Well. That was certainly an episode of television. It was mildly entertaining, and unlike the other solo Chibnall scripts this year it actually contained this marvelous invention called a “resolution,” in which all the major elements of the episode (the fatal disease the general has, the pregnant man about to give birth, the monster) are all dealt with by the time the credits roll. Certainly the best part was the bit exploring Ryan’s absent father, and his insistence on Yoss being there for his son.
The male pregnancy thing is an interesting topic to cover, but I don’t entirely get why it’s treated as something that happens in the distant future when it’s happening right now, in 2018. Trans men exist, people. Matt Strevens was continuously insisting that there was lots of LGBTQ representation this year, but I don’t know. I’m just not seeing it. Two offscreen lesbians who are dead and a pregnant man who could be trans but probably wasn’t, on top of erasure of non-binary identities with the insistence that people on Yoss’ planet give birth to children who are the same gender as their parents, without any sort of variation is just frustrating. I mean, what if Yoss’ son decides to experiment with femininity? Apparently the gender binary is strictly enforced on that planet. I sure wouldn’t want to live there.
I didn’t really like the Pting. Or rather, I thought it was well-realized (the CG this year is top notch), but I didn’t really get the whole “this is a deadly horrible monster and we’re all gonna die because there’s no way to stop it.” It looks, and acts, more like a mildly annoying pest than a fearsome creature. Honestly, it feels more like it was thrown in there so Character Options can have a toy to release for the Christmas shopping season. It’s like the apparently deadly water from Ghost Monument. If you can’t actually show me why this thing is deadly, I’m not going to believe that it is. I’m a Missouri girl, we call my state the Show-Me State for a reason. Don’t just tell us something, give us evidence!
There was absolutely no point at which I felt like the characters were danger. I didn’t even expect the LifePod to explode, but apparently they’re made of the same material that bridge consoles are made of on Star Trek. Kind of a shitty escape pod then, if they just kill their occupants. They say they’re near an asteroid field, but no asteroids ever show up. They say the ship will blow up after 3 dismissals… but the bomb is delayed just long enough for the Doctor and Yaz to trick the Pting into eating it.
Even the cinematography is boring, but that’s mostly due to the boring, Abrams-Trek design of the sets. I will say the navigation room does slightly resemble the TARDIS console room (and might actually make for a better interior than what we actually have), which is neat, if only so Jodie has a room to pace around.
Oh god, poor Jodie… I don’t like the way she’s treated in this episode. First she continually insists that she has to get back to the TARDIS right freaking now even though it’s in a SPACE JUNKYARD, AND IS PROBABLY FINE. The chief medic calls her selfish, which while not wrong, seems somewhat out of character, not unlike the entirely unearned conclusion in Ghost Monument that they’re all gonna die because the TARDIS didn’t show up at that exact moment. Jodie does her best to sell the material, but honestly, there’s just not much for her to sink her teeth into. She calls herself the Doctor several times, but the script doesn’t seem especially interested in, you know, letting her be the Doctor. (And, tall man shouting down at a woman who is shorter than he is? Really fucking bad optics.)
You know what this episode reminds me of? Time Heist. They’re the 5th episodes of their respective series, the set is a series of boring white corridors, and the stakes don’t really seem especially high even if the script insists they are. And what’s more? They’re entirely forgettable.
5/10.
Leave a Reply