Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Witchfinders

This week on Adventures in Narrative Substitution, we have a shitload of estrogen: three stories written by two different female writers, one of which features a female Doctor and another of which features an interspecies lesbian relationship that isn’t Vastra and Jenny. Oh, and there’s me, the transfemme enby wolf, putting all three of these stories under loup microscope.

First, let me get something out of the way: Chibnall’s commitment to diversity in as many places as possible is, by some distance, the best part of this era for me. I’m happy that we had Jodie Whittaker and Jo Martin as the Doctor, I’m happy that we had some more non-white companions, I’m happy that Ryan got to leave the TARDIS on his own terms rather than get killed off, I’m happy that we’ve had Black and brown and gay writers on staff, I’m happy that we’ve had female writers and directors. All of this sets an excellent precedent, and if the rumors I’ve heard about Chibnall’s replacement are true, I have little doubt that the next showrunner will build on that foundation, as well they ought to.

But it’s what this era has done with its representation that bothers me. Back in ‘Rosa,’ I made use of Ritesh Babu’s phrase, “aesthetics of representation,” to describe what I felt was the mismatch between what the Chibnall era said it was going to do with regard to its companions of color and what it’s actually done: kill off a Black woman in episode 1 so the middle aged white male companion has something to angst about, then give the Black guy an “arc” where he learns to love his white step-grandfather.

It’s the same story with gender and sexuality. Time and time again, we’ve seen this era profess to be engaged in supportiveness and allyship on the surface level, but when you dig deep, you find it’s actually doing far more harm than good. On the one paw, ‘The Witchfinders’ is the first story in the history of the series to be both written and directed solely by women and star a female Doctor as well as deal with a subject that predominantly affected women in history, which is all great! The Doctor’s recent gender change even affects the plot!

What’s not so great is that the historical event that the Doctor and her friends are visiting are the witch hunts organized by King James I in the late 1500s and early 1600s, a forerunner to the Salem, Massachusetts witch trials of the 1690s (and, incidentally, explored in The Witch Hunters by Steve Lyons, a First Doctor book that ought not to be confused with this story). Just what we need, 50 minutes of women getting to do things that have historically been handled by men on this show, and the first story has lots and lots of women being put through hell. Yay feminism.

After 22 episodes, I’ve detected a pattern or two in this era’s relationship with women: the Doctor went from being a commanding force for good to being an ineffectual, docile figure seemingly unable to get a hang on her ship or her new body even weeks after the regeneration had passed and she’d seemingly settled in. And yes, the show uses its historicals to emphasize important women like Rosa Parks and Ada Lovelace, but Rosa’s story has the TARDIS team work to ensure she’s arrested, and Ada gets her mind wiped at the end of ‘Spyfall”s second episode, once she’s no longer useful to the Doctor.

Really, at some point you start to wonder whether this is representation or exploitation. There’s something rather profoundly fucked up at including women at the table in a substantive way only to then turn around and focus almost exclusively on our pain. Thank the moon goddess we’ve yet to have a trans character in this era, they’d be insufferable. A 50 minute version of The Danish Girl with a store brand Eddie Redmayne as Lili Elbe? I sure hope not.

That’s another aspect of this episode, and the era in general, that bothers me: King James I. When he’s not accusing everyone who so much as looks at him the wrong way of being a witch, he’s very blatantly and awfully lusting after Ryan, whom he calls his “Nubian prince.” It comes off as predatory, which isn’t exactly a good thing to be doing when we’re talking about a figure whose sexuality is up for considerable historical debate to say the least, and that’s before you get to the whole “Let’s write this allegedly gay character as a sexual predator,” which was what happened to actual gay people in the ‘80s and is happening now to transgender people. And yet this is supposed to be our queer rep?

Perhaps I should explain myself a bit: Back in September 2018, Series 11 was just a few weeks off from airing, and executive producers Chris Chibnall and Matt Strevens decided to give an interview regarding their approach to queer rep in the season to come, coming off the back of Series 10, which had Bill Potts, the first Black lesbian companion on the show. Here’s what Strevens said, per Digital Spy:

STREVENS: Since the show came back in 2005, I think Doctor Who has been amazing at blurring the edges of sexuality and being quite genderfluid about the characters and relationships.” […] “I’m not going to say if any of our characters are or are not at this point. But it is part, I think, of the DNA that Russell re-imbued into the show… “There will be characters from across the spectrum.

So, okay, there’s a lot to unpack there, as John Mulaney might say. Matt Strevens clearly doesn’t know what the word genderfluid means with respect to sexuality; it certainly has nothing to do with relationships. Genderfluid – for your benefit, Matt – is a word which here means someone who does not identify as having a fixed gender. There are many words to describe someone who has relationships with people of many different genders, but “genderfluid” is not one of them.

And then there’s “There will be characters from across the spectrum.” Sure, okay, maybe. You’ve at least got some gay women and at least one or two gay men in there, except that… TWO OF THOSE FOUR PEOPLE EITHER DIED OR HAD DEAD PARTNERS, THE THIRD ONE WAS MADE GAY IN FUCKING POST-PRODUCTION, AND KING JAMES I WAS WRITTEN LIKE A SEXUAL PREDATOR! WHAT THE FUCK WERE YOU THINKING?! WEREYOU THINKING?! BECAUSE THE EVIDENCE SO FAR SUGGESTS THAT YOU WEREN’T!

Anyway, that’s pretty much this era’s problem with queer rep in a nutshell: to the extent that gay and lesbian characters are present, they’re basically cannon fodder or subject to such historical debate that you can’t really be sure whether he qualifies as representation or not. Sure, King James I may have been gay, but so could’ve James Buchanan, the only American president to have been a bachelor. Both of them are dead, so we can’t really ask them what their sexuality is, and if we could, they likely wouldn’t have a clue as to what the hell we were talking about (and James would probably suspect us of being witches or something).

In fairness, Series 12 does improve on this abysmal record at least a little bit. The episode ‘Praxeus’ is centered around a gay couple and they both make it to the end credits alive, but at various points, both of them were at least teased to die, as is traditional with gay characters at this point. And yes, Jack Harkness turned up again, but John Barrowman is a serial sexual harasser and a general piece of human trash, so I’m not counting him as good rep either. At least James I had Alan Cumming devouring the scenery.

CHIBNALL: There are LGBT characters within the show. Obviously, last year we had Bill in the show. [But] in terms of sexuality, it’s often not necessarily a thing you go into in a Doctor Who story.

Well, no, Chris. That would be because the show has, for most of its lifetime, been written by a succession of heterosexual men like you, and even when queer rep was possible, the time simply wasn’t right for it, so it had to be buried under layers of subtext. So, of course sexuality and gender isn’t necessarily a thing a Doctor Who story concerns itself with; there’s virtually no precedent for it! Establishing that precedent requires someone to try, and I certainly don’t expect him to.

Luckily, I don’t need to worry, because someone else already did. Rona Munro occupies a unique place in Doctor Who lore: In 1989 she had the honor of writing the final story of the show’s original run, ‘Survival,’ only to return in 2017 to write for the Twelfth Doctor in his own final season with ‘The Eaters of Light,’ making her the only classic series writer to return for the revival. And most importantly for our purposes, both stories have far more positive depictions of queer women than anything the Chibnall era’s been capable of delivering.

Let’s start with ‘Survival.’ In that story, the Seventh Doctor takes his companion Ace home to Perivale, where there have been strange disappearances. Near the end of the first episode, Ace encounters the reason for those disappearances: a species of anthropomorphic cheetahs on horseback have been kidnapping the humans and taking them back to their own planet, whereupon they slowly begin to transform into cats themselves.

Naturally, Ace swiftly gets kidnapped and, during the second episode, forms a friendship with one of the cheetahs, Karra. It’s hard to get across in text, but if you watch the story, there is a lot of lesbian subtext between their interactions, something that was entirely intentional on Munro’s part. The McCoy seasons tend to be quite popular among the queer contingent of Who fandom, not only for things like Ace and her continuing series of love interests across gender and species but also for things like ‘The Happiness Patrol,’ a story that’s positively dripping with 80s camp. And all this from a time when being gay was illegal!

Let’s jump forward in time, then, to 2017, and the world is a very different place. Section 28, which prohibited the “promotion of homosexuality” in British law, has long since been repealed; the US Supreme Court made marriage equality the law of the land; and there are more out gay, lesbian, and trans characters on TV than ever before! And best of all, Doctor Who now has an openly lesbian companion in the form of Bill Potts, a woman who is, in my estimation, the modern era’s version of Ace on the representation front.

The Eaters of Light attempts to provide a Doctor Who answer to two questions: why do crows caw, and what happened to the ninth Roman legion, said to disappear in Scotland during the second century. Aside from being a well-researched tale based on Scottish history with very obvious classic series vibes, it’s also notable for this exchange between Bill and the Romans she’s surrounded with, as what once was subtext becomes text:

BILL: Ah. Lucius, er. Right, listen. There’s er something I should explain.

LUCIUS: What?

B: This is probably just a really difficult idea. I don’t like men, that way.

L: What, not ever?

B: Nah. Not ever. Only women.

L: Oh. All right. Yeah, I got it. You’re like Vitus, then.

B: What?

L: He only likes men.

VITUS: Some men. Better looking men than you, Lucius.

L: I don’t think it’s narrow-minded. I think it’s fine. You know what you like.

B: And you like both?

L: I’m just ordinary. You know, I like men and women.

B: Ha! Well, isn’t this all very modern.

That right there is how you do queer rep: just a simple conversation between a lesbian, a gay guy, and a bi guy! Sure, one of them’s from contemporary Britain and the other two are from Ancient Rome, but does that really matter? It’s good wholesome representation, and that’s what counts. It really shouldn’t be too hard.

And yet here I am, having just spent the past two thousand words complaining about the current era’s issues with women and minorities. I couldn’t begin to guess why they think killing off most of your gay characters, pretending to kill off two more, and then hiring back someone with a known history of sexual assault allegations to play the greatest hits of 2007 counts as decent representation, but here we are.

I can tell you one thing though: I do not feel seen. I do not appreciate that my gender is being used for G-rated torture porn, I do not like that my status as a queer woman has been turned into cannon fodder to satisfy the people who aren’t watching the show anyway, because they turned off the moment Peter Capaldi’s eyebrows morphed into Jodie Whittaker’s. I feel like I’m being used, and I don’t like that.

Here’s what I do see: I see Doctor Who falling into the same trap of less-than-bare-minimum representation that people laud Disney for doing every other week, with an endless parade of characters who might be perceived as gay if you squint really hard. Meanwhile, that same company recently bought the Blue Sky Animation studio (the company who made the Ice Age series and The Peanuts Movie) and proceeded to cancel all its projects, including Nimona, a film adaptation of a web comic by Noelle Stevenson, a name you might recognize from Netflix’s She-Ra and the Princesses of Power. The movie was 75% complete and, had it been released, would’ve continued Stevenson’s trailblazing efforts at queer rep in children’s media.

But it was not to be, and all because the House of Mouse said no. And when you’re as indescribably huge as the Walt Disney Company, culture tends to mold itself around you.

Who else but Russell T Davies, a guy who might know a couple things about queer rep in television, offered these remarks in a recent interview, per PinkNews:

“Nonetheless, I think huge, cleaning warning bells are ringing as the giants rise up with Netflix and Disney Plus especially,” Davies told the online panel.

He continued: “I think that’s a very great worry. Loki makes one reference to being bisexual once, and everyone’s like, ‘Oh my god, it’s like a pansexual show.’

“It’s like one word. He said the word ‘prince’, and we’re meant to go, ‘Thank you, Disney! Aren’t you marvellous?’

“It’s a ridiculous, craven, feeble gesture towards the vital politics and the stories that should be told.”

Davies added that his “worry” about the future of LGBT+ stories on TV is that streaming services will “damn us” with “their condescension in the end”.

Davies is absolutely right. The visibility the queer community pulled off in the 2010s is worth celebrating and always will be, but the problem with greater visibility is that it also makes you a bigger target. Conservative governments and media companies are taking over the world: they don’t want us out and proud but back in the closet with the door locked shut.

I’ve given up hope that Chibnall will ever correct his course; he’s only got nine episodes left. But maybe his successor will.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑