First of all, I’d like to begin by shamelessly plugging my new book, the second volume of the Back to the Eleventh Hourtrilogy of critical essays on the era of the Eleventh Doctor. It covers series six, a truly mad and ambitious season of the show if there ever was one. Yes, the same description can be applied to series 13, but the difference is that series 6 was largely successful at what it chose to do, and series 13 crashed and burned in spectacular fashion. Say what you will about Moffat’s approach to series finales vs Chibnall’s, but I think it’s fair to say he’s never managed to strike out three times in a row. Who does he think he is, a batter for the Marlins?
Speaking of striking out, allow me to introduce the replacement story for Legend of the Sea Devils, 2010’s Victory of the Daleks, written by Mark Gatiss and last discussed in chapter 3 of the first Back to the Eleventh Hour book. In its own season it’s something of a misfire (as I discussed at length there) but when compared to something like Legend, I think it shines.
Now, okay, I’ll admit: I am probably stretching the format of this series to its breaking point by recommending a solidly C-tier Smith story in place of the penultimate Whittaker episode, and Doctor Who and the Pirates was right there, but I am loath to suggest yet another expanded universe story to people who may not be able to afford it. Victory is easier to find at least.
And let’s be honest: at this point, with the exception of Juno Dawson’s new podcast, I really cannot be fucking bothered to give even half of a shit about this era anymore. Village of the Angels may have been the straw that broke the wolfgirl’s back, but the truth is, I should’ve given up somewhere around series 12. Writing these posts has been cathartic for me, but even that isn’t enough anymore: I want to enjoy the media I’m critiquing, not tear it apart. To look again at Chibnall’s era and see the exact same mistakes being made over and over again isn’t fun, it’s boring, and if my increasingly bitter and furious tone in the past few essays isn’t enough of an indication, let me state for the record that I am absolutely at the end of my rope.
There is one post left in this series, and two left as regards Chibnall’s general oeuvre since 2007. I will be very, very, veryglad to wash my paws of him. So if this one seems a bit shorter than normal, it’s because I want to get this done so I can put myself out of this misery as quickly as I can. So, let’s jump right in.
The first thing to note is that these stories aired on the same day, twelve years apart: April 17th, 2010 and 2022 respectively. Both of them also center around bringing back a famous villain from the show’s past… and that’s pretty much where the similarities end.
Because look, here’s the thing: cribbed from David Whitaker Victory might be, it at least has SOME interesting stuff going on with the Daleks, and as terrible as the redesign looked, at least you didn’t have things like CGI eye blinks or mouth “movements” that resemble, as someone observed on Twitter, Kermit the Frog with his mouth glued shut. Whereas all Chibnall can think of to do with the Sea Devils is to make them into Generic Turtle Monsters.
And also, they’re D-list Doctor Who monsters. This is their third appearance in fifty years, and neither of their first two could ever be called good: One is British Navy propaganda, and the other contains a pantomime horse for a monster, is lit like a supermarket, and notably was the story that led to Peter Davison quitting and the one Michael Grade pointed to as evidence that the show should be cancelled. And this one, with a bar on the fucking floor, manages to be even worse than either of them through sheer incompetence.
And while Victory is very far from a good Dalek episode, it’s leagues ahead of all the Sea Devil ones. It’s shot better, the action scenes look like action scenes, Matt Smith carries the day with more than enough charisma to make it watchable, and allying Churchill with the Daleks remains a good idea that gets botched by the decision to also play into the war hero stuff.
But again: Chibnall’s story has none of this. It looks cheap, it’s shot all to hell, the Asian characters are just kind of there, (you could replace them with the pirates from Black Spot and the story would be largely the same) and as a story it doesn’t just fail to cohere, it fucking lays there, doing nothing. It was made fast and it looks like it. It’s amateurish, and quite frankly, if RTD wasn’t already coming back, I’d be declaring the show deserves to die. And maybe it will anyway, maybe the Davies gamble will fail and the show won’t get renewed for Series 15. I don’t know.
All of this brings me to the one aspect of the episode I haven’t discussed yet: Thasmin. That is, the attempt at a romantic relationship between the Thirteenth Doctor, a woman, and Yaz, another woman. Lately I’ve been watching series 2, the last time a Doctor/Companion romance was tried in quite this fashion, and I have to say, this is even worse, and 10/Rose was pretty fucking awful.
Everything the Doctor tells Yaz, stringing her along and saying “If I was gonna do it of course it would be you,” only to crush Yaz’s hopes, is toxic. This is literally what abusive partners do in real life. Making it even worse is the reason she gives for turning Yaz down in the first place: Because she’s virtually immortal, and losing her would hurt too much. That she and Yaz could be happy now, and make the most of the time they have, is thrown off the table because Curse of the Immortals. Which isn’t just absolute bullshit, it’s bullshit that strikes a very personal chord with me.
Some background: in the time between the last couple weeks or so of Flux and now, I’ve been dating a woman named Dani. Like me, she’s transgender and a wolf therian, and I love her more than life itself. (Hello sweetheart! I know you’re reading this!) In the time we’ve been together, we both have opened up about our past relationships, and what I’m about to share with you, my readers, was shared with her too.
I have a connective tissue disorder that bears some hallmarks of Marfan’s syndrome, but as far as I know isn’t actually Marfan’s. (If you don’t know what that is, Google is your friend.) It hasn’t really affected my life so far, thank goodness, but that wasn’t enough for my last ex, Alex, who told me when she dumped me that she couldn’t afford to take care of me in the event something went wrong.
When I started dating Dani, I told her about this as soon as I could. And you know what she said? She said, “If anything happens, I promise to do whatever I need to do to make sure you’re cared for.”
The Doctor is doing to Yaz what Alex did to me. And that infuriates me beyond words. Because the message the Doctor and Alex were sending is “You might not live long enough for our relationship to be worth going through.” Which is an appalling thing to say to anyone, but in the context of being the first queer relationship between the two lead characters in the history of the series, it’s cruel beyond words.
Are you happy now, Thassies? Because while I was perfectly fine with your readings of previous episodes up to now, this is where I draw the line.
This is your relationship. The one you made cute drawings and fanfics about got canonized at last, as a treat to the fans, and this is what it turned out to be: the Doctor stands revealed as an abusive person, putting her own heart(s) before Yaz’s. The Doctor says she can’t fix herself, the implication being she’s always been like this, as if literally the entire Moffat era never happened, as if she never already learned about how not to be an abusive bitch.
Yeah. I said it. The Doctor is an abusive bitch. I didn’t just say it, I FUCKING LIVED THROUGH IT. MY THEN-GIRLFRIEND LET ME MOVE IN WITH HER, I STAYED THERE FOR A WEEK, AND THEN SHE DUMPED ME WHEN I TOLD HER ABOUT MY CONDITION. SHE SAID I’D LIED AND THAT I BROKE HER TRUST, AND THEN SHE KICKED ME OUT, FORCING ME TO GO BACK HOME TO MY EMOTIONALLY ABUSIVE PARENTS.
Several deep breaths later…
Quite frankly, if Dani hadn’t come into my life when she did, and if I hadn’t started hormones five days after becoming her girlfriend, I honestly don’t know if I’d even be writing these words. Even now we’re figuring out how best to get me out of my current situation, so there’s a good chance that by the time the centenary airs and this series ends, I’ll be living a much better life than I am, and it’s already starting to look up.
There are good ways to write queer relationships, and there are bad ways to write queer relationships. I don’t know who wrote this one, but I don’t care, because it’s the worst possible attempt at a queer relationship as could be dreamed of, and as I’ve illustrated, it presses some very specific buttons for me personally.
For crying out loud, the stuff with Dorabella and Bracewell is handled better. I’d rather have that than this toxic noxious nightmare that we’re supposed to believe is “representation.”
This isn’t representation, this is exploitation. And I categorically refuse to be exploited.
My name is Christa Fenrira Mactíre. I’m transgender. I’m a lesbian. I’m a wolf. Mess with me, and I’ll rip you apart.
It’s a good thing this era is already over. Because if it wasn’t, I’d kill it myself.
This is your relationship, Thassies. Cherish it.
Leave a Reply