Let’s talk about civil rights, shall we? I was going to start this review by talking about racism and its role in American history, politics, and culture, but then yesterday morning happened. More to the point, Trump fucked everything up, again. As he often does.
I woke up to the news that the US government, under his administration, has decided to change government policy in such a way that trans people like me are legislated out of existence. I said in my review of 11.1 that my experiences as a transgender woman would be the lens through which I view this series, and I intend to continue doing so. I can’t not, especially in regards to an episode about civil rights.
According to the New York Times article I read about the situation, “For the last year, the Department of Health and Human Services has privately argued that the term “sex” was never meant to include gender identity or even homosexuality, and that the lack of clarity allowed the Obama administration to wrongfully extend civil rights protections to people who should not have them.”(Emphasis mine)
Yes, really. The position of the government is that trans people should never have been granted civil rights protections in the first place, because we don’t deserve them. That’s just not wrong, it’s barbaric, cruel, and utterly evil. It is, in other words, this administration’s modus operandi, a phrase which here means “a method of causing as much misery as possible for a particular group of people.”
The conservatives have had many bugaboos over the course of American history. Today it’s transgender people. Before that it was immigrants, and before them it was Muslims, like my Saudi Arabian girlfriend, who is (like me) trans herself. During the 1980s it was gay people, and in the 1950s and 60s it was black people, like Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King Jr. For as long as this country has existed, these people have fought against the tide of progress! That’s why they’re called conservatives! They want to conserve the world where a cisgender straight white man has power over everybody else, AND DAMN THE PEOPLE THEY RUN OVER IN THEIR WAKE! IF EVERY SINGLE TRANSGENDER AMERICAN WERE TO KILL THEMSELVES RIGHT NOW, IN THE FACE OF RAMPANT, GOVERNMENT-SANCTIONED HATRED, THAT WOULD BE FINE WITH THE REPUBLICANS!
*takes deep breath* Anyway. This is the world in which this episode is airing. A story about America discriminating against a minority airs on television on the very day that America decides to, once again, discriminate against a minority. Here goes nothing.
So, then, the episode. Goddamn. I have never seen an episode of Doctor Who like this, ever. Not once. Part of this is because of who wrote it: Malorie Blackman, the first person of color to write for the series in 55 years. Which is a good thing, because it gives us episodes like this, and a bad thing, because it took 55 years to happen. Having Ryan get attacked, and face repeated racist comments throughout the episode, and have an uninterrupted conversation with Yaz about what it’s like to be a person of color in the UK in 2018, are all things a white writer couldn’t have managed. (Yes, Sarah Dollard did that bit in Thin Ice where the Doctor punches a racist asshole in the face because he made racist remarks toward Bill, and their discussion about racism at the top of that episode is worlds away from the bullshit Gareth Roberts did in The Shakespeare Code, but that is not the point.)
Usually, Doctor Who works in allegories, but not today. Blackman, as in her story “The Ripple Effect,” (a 7th Doctor short story with peace-loving Daleks) gives us a story about small ripples, and how those ripples have consequences. Krasko isn’t an alien monster, he’s just a out-and-out racist who looks and speaks exactly like someone from 1955, or hell, 20 fucking 18.
And more importantly, Blackman strips the show of its tendency to end stories like these with a “it gets better” by pointing out that yes, in 53 years, America will elect its first black president, but racism doesn’t end because Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat. That president had to deal with a certain loudmouthed racist asshole claiming he was born in Kenya, and was actually a Muslim. In Georgia, right goddamn now, the Secretary of State is engaging in real life voter suppression against black people’s right to vote. Partly because he’s running against a black woman, but also because he’s a fucking racist.
Granted, yes. America’s situation in 2018 is, in some ways, much better than it was in 1955. But in other ways, things haven’t changed one bit. There will always be racists who think it’s perfectly okay to discriminate against black people. And there will always be white people who stand to benefit from a system that puts whites over blacks, which is the other key point Blackman emphasized.
Let’s focus for a bit on the Doctor and Graham. Putting aside the Doctor’s gender (though the line about still getting used to being called ma’am is something I can easily sympathize with), she’s white. Graham is also white. Both of them benefit from the privilege that comes with being white, and they know it. They aren’t happy about it, of course, but they still benefit. The narrative refuses to let the Doctor, a white woman, be the hero. She has to sit there, on that bus, and be complicit. What an image.
Going in, my thoughts basically could be described as “Don’t fuck this up, don’t fuck this up, don’t fuck this up.” And to everyone’s credit, they didn’t fuck it up. This, rightly, will go down as probably the best episode of the season. Blackman needs to come back next year. I know I’d welcome her particular brand of writing again.
But… this wasn’t the right episode for the moment. Not for me, anyway. Because like I wrote at the top of the essay, I woke up yesterday to the news that my government wants to deny me my right to exist as a human being, as someone with civil rights. I mean, if we’re going to do a celebrity historical about a black woman, why not do Marsha P. Johnson at Stonewall in 1969? Sure, it’ll never happen so long as this show is still run by white cis straight men, but that’s another argument for another time.
I’m white. But I’m also trans. And right now I needed a story about a trans woman. Someone like me. I didn’t get that. That’s not the story’s fault, it’s not anyone’s fault, except maybe the people at the BBC who choose to schedule these things, and even that isn’t really true, since no one could’ve predicted what the Trump administration would’ve said yesterday.
But I can make all the excuses I want. At the end of the day, it wasn’t the story I needed. To quote El Sandifer, whose opinion I value quite highly, “I need a story that can save me. I need a story that can save my brothers and my sisters; the ones who are actually dying out there. Who are being murdered for looking at the wrong person, who are suffering without necessary medical care, or who just can’t take another day of being afraid someone will beat them for having to pee. Instead I got a story about small changes that might have significant effects some day. A story that blatantly says that the people upon whose neck the boot is resting cannot be saved right now and are going to endure a hard and difficult life, and whose prize is that the next generation can be slightly less brutalized by the police and maybe even allowed to be one.” (Emphasis mine, again)
That’s not what I want out of this show. Not right now. I am not content with waiting until tomorrow. The bullies aren’t going to wait until tomorrow. Why the hell should I?
Give me a story that shows me how to fight NOW, and then we’ll talk.
Rating: 10/10, but only because they succeeded in not fucking up the whole race thing. And not turning it into a “white woman solves racism” plot.
Leave a Reply