One of the strong points of this era, as I’ve said repeatedly in the past, is the historicals. Most of them have also involved women in some way, tying in with the theme of a female Doctor changing what kinds of stories can be told in Earth’s past: Rosa, Demons of the Punjab, The Witchfinders, even parts of Spyfall get in on the action. Only Tesla stands out as the one traditional Davies-esque celebrity historical, down to the Skithra appearing to be a distant cousin of the Racnoss from The Runaway Bride.
On the flipside of this is a theme I touched on in my Witchfinders post: the exploitation of women, and a focus on female pain and suffering. Rosa Parks was the victim of terrible racism and, as we know, got arrested for the crime of not giving up her seat to a white person. The Witchfinders is all about a wealthy woman using her privilege to smack down other women under the guise of fighting Satan, creating even more suffering for her fellow women in the process, again focusing on female pain rather than survival. (The novelization is a lot better on that subject.)
This season, the knife gets twisted further. Remember Ada Lovelace and Noor Inayat Khan in Spyfall? What parts of the story were explicitly about them and their lives? Answer: nothing whatsoever. It was all about how they could be used by the Doctor to solve the plot of the week, and even some of that gets handled offscreen so the Doctor can exposit about it in tome to end the episode. And to add insult to injury, the Doctor wipes both of their minds after the main action, an act she’s never committed before or since to a historical figure, and was EXPLICITLY REPRIMANDED FOR BY CLARA THREE FUCKING SEASONS AGO, CHIBNALL.
In Haunting, this particular form of the objectification of women stops being subtext and starts being plain old text. Mary Shelley is allegedly the big celebrity guest of the week, but when the Lone Cyberman shows up, the Doctor starts arguing in favor of giving him what he wants because otherwise, Percy will die:
“His thoughts, his words inspire and influence thousands for centuries. If he dies now, who knows what damage that will have on future history? Words matter! One death, one ripple, and history will change in a blink. The future will not be the world you know. The world you came from, the world you were created in won’t exist, so neither will you.”
Mary Shelley doesn’t even get mentioned in that paragraph, she’s just there so she can be inspired to write Frankensteinby being in the same room as Ashad. She contributes absolutely nothing to the plot, this story could’ve been about any random group of people in an old haunted house (god knows Britain has plenty) and the major beats of the episode wouldn’t change.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with the idea of doing a Mary Shelley story with Cybermen in it, but if you’re going to do one, it might help to actually involve her in the freaking plot. This isn’t like The impossible Astronaut where Nixon was just there because he happened to be president at the time, that story would’ve turned out exactly the same if Hubert Humphrey had won instead. Haunting is supposed to be The Shelley Episode, like how The Unquiet Dead was The Dickens Episode. You only get one chance!
And also, why was it necessary to suddenly and awkwardly pivot to being about Percy Shelley instead? Anyone could’ve had the Cyberium, at least if it had been Mary, the story would still have been about her! Mind you, I don’t think there should’ve been Cybermen in this story at all: Ashad contributes nothing to the plot except to be a tease for the season finale, his role could and should have been replaced with some other creepy monster. But they’re here anyway, so I have to work with what I’ve got.
So: Mary Shelley and Cybermen. Is there another way? Funnily enough, yes! This exact combination was explored by Big Finish in 2011, with the story The Silver Turk. It again stars the Eighth Doctor, though at this point in his life he’s still the dashing Romantic of the 1996 TV Movie, and it was written by Marc Platt, author of Ghost Light on TV for the Seventh Doctor and Loup-Garoux for the fifth, again for Big Finish. (See the third Moonlight Side post for more on that.)
The first thing Turk does is the simplest: rather than being a character whom the Doctor goes to meet, she is instead his companion, which means she gets to be involved in a standard Doctor Who plot from that direction. Turk takes place in Austria during the 1870s, and the Doctor and Mary attend a performance of an alleged automaton referred to as “The Silver Turk…” but surprise, it’s a Cyberman.
And before you think this is just a preemptive remake of Nightmare in Silver, it turns out that this is an even better substitution than I imagined: there are two Silver Turks in this, and they both have names! They’re called Gramm and Bremm! And they’re not trying to take over the world or anything, they literally just crashed on Earth and thought it was Mondas. Gramm intends to build a transmitter so he can phone home and tell the other Cybermen where Earth is, with the Doctor’s sonic screwdriver as a key component.
But in my favorite part of the story, Mary freaking Shelley herself breaks the sonic into pieces, rendering it useless and preventing the transmitter from being built. It’s a great moment, and exactly what the TV show should have done. Instead we got morally bankrupt nonsense about letting one goddamn poet live at the expense of billions of lives. Really makes you wonder why I watch this goddamn show.
Another thing that galls me about this episode is another one of the Doctor’s lines from the speech I quoted above: “Sometimes, even I can’t win.” In this episode, the Doctor doesn’t even try to win, she just gives Ashad what he wants and then goes forward in time to try and stop him from causing any damage. This era seems to be fundamentally incapable of letting the Doctor be a hero, and I don’t like it. Even the Davies era, cynical as it often was, still found plenty of opportunity to let the Doctor do his thing.
I wish I could say it gets better. I really do. But that’s not how the story goes.
Leave a Reply