FINALLY! What we have here, for my money, is easily Chibnall’s best script of the series, at least so far. Unlike his first two episodes this year, this one doesn’t run around with a bunch of half-formed plot ideas that ultimately go nowhere. It’s tight and focused, telling one complete story and leaving it at that. It’s also probably his scariest script yet, especially if, like Ryan, you’re not big on spiders.
I mean really, I honestly can’t believe that this is the same guy who gave us the muddled romp that was The Ghost Experiment. This feels more like the guy who wrote Broadchurch. His take on Yaz’s family is delightful, they feel like real people. The sibling dynamic Yaz has with her sister reminds me very much of my own with my brother, if reversed (I’m the older sister, not the younger).
What I also liked was the honest take given to Graham and Ryan in regards to Grace’s death. The scene with Graham standing alone in a darkened house, haunted (literally) by the ghost of his wife was heartbreaking, I’ve been in that exact situation before, so I know just how he felt. The subsequent scene of him and Ryan walking through the ballroom discussing family was beautiful, Ryan’s unspoken implication that Graham is proper family (whereas his dad isn’t) is worlds away from where they were at the start of the series, and I love that.
And of course, there’s Jodie, who continues to show us more of her Doctor as the weeks go by. At points (especially when she thinks she’s saying goodbye at the start) she echoes Ten, while at others (the purple sofa scene) she felt like a more restrained Eleven. Then there’s her heartbreak when she discovers what happened to the mother spider, and her anger toward Robertson, who I’ll get to in a moment. She may not have Peter Capaldi’s attack eyebrows anymore, but she can still be terrifying when she’s mad.
And now, Robertson. Played by an actual American for once, Law & Order’s Chris Noth, he’s a hotelier and businessman with eyes on running for president in 2020. And like a certain orange-faced tyrant, he’s cold, callous, and doesn’t take responsibility for the things his company does, blaming it on others. His resemblance to Trump (who gets name dropped, causing Robertson recoil and say “Please don’t say that name”, suggests they have a history, and a rivalry) is definitely intentional. I mean, you could replace Robertson’s character with Trump and the script wouldn’t change one bit. While I very much doubt we’ll be seeing him again after this week, it wouldn’t be hard to guess what his administration would be like.
And of course, the spiders. Damn, that was creepy, especially with how large they got as the episode went on. I’m not exactly arachnophobic myself, but seeing spiders as big as vans freaked me out to no end. As an enemy they were excellent (and better than killer bedsheets).
Of course, I can’t talk about the spiders without talking about the resolution. I just don’t like that the Doctor’s apparent solution to the problem is to kill the spiders, rather than, I dunno, shrink them back down to normal size or something. It’s the same inconsistent morality problem that Ghost Monument had.
Second of all, exactly what is his problem with resolving conflicts? It’s like he just realizes he only has 5 minutes left so he has to put his toys away and does nothing to actually end the story. Robertson just waltzes off, and the Doctor just stands there and glares at him. Uh, hello?! What happened to the Time Lord who took down Harriet Jones or Helen A?!
Third of all, another week, another dead lesbian. I mean Jesus Christ, what a comedown after a season where we had a black lesbian as the fucking companion. CHRIS. IT ISN’T 1998 ANYMORE. QUIT KILLING YOUR LESBIANS. If this is his idea of LGBT representation then I don’t know why he bothered.
That said, I really do enjoy that ending TARDIS scene. The best part of any first series with a new Doctor is watching the companions agree to travel with the Doctor, and Chibnall (as well as our four regulars) pull it off brilliantly. The Doctor’s ecstatic grin as they accept is a joy to behold, and I especially like the sight of all four of them pulling the dematerialization lever as we cut to credits.
Honestly, aside from Chibnall’s apparent problem with effective resolutions, I stand by what I said at the start: this is easily his best script yet. If he can pull this off for the rest of the series, I’ll be very pleased.
Ranking: 9/10.
Leave a Reply