NOTE: The following was written in December 2021 before the New Years special “Eve of the Daleks.” Rather than edit this post, I’ve decided to focus on the Yaz/Doctor shipping thing in the “Eve” post.
To make up for the lack of classic series representation in last week’s post, today I’m rejecting the New Series entirely save for this, the sixth episode of series twelve. There is a school of thought about this story which holds that it is secretly a work of genius because it contains a gay couple who, wait for it… DON’T DIE! WHAT AN ACHIEVEMENT!
This statement is patently ridiculous. Accepting it as true also requires us to accept whatever less-than-bare-minimum “representation” that the Walt Disney Corporation deigns to give us as being great rep too. I mean, yes, Adam and Jake don’t die, but you know what isn’t so great? THAT IT WAS EVER A POSSIBILITY IN THE FIRST PLACE.
I know though that queer rep in Doctor Who, particularly the main TV show, has always had a lot to be desired. The 1980s are no one’s idea of a good time to be queer: in Britain, Section 28 outlawed any “promotion of homosexuality” by local authorities, and then there was the AIDS epidemic, which the Reagan administration refused to do anything about. What rep we had (see: Ace in seasons 25 and 26) had to be shown through subtext, whether through authorial intent or in particular line reads and acting choices from the performers on screen.
The situation improved somewhat by 2005, when Russell T Davies first took control of the show. Coming off the back of his series Queer as Folk, Davies wasted no time in injecting a bit of queer magic into the show textually: at one point in the early sections of Rose, the Doctor speed-reads his way through a gossip magazine and declares, “That won’t last, he’s gay and she’s an alien.” A statement of intent if there ever was one.
Things have changed even more here in the 2020s. Being openly queer and telling queer stories on TV is much more common these days, particularly in children’s television, where shows like Steven Universe and She-Ra and the Princesses of Power display queerness in all its myriad forms so that kids can see themselves reflected on screen.
So given all of this, Chibnall’s decision to pivot 180 degrees from Madame Vastra and Jenny Flint or Bill Potts to killing off gay people on screen and off isn’t just puzzling, it’s infuriating. If he was reluctant to write queer characters positively because he, as a cis-het, isn’t part of the community, I could almost understand… except that his immediate predecessor already wrote one popular lesbian ship, kinda/sorta implied Clara was bisexual, and ended Bill’s run by turning her into a lesbian water goddess so she could run off with Heather. So really, he hasn’t got an excuse.
Getting back to the claim that this episode is superior rep compared to Series 11’s murder-a-thon: admittedly, yes, letting the gay couple live is an objectively better decision compared to not doing that, but I don’t think it’s worthy of praise either. We could’ve had that all last season and instead we got stuck with cannon fodder. Furthermore, Praxeus was written (at least in part) by Pete McTighe, so of course the relationship shown here was portrayed more realistically and sympathetically, McTighe was probably working off of some of his own experiences! That’s what writers do!
If you want good gay rep in a Doctor Who story, then allow me to introduce you to UNIT Dating. This is the second episode in the second Stranded box set, itself an Eighth Doctor audio series from Big Finish wherein the Doctor and his companions Liv and Helen find themselves living in the Doctor’s house on Baker Street in London, with an assortment of interesting boarders, some of whom are queer: Tania Bell is a transgender Torchwood agent, while Ron and Tony are a pair of older gay men.
UNIT Dating focuses on Ron and Tony and the beginning of their relationship, with half of the story set in the 1970s, during the Doctor’s time as UNIT scientific advisor. Ron and Tony first met when they also worked at UNIT, under the Brigadier. The other half of the story is set in 2020, in which Tony’s memories are repeatedly rewritten due to an Ogron struggling to fix a broken time machine. Eventually the problem is solved and the story ends happily with the two of them dancing to a favorite song.
UNIT Dating, both as rep and as a Doctor Who story, is fabulous: the cast are all brilliant (Jon Culshaw’s Brigadier impression is so good you’d swear they’d resurrected Nicholas Courtney circa 1971) and Gill, as a gay man himself, knows how to craft a good romance as well as Pete McTighe does.
Really, the story’s only significant flaw is a question of availability: this isn’t an episode of television that you can stream on iPlayer or HBO Max, or buy for $2.99 on iTunes or Google Play, this is an audio adventure that you can buy through Big Finish directly as a download, where it comes as part of an existing story arc. Yes, it’s a good story and I highly recommend it and the parent series to anyone, but I am also very aware that not everyone has the disposable income to afford dropping $20 on an audio box set on a whim. So while I’d easily recommend this to anyone who wants good queer rep, that recommendation comes with caveats.
On the other paw, it wasn’t like I had much choice. The various Doctor Who books from the Wilderness Years have long since gone out of print, aside from some reprints in the mid-2010s. RTD’s own Damaged Goods, one of his very first Doctor Who stories, contains plenty of gay rep but hasn’t been in print for 25 years. (An audio adaptation did come out, though the rep was toned down a lot.)
And the TV situation… well. I’ve covered that in detail already, but the immediate future isn’t very promising. There are rumors that Thirteen and Yaz might get together at some point during the 2022 specials, and when quizzed on the possibility of a relationship between the two characters, Mandip Gill was vague:
“Obviously I wouldn’t say [if it was happening],” Gill told Radio Times as part of a wider series 13 interview.
“But it could do. Because, you know, they have spent so much time together. That’s what happens to people naturally.” […] “At the same time, it could also head down the route of like it being platonic, because two people are allowed to travel together and not have that relationship.” […] “People have asked about it, people have wanted it. Me and Jodes have a lovely relationship as people, as actors, and our characters have a really, really nice relationship. And I think it’s been written very naturally.”
Now, okay, I’ll admit, I have a different perspective here than Gill does. She’s actually a member of the cast on the show, and I’m just a loudmouthed internet commentator, but come on. First of all, Chris Chibnall appears to be completely incapable of writing human emotions outside of the context of a police procedural, second of all, as happy as I am that Gill and Whittaker have chemistry, it really does not come across on screen. At all. In three series, the one and only time I felt I could see evidence of that chemistry in their work was during The Halloween Apocalypse, before they met up with Dan Lewis. The rest of the time, Yaz has spent most of her scenes being paired up with one or both other members of The Fam while the Doctor is off horsing around with a pair of temporary companions.
Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that the rumors are true and Yaz admits she has a romantic attraction to the Doctor, and the Doctor admits the same, as much as she’s able given that she’s a 2000-and something year old Time Lady. The Thasmin shippers in the fandom would, of course, be overjoyed, news articles would be written about it, Gill, Whittaker, and Chibnall would all be interviewed about it, it would basically be the biggest news the show’s had since Whittaker’s casting. As a sapphic girl myself, would I be happy?
No, I would not. This kind of thing has to be earned, you can’t just casually announce that one of your characters is queer with no buildup and expect everyone to fall in line. Voltron: Legendary Defender pulled that exact stunt in one of its later seasons: Shiro, the team leader, was shown in a flashback to be gay, only they then killed off his partner offscreen. Everyone got pissed, and at the end of the last season, they… largely never mentioned it again outside of a quick shot in the series finale of him getting married. Now, admittedly, the Voltron writers had to be very careful as to not piss off the Dreamworks people, but then, the She-Ra writers worked a lot harder for the queer rep they got, which was a lot. Especially in the last couple seasons.
If Thasmin happens in the specials, it’s going to feel cheap. It’s going to feel calculated to pander to the kinds of people who look at a couple of easily removable lines of dialogue from Loki and say “This is great rep!” It’s really not. If you want good rep in your science fiction, there’s UNIT Dating, or outside of Doctor Who, the third season of Star Trek: Discovery is another good place to go. And I have no doubt that the second era of Russell T Davies, when it starts, will count too.
But not Praxeus. Screw Praxeus.
Leave a Reply