Adventures in Narrative Substitution: The Vanquishers

My usual thing for this series is to contrast the Chibnall era with something else, but as with the Survivors/Kroll post, I can’t really do that this time: in this case, the writers are too much alike. Chibnall, Bob Baker, and Dave Martin all attempt to make Doctor Who into Epic Television. The vast majority of Armageddon Factor doesn’t do any of the subversive anti-epic stuff that Ribos Operation was doing. Instead, we get budget Star Wars: the Doctor is specifically made an agent of the White Guardian, and his goal is to keep the Black Guardian from getting it instead.

But the thing is, it wasn’t just Baker and Martin on writing duties for this story. They dissolved their writing partnership after this story, but there were still rewrites that needed to be done. Outgoing script editor Anthony Read decided to hand this task over to his replacement, Douglas Adams.

Adams’ contribution to the story was the climactic sequence in the sixth episode where the Doctor, talking to the White Guardian on the TARDIS scanner, stalls for time, doing everything he can to avoid giving the completed Key to the Guardian. At one point he points out that Princess Astra (played by Lalla Ward) would be imprisoned forever if the Key is used. The Guardian’s response: a boilerplate statement about how regrettable that would be. That’s enough for the Doctor, who reveals that the Guardian he’s been speaking to isn’t the White Guardian after all, but the Black. Deciding that no one should have such awesome power at their disposal, not even the guardians of the universe, he disperses the Key’s pieces back into space.

Adams, as we saw in The Pirate Planet, was distrustful of the entire idea of balance. In his personal life, he was also an avowed atheist, giving the Doctor’s breaking of the key an additional dimension. This wasn’t just the Doctor deciding that a ridiculously powerful criminal shouldn’t have access to a weapon of mass destruction, this is the Doctor deciding that not even God Himself can be trusted with the Key’s power, and the best thing is to make sure no one else can find it and put it back together again.

In her post on Ribos, El Sandifer writes: “Presented with a radically dualist universe, the Doctor’s reaction is essentially to reject the entire premise. And, of course, he’s right to. If the Black Guardian is a callous tyrant like the Graff and the White is an old colonial master, rejecting them in favor of a third option is clearly the correct choice.” The Doctor is manifestly not a being of order, they never have been. They are a being of chaos, and chaos can do anything it wants to.

Or at least, that was the case until Chris “Sorting out fair play throughout the universe” Chibnall came along. Here the Doctor talks about “balance in the universe,” and the importance of restoring that balance. We’re right back to Baker and Martin territory here, and this time Douglas Adams can’t get us out of it.

Honestly, The Vanquishers and Survivors of the Flux really make you wonder whether or not Chibnall understands his lead character’s motivations in the first place: in Survivors, the Doctor is horrified when she learns that the Division “Interfered, in contravention of all Time Lord directives.”

Yeah. The Doctor is horrified that someone broke the sacred rules of the Time Lords. The rules that SHE HERSELF, FROM WILLIAM HARTNELL ON DOWN, HAS BROKEN TIME AND AGAIN FOR NEARLY SIXTY GODDAMNED YEARS. For crying out loud, part of The Three Doctors is entirely about the Doctor breaking the laws of time by meeting himself, albeit with permission because the Time Lords have no other options on the table!

And as for the Time Lords themselves?! We know exactly what the Doctor thinks of his own people: he hates them! When he calls for them in The War Games, it’s clear he’s doing it at an absolute last resort, and he’s not happy to be doing it. At his trial, he calls them out spectacularly:

“All these evils I have fought, while you have done nothing but observe! True, I am guilty of interference. Just as you are guilty of failing to use your great powers to help those in need!”

They thank him for this by exiling him to Earth and forcibly regenerating him into Jon Pertwee. (Eventually.)

53 years later, we get a Doctor who simply does nothing but observe. Refusing to get involved is all over this era, dove-tailing with an obsession to get history exactly right, as seen in Rosa. In this episode, it leads to SEVEN BILLION LUPARI ALL BEING KILLED OFF-SCREEN BECAUSE THEY COULD ONLY AFFORD TO MAKE ONE FUCKING COSTUME. The Doctor does nothing to address the fact that Karvanista’s entire species just got wiped away from existence, nor does she do anything about the bomb in his brain that he says would kill him instantly if he blabs about their shared past together. She just bounces off, back to her box, off on another adventure.

This era is ugly. It’s aesthetically ugly, its stories are ugly, and most damningly of all, it’s morally ugly. It really is just as well that there are only three episodes left of this misbegotten train-wreck of an era, because the truth is, I’m tired of writing about it. I am tired of devoting large chunks of my days off from my shitty retail job to thinking about this era and its many, many failures.

I am aware that Chibnall’s appointment as showrunner largely came about because Steven Moffat had to basically get him drunk to accept. I am aware that Chibnall and his bosses at the BBC had a hell of a time trying to get anyone to run the show after him: Sally Wainwright was reportedly the choice of Piers Wenger, the BBC’s head of drama and a former executive producer on the show during series 5 and 6, but Wainwright wasn’t interested. They landed on Davies because he was the only person in the world who had the experience they were looking for. If not for that bright idea, I honestly believe we really would be looking at cancellation, just as in the 1980s.

And in a way, we’re still looking at cancellation, just not quite in the way you expect. Doctor Who is one show, but like the TARDIS, it’s bigger on the inside: every time a Doctor regenerates or a showrunner or script editor arrives or departs, the current version of the show dies to make way for the new. Tom Baker gave way to Peter Davison, Matt Smith gave way to Peter Capaldi.

So it is, in a way, entirely fitting that this episode ends with Time itself, in the Doctor’s form, grimly announcing that Thirteen herself is not long for this world. This era is not fit for purpose. It will not only die soon, it deserves to die. I don’t know what show it is we’ve been watching for the past three seasons, but I do know one thing…

It sure isn’t Doctor Who.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑