmers, staggering under their new-found riches. With nothing else to do, they promptly bought everything in sight. The people who had lived in the city could suddenly no longer afford to, but didn’t really fancy moving. Gradually, things evened out, but by this point the countryside was barren, the cities were overcrowded, and no one could buy any house larger than a shoebox.”
In summary, if everyone in the world is rich, then everyone in the world is poor. The Zanakians have more in common with Rigsy and the rest of the community service workers in ‘Flatline’ than they have with Jack Robertson. And the Captain is their cruel king, content on ruling from atop his mountain-bridge, using his guards to quell any uprisings that may start.
Over the course of four episodes, the Doctor and Romana try to figure out what happened to Calufrax and, in so doing, run right into the economic situation I’ve just described. They eventually discover that the planet is hollow; it hops around from place to place, consuming other planets and mining the minerals contained there before moving on to the next one.
Toward the end of episode three, the Captain is showing the Doctor his very own museum: a series of glass display cases, each containing the remains of a victimized planet, and their exchange is worth reproducing in full:
CAPTAIN: Why doesn’t it? Because the whole system is so perfectly aligned by the most exquisite exercise in gravitational geometry that every system is balanced out within itself. Which is why we can stand next to billions of tons of super- compressed matter and not even be aware of it. With each new planet I acquire, the forces are realigned but the system remains stable.
DOCTOR: Then it’s the most brilliant piece of astro-gravitational engineering I’ve ever seen. The concept is simply staggering. Pointless, but staggering.
CAPTAIN: I’m gratified that you appreciate it.
DOCTOR: Appreciate it? Appreciate it? What, you commit mass destruction and murder on a scale that’s almost inconceivable and you ask me to appreciate it? Just because you happen to have made a brilliantly conceived toy out of the mummified remains of planets!
This scene, right here, is everything I love about the Doctor: he can admire an enormous feat of engineering when he sees it, then turn right around and reject it for the crime against the universe that it is. And of course, Tom Baker’s acting in the scene is glorious; he drops the Doctor’s jovial, silly persona just the once to reveal white-hot, red-faced fury, and it’s magnificent.
Slightly later in the quoted scene, the Doctor asks what it’s all for, and the answer comes a few scenes later: the real villain here isn’t the Captain but Queen Xanxia, believed to be dead but, in reality, attempting to give herself a new body, using the power of planets to do it.
And here we have ‘The Pirate Planet’s answer to Jack Robertson. Just like Earth billionaires, Xanxia is vacuuming up the natural resources of every planet she comes across for her own gain. In early script drafts, the character was intended to be either a proto-Missy or the Master’s daughter, but honestly, I think she’s much better as just a random, evil rich person. Anyway, her plan won’t even work; as the Doctor points out, she’ll just have to keep consuming massive amounts of energy until, eventually, there isn’t anything left to take and she dies anyway.
All of the above was relevant back in the late 1970s, but it’s even more relevant now as climate change ravages our world. Just this year, the western United States has seen seemingly endless wildfires, while Canada and the Pacific Northwest got stuck in a heat dome in July. Our polar ice caps are continuing to melt, storms are getting increasingly destructive, and animals are dying out. Meanwhile, people like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk are building rockets and shooting themselves into outer space. They’ll be able to escape the oncoming ecological catastrophe; they could build themselves a base on the moon if they wanted, or on Mars.
But those of us down here below, human and otherwise? We are expendable. Jack Robertson represents the very worst of humanity, and the Doctor does nothing to stop him. She lets him walk off to run for president at the end of ‘Arachnids’ and then again in ‘Revolution of the Daleks.’
This is where centrism leads. Clara would’ve stopped Robertson. The Doctor as written by Jamie Mathieson or Douglas Adams would have too.
But not Chris Chibnall’s Doctor. The Doctor should always, no matter the gender, stand up to people like Robertson and Trump and defeat them by any means possible. That quality is essential to their character, and if you lose that, then you’re not writing the Doctor anymore.
You’re writing someone else.
Leave a Reply