Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Ascension of the Cybermen/The Timeless Children

First of all, let’s just admit something: Ascension is only in the title of this post because it’s a two-part episode, and my usual thing with two-parters is to do them at the same time. (See: Spyfall in this series, and the various Smith-era two-parters in Back to the Eleventh Hour.) But second of all, there is literally no point in doing a separate post for Ascensionbecause it’s an absolute non-entity of a story. As my friend Frezno wrote about it in their first impressions blog, “Ascension Of The Cybermen is a teasing mess that resolves nothing and only raises more questions for 50 minutes.” So given all that, why bother giving it more thought than it deserves? Let’s move on.

The last time we had a season finale set on Gallifrey was Hell Bent, the finale for Series 9. At the time, Steven Moffat was quoted as saying: “If the Doctor has lost his moral compass, if he’s being selfish, if you really, really hacked him off, if you really got him angry and gave him nothing to fight for… what would you end up with? That’s the “hellbent” of the title. An angry, off-the-rails Doctor.”

The end result? The same thing Moffat’s finales always are: a character piece, in this case devoted to explaining why, in exquisite detail, the Doctor and Clara Oswald cannot travel together anymore. The story doesn’t start that way: it opens with the Doctor kicking Rassilon off-planet and taking control of Gallifrey as the new president, but that’s just a means to an end. The real story is about the Doctor and Clara.

That wasn’t enough for some people. Some people wanted MOAR LORE, MOAR GALLEYFRAY! Five years later, that was exactly what they got with The Timeless Children, an episode where the Doctor is captured by the Master and forced to listen to him menacingly give a fucking PowerPoint presentation about “The Timeless Child,” a being from another universe who was orphaned in this one and adopted by a Gallifreyan woman, Tecteun. The child was experimented on, killed and brought back to life, changing faces every time, representing many Earth cultures. Years later, the child grew up and became an officer in the Division, but became disillusioned and escaped. That child’s name?

The Doctor.

That’s right: just having the character be a renegade Time Lord, a being of unimaginable privilege who chose to give all that up in favor of traveling the universe helping out those in need wasn’t enough, Chibnall had to go and make them a Chosen One character in the tradition of Joseph Campbell and his monomyth. And then he had to go and make them a fucking police officer, in offensively stereotypical rural Ireland no less! EVERYTHING THIS MAN FUCKING WRITES TURNS INTO A FUCKING COP SHOW! IT’S ALL HE KNOWS HOW TO FUCKING DO! GO LOOK AT HIS IMDB PAGE! LIFE ON MARS! SPOOKS! LAW & ORDER! TORCHWOOD! BROADCHURCH! AND NOW FUCKING THIS! YOU MIGHT AS WELL CALL IT OFFICER WHO!

But really, we should’ve seen this coming. Remember in The Woman Who Fell to Earth, when the Doctor finally realizes who she’s supposed to be, and when she has to announce what being the Doctor means, she landed on “Sorting out fair play throughout the universe?” I wrote back then that “the Doctor, a character all about breaking the rules, has now become a Space Centrist devoted to the upholding of those rules.”

The Thirteenth Doctor doesn’t tear down corrupt regimes, she defends them. That’s also what police officers do, they enforce the status quo, often violently, and usually at the expense of racial and sexual minorities. Human society is built on upholding a white supremacist patriarchy, and police officers are part of how that happens. They shouldn’t be valorized, they should be torn down and exposed for what they are. When we say “All Cops Are Bastards,” this is what we mean. Even people who want to “make a difference,” like Yaz, are complicit in the suffering of others.

And in explicitly allying the Doctor with the police, Chibnall has chosen a side. Yes, I know, the Doctor later escapes, and yes, the Division are at least portrayed as villains more often than not, but still: he picked a side. And that matters.

Look at the real world. When Michael Brown was shot and killed in his hometown of Ferguson, Missouri in 2014, his murderer Darren Wilson was not charged. Jason Stockley, another St. Louis cop who killed a Black man, was found not guilty. Sure, George Floyd’s murderer, Derek Chauvin, got convicted, but his case is the exception that proves the rule: America is a white supremacist nation, and the legal system will bend over backwards to keep it that way.

So when I return to The Timeless Children and its decision to explicitly tie the Doctor in with the cops via the Ireland flashbacks, it turns my stomach. That’s not what this show should be about. That’s not what this character should be about. Making it happen is a betrayal of everything this character is meant to represent, a betrayal of everything the show’s original writers, David Whitaker especially, worked hard to build. The Doctor isn’t police, that’s just what it says on the box.

Do I believe any of this is intentional? Of course it’s not fucking intentional, this is the same man who put the Master, now a brown man, into a Nazi uniform without thinking about the implications! He never thinks about the implications! He just blunders into these things without meaning to!

Really, the best thing to be said about the Timeless Child “arc” is that it ultimately comes to nothing. The Doctor chooses not to regain her wiped memories, and chances are, the whole thing will be swept under the rug and never mentioned again except for a cheap joke, like “I’m half human on my mother’s side” was for the best part of 25 years.

And as for the whole Chosen One thing, with the Doctor allegedly being from a parallel universe and orphaned? I saw that show already: it was called She-Ra and the Princesses of Power, and it’s fucking brilliant. It premiered just a month or so after Series 11 and released its fifth and final season two months after Timeless aired. Not only does it deal with how shitty being a “Chosen One” is, it turns out that at the end of season 4, She-Ra is actually part of a great big alien weapon of mass destruction that almost gets used to wipe out the Horde… until Adora breaks the Sword of Protection, rendering the Heart of Etheria useless. WHAT’S THIS?! A BLONDE HEROINE WHO ACTUALLY DOES SOMETHING?! WHAT A CONCEPT!

Speaking of better female Doctors than Thirteen, I wrote in my Flatline post that Clara Oswald was essentially the real first female Doctor, and in Hell Bent, that’s taken to its logical conclusion: she’s got a TARDIS now, and she’s functionally immortal. The episode ends on a shot of two TARDISes, a phone box and a diner, flying away into the stars, and while we followed the box, I wish every single day that we’d followed the diner instead.

Because what did following the police box give us? This. It gave us “Fair play throughout the universe.” It gave us the Doctor killing a bunch of spiders with a Ghostbusters backpack instead of a gun. It gave us Kerblam. It gave us The Battle of Ranskoor av Kolos. It gave us the second episode of Spyfall, and “Now they’ll see the real you.” It gave us The Timeless Children. Next time it’ll give us a toothless allegory about authoritarian police states and Daleks, and then six episodes about the end of the universe and even more space cop shenanigans. Later still it’ll give us whatever the fuck happens for the final episodes of the era.

You want narrative substitution? I’ll give you fucking narrative substitution: listen to the Twelfth Doctor Fan Audios, a series of fan-made audio plays for which I’m one of the sound editors. Read Clara Oswald: The Untold Adventures when it comes out. If you want 13 content, I’m happy to recommend the New Series Adventures books and the Titan Comics, or even my fanfics if you want some good ol’ fashioned interspecies queer rep in the tradition of Vastra and Jenny. Any and all of those things would be better than subjecting yourself to this.

The final words of the Moffat era were: “Doctor… I let you go.” I wish I had.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑