I don’t know if it gets remarked upon a lot these days, but while there are several dividing lines between the classic and the new series, one of them is this: 9/11. Series 1 in particular is very much a product of its time, up to and including the vicious satire of Tony Blair and his government acting like George W. Bush’s lapdog as Dubya decided to invade Iraq, then invent an excuse as to why, that runs through Aliens of London. It’s aggressively political in a way that recalls the best stories in the Cartmel years, that it goes so far as to murder Blair is icing on the cake. (Note for my fellow Americans: Tony Blair is to the UK what Bill Clinton and the rest of the post-Reagan Democrats are for us, i.e., pretty much everyone other than The Squad.)
Obviously, given that we are now about as far away from Aliens of London as it was from Survival, the fact that it is a relic of the immediate fallout of 9/11 gets more and more obvious every day. Bush himself is long gone, spending his post-presidency as an artist, both the Iraq and Afghanistan wars are wrapped up, (and in the latter case, the Taliban is back in power like they never left) and we are still more likely to find Bigfoot than we are to find Iraqi WMDs.
Revolution of the Daleks, at least in part, feels like an attempt to take Aliens of London and update it for the world in 2021, but from a different angle: rather than foreign wars, we have the advancement of a national security state. The Trump Daleks get posted all over Britain, from the borders to the entrances of various national parks. Everything looks as though a point is about to be made about creeping fascism in alleged democracies led by the far right, whether in Britain or America. And then it just… doesn’t happen. Daleks get posted to a park, they activate and start killing people, and that’s it. Meanwhile, there’s Once and Future Showrunner RTD proclaiming how much of a lying of shit Blair is, but with giant green fart monsters.
None of this is a surprise. Chibnall is utterly, almost spectacularly incapable of making his attempts at political commentary cohere. He’s a centrist of the highest order, always choosing to avoid saying anything at all for fear of pissing off the people who aren’t watching the show anyway because they think it’s gone “woke” under his stewardship. Boy, I wish it did.
On the other paw, do we really want someone like Chris Chibnall making barbed political commentary? Not when the episode’s resolution can be described as the Doctor calling in the Skarosian Green Berets to kill off the Trump Daleks, so that she can then swoop in and “fix” the mess she caused in the first place, or just after that, when Robertson simply wanders off to go run for president again. (Like his character’s inspiration, Chris Noth has since been accused of sexual harassment, and while I’d say that would make his return unlikely, Chibnall himself didn’t seem to mind bringing John Barrowman back TWICE, despite credible allegations of Barrowman engaging in acts of sexual misconduct as late as his tenure on Torchwood. For which Chibnall was the fucking showrunner.) So maybe it’s just as well that Chibnall never commits to the “Daleks are integral to British national security” bit, because he’d probably decide that police states are a necessary evil. Or something.
Another running theme of Aliens of London: its character drama. The story starts with the Doctor dropping Rose off at home 12 hours after she left… except it turns out it’s actually been a year and Rose has been missing and presumed dead for twelve months. Jackie and Mickey are, understandably, pissed off with both of them but especially the Doctor, and it takes the whole Slitheen ordeal to get them to patch things up, or at least grudgingly accept Rose’s new life as a time traveler.
Meanwhile, Revolution was billed as the great big Farewell story for Graham O’Brien and Ryan Sinclair, two of the Doctor’s closest friends, and about whom, the Doctor can say “One of the first things I noticed about you that night we met. I thought, not everyone can carry off a yellow beanie. There’s a lad to rely on.” Ignoring the stilted nature of the scene, (the rumor is that it was shot post-COVID) this piece of dialogue sums up the Chibnallian approach to writing characters better than else: surface details about what what they are and what they do, nothing about who they are.
Series 12, to its credit, tried to flesh out Ryan’s character a bit more: Spyfall opens with him playing basketball (quite a choice for someone who is supposed to have dyspraxia, but apparently Tosin Cole likes the game) while Orphan 55 gives him a bit of old-fashioned climate anxiety, which then gets followed up on in Can You Hear Me? in his nightmare scene and group therapy sequence at the end.
And then in this episode… he and Graham just leave, the latter restating a line of his from Woman, and our last shot of both of them is Ryan trying to ride a bike on the very same hill we first saw him on. There is no build-up to this moment whatsoever, and despite expository dialogue about rock monsters, I get the impression neither of them are going anywhere any time soon, except maybe to Graham’s house.
Chibnall’s version of Doctor Who, from the word go, has been about nostalgia for the Old Days, whether those Old Days were in 2007, or 1963. In this case, Chibnall appears to be going back to the very old days of the classic era, when traveling companions just up and left in mid-story. At least Graham and Ryan leave on their own terms, rather than because someone’s contract ran out (Jackie Lane as Dodo) or they died (Matthew Waterhouse as Adric).
If Chibnall’s writing style for episodes like these can be described as “excitable 7 year old playing with action figures,” the abrupt departure of Graham and Ryan comes across as him declaring “I don’t wanna play with you anymore,” like Andy to Woody during a nightmare in the second Toy Story. Because the very next thing he does, after lingering on a shot of what should have been the first all-female TARDIS team for the first time in the history of the series, is introduce John Bishop as Dan “Emotional Support White Guy” Lewis.
“Is the future going to be all girl?” sneered Harold T. Master at Twelve, two seasons ago.
“We can only hope,” replied the Doctor.
My hope ran out.
Leave a Reply