The Mactíre Anthology: The Woman Who Fell to Earth Review

NOTE: This review, like the others, was written following the episode’s broadcast in late 2018, and so does not reflect changing opinions since then.

Well, here we go again: the start of a new era. When Twice Upon A Time aired, I spent most of the episode anticipating its final moments, when Peter Capaldi would transform into Jodie Whittaker.

When that moment finally came, I was on the edge of my seat, watching as director Rachel Talalay gave us one of the most beautifully shot post-regeneration sequences ever: The Doctor, silhouetted and standing in white smoke, the reflection of the ceiling in her eye, the eerie, echoing groaning sounds of the TARDIS, the original version of The Doctor’s Theme from 2005, taking us straight back to the days of Christopher Eccleston as an equally different Doctor… then… that moment.

You know the one I’m talking about: that long panning shot from the TARDIS console, past the Doctor’s hands, and up to her face. She looks at her reflection in the scanner monitor, grins, and says: “Oh, brilliant!”

That was a momentous event anyway, but for a transgender woman like me? It was as though someone had captured the same joy and euphoria I felt the first time I saw a girl in the mirror, and put it in my favorite show. Then it happened again, when the Doctor expressed surprise at being called ma’am and remarked about how long it had been since she’d had to wear women’s clothes.

I’ve written before about this show and how it has helped me through my own regeneration, as I prefer to think of it. The Doctor’s insistence that their “real name” doesn’t matter, that the name they chose is what’s important, is a rebuke to those people who like to ask us what our deadnames are. Missy was like a cracked mirror version of trans women, reveling in the euphoria of being female while causing chaos, and now we have the Doctor, a hero to girls everywhere, be they cis or trans.

That’s the lens I will be viewing this era of the show through. How could I not, when so many of the things I’ve experienced are now happening to a character I view as an aspirational figure? I am trans, and now so is the Doctor.

Anyway, to business. I would describe this episode as having the very rough outline of Rose, but with the grim, dark tone of Deep Breath. It has Rose’s focus on the companions rather than the Doctor, and Chibnall goes to great lengths to make them seem like real people, much like Russell T Davies did. The Doctor doesn’t even turn up until the companions are facing death, as Eccleston’s incarnation did in that episode.

What the episode largely lacks however is wit. While there are some humorous lines (most of them belonging to the Doctor and Graham), for the most part the dialogue is plain and straight as can be, without the rapid-fire quips that marked Steven Moffat’s scripts. Basically, it feels like an episode of Torchwood or Class, which is rather jarring seeing as the promotional trailers (and Chibnall’s statements) suggested this would be a lighter series.

Jodie, of course, pretty much owns the role from the word go. Her Doctor has none of the emotional baggage that drove her previous incarnations, and her empathy and kindness could be read as her following the Twelfth Doctor’s advice in his final speech. To me, she has Eleven’s eccentricity with Nine’s snark and Ten’s propensity to babble.

The companions are… okay. I like the idea of an ensemble of differing ages and races compared to the traditional Doctor+one companion team up, but I can’t quite understand why it was necessary to make Tosin Cole and Mandip Gill’s characters 19 when neither of them (especially Gill) really look it. Graham’s pretty good, especially in the funeral scene at the end. Sharon D. Clarke’s character, Grace, is pretty easily my favorite, which just makes it even more of a shame that she dies.

I mean, honestly. The production team have been talking up the show’s new focus on diversity and inclusion for almost exactly a year now, and then they go and kill off a black woman in the first episode. I mean, what the hell?! It’s exactly the same trick Star Trek did when they killed Michelle Yeoh’s character at the end of Battle of the Binary Stars, and thanks to the fact that Grace was married to Graham, a white man, it’s also not unlike Hugh Culber’s death in Despite Yourself! Talk about bad optics.

So, yeah. That particular death scene was, I felt, a major misstep. What they choose to do with it going forward will be revealed in the coming weeks, I’m sure.

On a more positive note, the episode is, from a production standpoint, a major step up from the Moffat era, as significant a change as the move to HD in the very late stages of the Tennant era. Jamie Childs’ direction, the new anamorphic lenses, and the 18:9 aspect ratio give the show a more cinematic look than before, and Segun Akinola’s score is a world away from Murray Gold’s more… up front sensibilities. It’s heavy on synthesizer and reverb, giving the already dark episode an eerie, spooky feel.

And of course, no discussion of the music would be complete without the theme tune, which finally shows up at the end, with the classic cliffhanger scream introduced in the 1970s, before segueing into Akinola’s take on the main theme. Like Gold’s first version, there’s samples of Delia Derbyshire’s original version, but that’s about where the similarities end. The Derbyshire melody samples are drenched in reverb and, to my ears, mixed in with extra synth parts. The bassline is there, but rendered primarily in loud, metallic-sounding drum hits with a deep, pad-like synth accompanying that. I can’t really talk about the credit sequence, as there were no opening titles, and the closing credits were… well, blurred. I can’t really say what they are, except they seem to be dark and avant garde.

To sum up? I’m glad I watched it twice, as I enjoyed it more without BBC America’s insistence on 10 minutes of commercials for every 10 minutes of show. While it’s not The Eleventh Hour good, I think it’s a solid start to what looks to be an excellent series. Onwards and upwards!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑