There’s a particular structure to Doctor Who seasons, at least in the modern era. Call it the Davies Model, if you like: a present-day Earth story to start things off, a trip to an alien planet in the future, then a run through Earth’s past in Episode 3. Every season has featured some variations on this theme, but otherwise the general skeleton remains the same. Series 11 is no exception; last week we had our present-day Earth drama, now we have this.
We might as well start at the beginning, which means starting with the title sequence, as there’s no cold open to lead us into it. Showrunner Chibnall has spoken a lot about taking the show back to basics, from giving us a 4-person TARDIS team to bringing some of the old educational edict instituted by the program’s original creators. Apparently that approach even extends to the components of a given episode, as this is the first time a modern episode of Doctor Who has started with just the title sequence since Rose, all the way back in 2005. The idea of a cold open (or a pre-title sequence) was used sporadically during the classic days, but otherwise, the majority of those episodes began just like this.
So, the sequence itself then! It’s gorgeous to look at, starting with an amorphous purple shape as the opening bassline notes come in, which expands to fill the screen just as the main melody (the OOO-WEE-OOOH bits) begins. It’s rather similar in concept to the original 1963 title sequence actually, as the new one dispenses with all the usual trappings of a Doctor Who opening sequence for the basics: the names of our main cast (written in 2D gold, rather than in 3D), the logo, and other credits (producer, director, and story and author). No flying TARDIS, no vortex (unless the warped space effect after the logo flies offscreen counts), and it’s all over in about 36 seconds.
As for the theme? I mentioned it last week, but I’m going to talk about it again just because: Akinola’s take is a world away from Murray Gold’s loud and busy compositions, he strips it back to a bassline (a deep, menacing drone), and a melody, consisting of recycled Derbyshire samples with some reverb and additional synths. Not a hint of Gold-esque orchestrations in sight!
Okay, now I have to talk about the actual episode. Which is… well, better than the last one, at least in my estimation. Graham gets most of the comedy lines, and he’s certainly starting to warm up. Ryan’s dislike of ladders is a good nod to last week’s crane adventure (and his disability), as someone who hates stairs because of her bad knees, I can definitely relate. Yaz… well, Yaz exists. I’m glad to have a little bit of background on her, with her family, but I hope future episodes go into greater detail. I want to like her, but it’s a little hard when we know so little about her. And of course we have the Doctor herself, who continues to be generally wonderful and amazing. I’m a little surprised that the shades she handed Graham weren’t Twelve’s sonic sunglasses, but that’s just me nitpicking.
The guest cast are a mixed bag. Angstrom and Epzo are pretty good, Angstrom in particular is probably my favorite. Ilin… meh. Art Malik is probably a fine actor, but his performance here comes across as a man who is literally only there to collect a paycheck. He’s phoning it in, twice! (That’s a joke, since his character is a hologram and all.)
The plot is… well, it’s basically a romp. I wasn’t expecting the ghost monument to actually be the TARDIS, but looking back it was a pretty cool idea. It doesn’t seem quite so grim as last week’s episode did, the daylight shots certainly help with that, along with some of the Doctor’s more humorous comments. The cinematography and location work are breathtakingly beautiful, I look forward to seeing more of it next week.
I also liked the explanation of why the Doctor is against guns (the NRA is basically guaranteed to hate this episode, which is fine with me), and the resulting shootout/embarrassment of Ryan. Playing Call of Duty doesn’t mean you can jump into the middle of a firefight, dude.
Finally, we get to it: the TARDIS scene. From the moment I heard the first vworp, I knew what was coming. And oh goodness, the Doctor’s reaction to having her box back is a thing of beauty, evoking 11’s own scene in The Eleventh Hour. The cyan paint job is going to take some getting used to (I preferred the deeper blues of the Smith/Capaldi boxes), but otherwise? Good to see the old girl back again.
As for the new interior? I’d describe it as a crystalline version of the old Eccleston/Tennant console room. It works as a response to the design from the late Michael Pickwoad, but I think it could stand to be a little brighter, like Ed Thomas’ interior from series 5. The biscuit dispenser is cool though.
So, yeah: in my book. The Ghost Monument is a perfectly good episode of Doctor Who. Not flashy and clever, but solid and dependable. I liked it more than last week, so that’s something. Easy 8/10.
Rosa Parks though… that’s gonna be tricky.
Leave a Reply