Adventures in Narrative Substitution: Eve of the Daleks

I’ve talked a lot over the course of this series about queerness, and in particular, the Chibnall era’s continual failures to deliver. I don’t think I’m being at all hyperbolic when I say that his era of the show is easily the most cis-het of the New Series so far. And when queer characters have popped up, they are usually either killed off or already have had their partners killed offscreen, rendering their queerness little more than an incidental detail that can be easily removed, as with pretty much anything Disney does on the representation front.

In the gap between Series 5 and 6, Steven Moffat was rightly called out online for a complete lack of queer content in his Doctor Who, with the exception of Mark Gatiss. In response, Moffat went and created the interspecies lesbian pair of Madame Vastra and Jenny Flint, a pair of Victorian crime-fighters said within the show to be Sir Conan-Doyle’s inspiration for Sherlock Holmes. 4 seasons later, we got Bill Potts, another lesbian who, after adventuring with the Doctor and becoming a Cyberman, got resurrected by her own love, Heather, and became a lesbian water goddess. Yes, these characters were all written by a straight man, but even they can churn out a decent queer romance if they care enough to try.

Which brings me to Chris Chibnall and the character of Yasmin Khan. People in certain sectors of Who fandom that I’m not in decided that Yaz was attracted to the Doctor, based off a few isolated lines in Series 11, and repeatedly demanded that be brought up within the show itself. It took a while, but Chibnall seemed to have heard them: in the last quarter of Eve of the Daleks, she and Dan Lewis have a brief chat about Yaz’s sexuality, and her relationship to the Doctor in particular:

DAN: Have you ever told her?
YASMIN: Told her what?
DAN: How you feel about her.
YASMIN: I don’t know what you mean.
DAN: Yeah, you do.
YASMIN: Is it that obvious?
DAN: Maybe not to a good-hearted weirdo. But I’ve spent four years travelling the world with you. I saw it then. You didn’t half cane looking at that hologram.
YASMIN: I didn’t. I mean, it were just that it… She’s just… I don’t know what to do, Dan. I’ve never told anyone. Not even myself.
DAN: Just tell her.
YASMIN: It’s not that easy.
DAN: Look, I took way too long to tell somebody that I liked them and then… the universe ended and everything got messy. I wouldn’t want that to happen to you, Sheffield.

Chibnall has, over the majority of his term, struggled to give Yaz (and thus Mandip Gill) anything to do, Gill has repeatedly implied in interviews that she’s struggled to find a way into the character. and at one point, Chibnall allegedly asked her for ideas on what to do with Yaz, which is an amazing thing for, you know, the showrunner to be doing with one of his employees. There were glimmers of a personality for Yaz in Series 13’s opening episode, but within two weeks we were back to “Yasmin Khan is Also There,” being exposited at by Cherry Flavored Hordak as if she had nothing better to do.

The quoted exchange isn’t bad, per se. If it had happened between Yaz and Graham sometime in Series 11, we could’ve had a really interesting character arc for Yaz as she struggles with her identity as a sapphic woman in love with an ageless Time Lady, but instead, it’s happening in episode 29 of 31. Chibnall has exactly two stories to deal with this new Plot Development, and given his proclivity at spectacularly dropping the ball when he really needs to not do that, I don’t imagine this is going to pan out very well for anyone. IF ONLY THERE WAS SOME OTHER TV SHOW A BLONDE-HAIRED SUPERHEROINE THAT HE COULD BE TAKING NOTES FROM.

She-Ra and the Princesses of Power, obviously, is not Doctor Who. But this late into the era, I admit I am struggling to find Who-related stories to write about in this space, so I’m branching out a little. It debuted just two days after Demons of the Punjab, and dropped its final season in May 2020, a couple of months after Series 12 wrapped. And unlike the aggressively cis-het Chibnall era, She-Ra is queer to its very bones.

Created by ND Stevenson as a reboot of the 1980s series She-Ra: Princess of Power, SPOP tells the story of a slow-burn romance between Adora, the protagonist, and Catra, the antagonist. Their story is of two women who have been friends since childhood, only to be ripped apart by standing on opposite sides of a war. Both of them love each other, but neither will let themselves admit it: Adora is too busy trying to keep Etheria from falling into the clutches of the Horde to think about personal relationships, and Catra hides her feelings by becoming Adora’s enemy, up to and including breaking all of reality.

During the fifth season, Catra has all of her existing relationships torn down, and winds up brainwashed. Adora comes to her rescue, and Catra switches sides, fighting against the Horde rather than for it. In the series finale, Catra saves Adora’s life and the two of them share a kiss, in a landmark moment for children’s animation. This scene was far from a sure thing: Stevenson and the rest of the writing staff, at first, had to work very hard to convince the bosses at Dreamworks that it wouldn’t cause any harm.

What makes the kiss work is that it’s earned: every moment between Catra and Adora in each of the preceding 51 episodes was working toward that scene, particularly the romantic dance the two of them share in the ‘Princess Prom” episode. You can’t watch She-Ra and not pick up on the fact that Adora and Catra are attracted to each other, it’s basically a central plot point.

But Chibnall has, over and over, failed to do anything that felt earned. If anything comes of Yaz’s alleged attraction to the Doctor, it will be because he realized at the last second that something needed to be done about it, and so it came up with the same amount of set-up as Graham’s revenge quest against Tzim-Sha: nil.

If anything, comparing Thirteen/Yaz to Catra/Adora is an unfair comparison: Catradora was written by a queer transmasculine enby, Chibnall is the dictionary definition of Heterosexual Cisgender White Male who doesn’t seem to quite grasp how romance works. For fuck’s sake, the other couple in the episode is Aisling Bea and Nick the creepy stalker dude who keeps tokens from his many ex-girlfriends. (Dude, if you have to rent out a damn storage unit to keep your exes’ shit in, it’s just possible that YOU ARE THE PROBLEM.) Completely improbably, Nick and Aisling end up Together by the end of the episode, with Nick describing their “first meeting” (the Dalek attack) as a meet cute.

First of all, that’s not what a meet cute is. Second of all, Aisling should’ve served his ass with a restraining order, only customer or not.

But I digress. Making Yaz queer only works if the character was designed to be queer from the word go, and seeing as she also briefly seemed to have a thing for Ryan before it got unceremoniously dropped, this really does smell like “Last minute character trait” thing. And again, there are TWO EPISODES LEFT. TWO. AND ONE OF THOSE IS 13’S REGENERATION EPISODE. THERE IS LITERALLY NO TIME TO ADEQUATELY EXPLORE THIS.

And yet, there are people on Twitter who are arguing, with straight faces, that Yaz is somehow better representation than Bill. Yaz isn’t queer rep in any way whatsoever, if anything, she’s exploitation. Chibnall is supposing, apparently correctly, that the show’s remaining viewing audience contains people who will applaud like seals for even the barest hintof queerness.

I say no. I’m not going to fucking take Chris Chibnall’s goddamn table scraps when ND Stevenson and the rest of Crew-Ra are over here providing us with a five-course meal at a ridiculously fancy restaurant. I’ll take no rep over piss-poor fake rep any day of the damned week. Hell, you want to know what a real lesbian relationship looks like? Go check my Twitter for tweets about my ongoing relationship with @WanderingJoy071. I don’t need Chibnall when my amazingly talented girlfriend is just a text message away.

Oh, and one more thing, this later exchange between Dan and the Doctor:

DAN: She likes you.
DOCTOR: I like her, too.
DAN: No, I mean… she likes you.
DOCTOR: I don’t understand what you’re saying, Dan.
DAN: I think you do. But for some reason you pretend to me, and to her, that you don’t.

You know what never happens on She-Ra? There are a lot of queer characters on that show (I’m pretty sure they outnumber the cishets by 2:1 or something) and in 52 episodes across five seasons, NOBODY GETS OUTED. EVER. NOT ONCE. Everybody gets treated with respect! Because everyone knows that OUTING PEOPLE IS NEVER FUCKING OKAY. That’s how you know Chibnall is a cis-het, he just plunges straight into Dan outing Yaz to the Doctor without a second thought, just like my mother when she outed me to my 80 year old grandma this past New Year’s Eve. Thanks a lot, bitch.

Anyway. Fuck Chibnall for trying to pull the wool over our eyes. If he actually does attempt to follow through with this, I have no doubt it’ll be one of the most homophobic homosexual relationships ever put to screen.

Gimme 10-foot tall sword lesbians kissing cat-girls any day of the week.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑