Adventures in Narrative Substitution: War of the Sontarans

One aspect of the Chibnall years that I haven’t remarked on yet is its lack of humor. Now admittedly, literally any other writer being appointed to replace Moffat would’ve been something of a come-down, given Moffat’s situation comedy background (EVERYONE GO AND WATCH PRESS GANG) leading him to infuse virtually every script he ever wrote with jokes, particularly one-liners. Not everyone can do that, and certainly not while making it look like the easiest thing in the world.

Then came the switch to Chibnall. One of the first things I noticed about The Woman Who Fell to Earth, aside from the darkness of the setting and the script, was that there weren’t very many jokes. Yes, there was Salad Guy, but Salad Guy was funny and memorable in the same way the blind dude who says “Help me” in Rocket Attack USA is memorable: he comes completely out of nowhere, has no particular relevance to the story, says one bizarre line that makes no sense even in context, then disappears again.

Other bits that are funny in that story either come down to an actor’s line read (the Doctor’s cheerful “Not anymore!” after wiping Ryan’s phone so she can use it for her own ends springs to mind) more than anything intentionally placed into the script.

Because when he tries to be funny, that’s how we get the infamous family conversation bit in Resolution (of the Daleks), or literally everything involving Nick and Sarah in Eve of the Daleks, which tries for romantic comedy but lands on “creepy stalker pursues his crush who is then guilt-tripped by the story for not returning his affections.” Very Love, Actually.

Where this lack of comedy really gets thrown into sharp relief though is the related concept of very little silliness. One of Chibnall’s complaints about The Trial of a Time Lord from his infamous 1986 TV appearance was that there were too many “silly monsters.” And one imagines he must’ve nursed that grudge for a good 30 years or so, because once he got the top job, the Daleks had the plunger removed and replaced with a claw.

For goodness knows whatever reason, the Chibnall era has been utterly devoted to playing everything seriously. And with War of the Sontarans, we hit the limit of that approach, as Chibnall tries to do this with the Sontarans. As created by Robert Holmes, the central joke of the Sontarans is that while they are full of military bravado and machismo, they lookridiculous, being short and potato shaped. They are exactly no one’s idea of an intergalactic conquerer, but they do it anyway.

Even Chibnall understands the Sontarans can’t taken entirely seriously: the commander the Doctor has a shouted (and likely COVID-compliant) conversation with twice says he wanted to invade Earth partly to fulfill the claim Linx made on the planet in The Time Warrior, and because “he wanted to ride a horse.” Then there’s the bit in The Vanquishers where they all get addicted to chocolate like it’s peppermint schnapps or something.

Even so, the rest of the time he tries to go for seriousness. The episode is called War of the Sontarans, the potato heads easily mow down the British soldiers, and in the season finale it’s revealed that they are the titular Vanquishers, rather than Cherry Flavored Hordak and Blue’s Clues.

Because apparently, someone who was once a member of the Doctor Who Appreciation Society, the biggest group of anoraks on Earth, never watched The Invasion of Time, the Sontarans’ last attempt at being a big season finale enemy on par with Daleks. It failed to work in 1978, and this is why, in 2008, RTD gave them the Silly Monster Two-Parter slot in series 4: they are just too ridiculous for anyone to take them remotely seriously. If he wanted po-faced seriousness, he should’ve gone another hyper-masculine alien race: THE FREAKING STENZA! WOULDN’T THAT HAVE TIED THE ERA UP WITH A NICE BOW! But alas he didn’t.

On the other side of the coin, you have Douglas Adams. We all know him from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy and Dirk Gently, but in the late 1970s he had a brief stint as a writer on Doctor Who as well, contributing three scripts: The Pirate Planet, City of Death, (co-written with Graham Williams) and Shada. He also had a fourth story, The Krikkitmen, that didn’t get made, but it was eventually novelized, as were his three other stories.

The Pirate Planet, while a very funny script, uses humor to make a very important point: genocide is bad. Yes, the Doctor can appreciate a fancy shrunken planet museum, but he also knows exactly how evil it is and how many people were killed to make it happen. Repeatedly stressed is the theme of balance: the shrunken planets are balanced with each other, Queen Xanxia is at a point balanced between life and death, and the more planets that get destroyed, the stronger the Mentiads become. Far from being a moral good, all the balance shown here is rooted in atrocity.

And of course, the Doctor loudly and spectacularly attacks the Captain for his planet-shrinking scheme, whereas in War of the Sontarans, the Doctor only comes up with this after the British lieutenant blows up a Sontaran ship: “Sometimes men like you make me wonder why I bother with humanity.” Then she praises Dan for.. uh… blowing up the Sontarans, but with their own ships instead of TNT. Once again, the aesthetics of violence are considered to be of greater importance than the violent acts themselves.

Dan and the lieutenant both do the same thing (massacre Sontarans) but Dan gets the praise, partly because he’s A Companion Now (despite the fact that he’s been with the Doctor maybe five minutes) and because he employed a science fiction solution to the problem, whereas the lieutenant just used what he had on hand, and TNT (as anyone who’s watched a bunch of old Roadrunner cartoons knows) is definitely more traditionally violent-looking.

And, look, here’s the thing. This sort of tedious faux-moralism sucks. The Doctor doesn’t usually use guns, but sometimesshe does, though context is key. More often she’ll resort to other violent methods of problem-solving: for crying out loud, The Day of the Doctor is about getting the Doctor’s warrior incarnation not to use a WMD! If the show was trying to make a point about this hypocrisy, that would be one thing, but it isn’t! It genuinely seems to believe that aesthetics are more important than actions!

And in another four episodes, Dan’s destruction of the Liverpool fleet will turn out to be entirely pointless anyway. Go figure.

We’ll always have Zanak.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑