Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Division

In 1970, Doctor Who had changed. Black and white was out and color was in. Jon Pertwee replaced Patrick Troughton as the Doctor, and for once, he didn’t travel in time and space, but stuck around on Earth as a nominal employee of the United Nations Intelligence Taskforce, aka UNIT. All of a sudden, Doctor Who had become a military science fiction show, like the early ‘70s equivalent of Stargate SG-1 or something. Instead of being a wandering bohemian who did what he felt like, he now had a job to do! An officer to report to! He was but one cog in the military machine, working to protect Earth, and thus Queen and Country, from harm.

No surprise then that Chris Chibnall’s favorite era of the show appears to have been the Pertwee years. Two of his pre-Whittaker scripts resurrect concepts and storylines from that era: The Hungry Earth/Cold Blood is a modern remake of Doctor Who and the Silurians, with dashes of Inferno and The Green Death for flavor. The Power of Three brings back UNIT and gives us the Brigadier’s daughter in the absence of Lethbridge-Stewart himself as part of a storyline in which the Earth is invaded by an alien menace, as seen periodically in the Pertwee era.

But I think what really appeals to Chibnall about that period of the show isn’t just that it’s grounded on Earth in a world that looks like ours. It’s something I mentioned in the first paragraph: the Pertwee era gives us a Doctor who is part of a system, rather than being an anarchic destroyer of systems. So, during Series 12, Chibnall introduces the concept of The Division: a Gallifreyan black-ops group that is later revealed to include other species, such as the Lupari and the Weeping Angels. The Doctor is said to have once been a part of this group, though she broke free and had her mind wiped.

In a way, the Division echoes the infamous season 6b theory, created by various Doctor Who fans to provide an in-universe explanation for things like why we never actually see the Second Doctor become the Third at the end of The War Games, (Pertwee hadn’t been cast yet) and why Patrick Troughton looks considerably older in The Five Doctors and The Two Doctors. The theory holds that at some point between War Games and Spearhead, the Doctor became an agent of the Time Lords and carried out an unspecified number of missions for them, it even pops up in “Save Yourself,” Terrance Dicks’ final Doctor Who adventure.

But with the Division, Chibnall goes one step further: he posits that the Doctor had an entire galaxy of faces prior to William Hartnell’s, from the Morbius Doctors to Jo Martin, but lost her memories of them when she escaped from the Division’s clutches. She then spends Series 13 trying to recover those memories, as opposed to doing the sensible thing and, I don’t know, destroying the Division from within. Or something.

The way the Division is depicted in the show makes very little sense: half the time, the organization is very definitely Bad, but the episode Once Upon, Time spends large chunks of its running time in a flashback scene depicting the Jo Martin Doctor’s last mission with her strike team, and at this point, the Division is framed as the good team we’re supposed to root for. All cops are bastards, unless one of them is a dog, it seems.

On the other side of the coin then, we have UNIT. As introduced in Spearhead From Space, UNIT is a paramilitary organization that investigates weird things, and they are unambiguously the Good Guys, led by Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, the most unflappable man in the world. But the thing is, they’re military. The Doctor is an iconoclast, what use does he have becoming an agent of the state?

Well, in the minds of some people, there are systems out there that are good, and protect the people they serve. UNIT, in defending Earth against alien invasions, is one such organization, and the Doctor, as an alien himself, could give them intelligence they wouldn’t otherwise have. So the Doctor becomes UNIT’s “scientific advisor,” and gives them his tacit endorsement.

The Doctor, being a character played by British actors and written by British writers, is thus also British. So, of course, this gets reflected in his attitude toward various British institutions and aspects of society: he drinks tea, pals around with the Royal Family, is the best friend of Winston Churchill, and even makes a speech in The Doctor Dances about Britain, standing alone, refusing to allow itself to be overrun by Nazis. And in becoming part of UNIT at the end of Spearhead, he fulfills his destiny by becoming part of the empire itself.

Which brings me back to Chibnall’s peculiar choices with regard to depicting the Division. The Ireland scenes in The Timeless Children show us Brendan, AKA the young Doctor, joining up with the police because he wants to “make a difference,” even though the Division itself is, ya know, evil. The Atropos siege scenes in Series 13 suggest that while the Division as a whole might be bad, the Doctor and her strike team are the Good Guys. If the Division is supposed to be a critique of police departments, it’s not a very good one. Chibnall’s obvious fondness for cop shows means he’s always going to try and depict them positively at the risk of muddying up the story he’s trying to tell.

The Division, as a concept, sucks. The Season 6b theory that I mentioned a few paragraphs ago, say what you will about its validity or not, at least tried to address something we’d seen on screen. We’re Doctor Who fans, we like to have explanations for everything, even the realities of TV production. “It’s just a show, I should really just relax” is never going to be enough for us.

But the Division? It is absolutely, completely pointless. There is simply no reason for it to exist except as, as my friend Freezing Inferno said, a “lore shakeup delivery system.”  We don’t actually need to have an origin story for the Doctor. It was enough, in 2014’s Listen, when Steven Moffat simply implied that the boy Clara talks to was a very young Doctor. We didn’t need anything more than that.

Chibnall, evidently, thinks otherwise. The end result was that Series 13 became the most continuity-driven season of the show since the fucking Colin Baker era, and for no reason at all! No one asked for or needed an explanation as to the Morbius Doctors! But we got one anyway! No one needed to turn the Doctor into a “Hero’s Journey” store-brand Luke Skywalker, but we’re here nonetheless!

And in the end, it all comes to nothing anyway. Tecteun gets killed off, the Doctor elects not to open the watch she spent all season looking for, and the Division, like Jack Robertson before it, is never actually defeated. Knowing Chibnall, I’m going to hazard a guess that it’ll come back in his final story, as the cause of Thirteen’s regeneration, maybe with the Master at the helm this time.

I liked Series 11 better.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑