The RTD Rewind: The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances

I want to talk for a bit about something that’s been sticking in my craw for the past ten years or so, and it can be summed up in two words delivered by Christopher Eccleston at the end of part two of this story: “Everybody lives.”

In later years, Moffat gained a reputation among certain communities of Doctor Who fandom (okay, fine, it was Tumblr) as being the guy whom your favorite characters could never be safe around, because he would always kill them off. And the list, admittedly, is quite long: Amy, Rory, the Eleventh, War, and Twelfth Doctors, Clara, Danny, Bill, and River all die at some point during his time writing on the show, just not exactly in that order.

And I get why he got that reputation, because I was one of the people who advanced it! It’s been ten years and I stillhaven’t gotten over The Time of the Doctor! But what I’ve come to realize, now that his era is within the rearview mirror and I’ve spent the past four years writing about it critically, is that we’ve all been missing something obvious, like the Doctor not realizing Rory is alive until halfway through a monologue.

Yes, people die in a Moffat story. But they also live, and more to the point, they live happily: Amy and Rory die of old age in New York but live good lives in the meantime, Clara dies in the Trap Street but steals a TARDIS and runs away as a functional immortal with an infinite amount of wiggle room to spare, the Doctors regenerate with smiles on their faces, Danny gets to be a soldier one last time, Bill meets up with Heather and becomes a water goddess, River gets saved to the computer of the biggest library in the universe.

And even before the new series, in his very first Doctor Who screen credit, the Hugh Grant Doctor regenerates into Joanna Lumley and walks off arm in arm with Jonathan Pryce’s Master, apparently retiring into becoming… well, at a guess, a museum curator. What Moffat loves is a happy ending, no matter how he gets there.

And this story is pretty much the poster child (pun not intended) for happy endings. Strip away the science-fiction trappings and this story, at its heart, is a lost little boy looking for and then eventually finding his mom. Who hasn’t been in a similar situation? Hell, Sydney Newman, one of the creators of the show, once produced a short film set in the Canadian National Exhibition where a little boy goes off to explore, gets lost, and is reunited with his parents at the end! This is Johnny at the Fair, only 90 minutes long and crossed with a horror movie.

Really, you can watch all of Moffat’s Davies-era scripts and see which concepts and ideas he’ll return to in his own era, as I plan to do for the duration of the rewind. In this one we have glitchy technology, the weapons forges of Villengard, jokes about the sonic screwdriver being used to build cabinets, children being creepy, abandoned places that turn out to not be abandoned after all, body horror, nanogenes, and monsters that turn out to not be monsters at all. Also, lots and lots of quippy one-liners, just like in all of his sitcoms. (He was apparently a huge fan of American comedy, and that really shows in his approach to dialogue.)

What makes these episodes sing for me, beyond the echoes of the future past, is why the ending happens. Jamie only gets reunited with his mother when she finally accepts that’s what she is, rather than continuing to insist on the lie about being his sister. Elizabeth Sandifer framed it in terms of sexual liberation, and that’s the reading the story is definitely going for (dancing as a metaphor for sex is about as subtle as an anvil to the face) but I’d argue there’s another layer to that: the freedom to be one’s true self, in any and all forms that may take.

In the queer community, there is this thing called the closet. The closet is a multi-faceted thing: it can be a place where a person grows into themselves, much like a caterpillar becomes a butterfly by cocooning itself into a chrysalis. It can be a refuge in unsafe environments, and it can be a prison. To come out of the closet, in one sense, means throwing yourself out into the world for all to see, with no more barriers or obstacles keeping you inside.

It’d be a little much to suggest that this story is a giant metaphor for coming out of the closet, but it is a metaphor for one of the things doing that can lead to. Part of staying in the closet can involve things like marrying a woman if you’re a gay man, or vice versa, or choosing not to correct anyone when they deadname or misgender you because they don’t know any better. Or it can simply be repressing one’s true feelings in the hopes that it’ll go away, as with Mr. Lloyd and his secret affair with the town butcher. Repression of that sort was very common in the 1940s, homosexuality was actually illegal in Britain until 1967, and even after, it was still frowned upon.

For another look at this idea, consider the movie Pleasantville. Released in 1998, it stars Tobey Macguire as a fan of a 1950s American sitcom. During a fight with his sister, the two of them get transported into the black and white world of the show and attempt to play their roles, which gets derailed when the sister, Jennifer, has sex with the boy she’s dating, introducing “dancing” into the show, and changing it in the process: The town and its citizens gradually transition to color over the course of the movie as more characters break free of their staid sitcom roles and become real people, embracing their own true selves.

As you might imagine, themes like embracing one’s potential resonate heavily with me: the Moffat era was my first era of Doctor Who, and it was there alongside me as I started questioning my gender identity, then eventually accepted that I was trans. And like Nancy here or the people in Pleasantville, I’ve been much happier ever since I stopped hiding and pretending to be a boy. I still can’t dance to save my life, but the good news is, that isn’t required for me to happy. I’m a transfemme enby wolf in a happy relationship with another transfemme enby wolf, and she loves me for me, dancing skills or no.

And that, I think, is why this story is my favorite of the Eccleston era: not just the writer, but the ending and the themes. It’s a very strong start to a twelve year career writing for the show, and while I’m not going to get my hopes up on a return for the second Davies era, let’s just say I wouldn’t be too shocked either. They’re the Lennon and McCartney of Who, those two.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑