If there’s one thing that can be said about historical episodes in the Chibnall era, it’s that they are the closest the show has come to doing a standard pure historical since 1982’s Black Orchid. Sure, Rosa was more of the celebrity variation that was introduced in the Davies era, but it also wasn’t a romp like those episodes were. Neither is this one.
I, being a white woman from the American Midwest, have precisely zero place to talk about how well the partition of India was treated in the episode. I didn’t even hear about it until this week, for crying out loud! But, much like Rosa, I can say (given the evidence presented and a bit of background research courtesy of this Radio Times article) that the subject matter was serious indeed. Again, not exactly a fun romp.
Weirdly, this episode makes me think of Father’s Day, Paul Cornell’s Ninth Doctor story in which the Doctor and Rose go back to 1987 (40 years after this episode took place!), and Rose prevents her father’s death, setting off time paradoxes. On both occasions, there’s a tearful death scene for a guest character at the end: Pete Tyler, and Yaz’s nan’s first husband. Unlike Father’s Day, there isn’t really a villain here (except maybe the British government). The titular demons were assassins, but at about the halfway mark it’s revealed they became mourners of the lost instead.
No, the closest thing this episode has to an antagonist is the British government and Prem’s brother Manish, who tries to prevent the marriage mentioned at the top of the episode and, when that doesn’t work, has his brother murdered. And, as with Father’s Day, the Doctor can’t do anything to stop it, lest she prevent Yaz from being born. (Those two are so in love.) But, like with Rosa, given the subject matter having anything like sci-fi aliens responsible for the conflict of the episode would’ve been extremely inappropriate.
Mandip Gill, of course, is fantastic. She remains my favorite of the companions, and it’s a crying shame she’s barely had any focus this year. I hope she sticks around for another series so we can see more of her.
Also: Credit must be given to Segun Akinola for swapping his synthesizers for Indian classical music instruments with this. It’s good to have orchestral music back in modern Doctor Who again, even if Akinola’s take is still very different from Murray Gold. Bonus points for recording at Abbey Road and drenching the score in that studio’s very particular reverb sound, and his one-off variation on the theme tune, arranged in the style of the incidental music. Shame the next time trailer was blocking it… I hope it comes out on a future soundtrack.
The strengths of the Chibnall era seem to be from its guest writers. Vinay Patel gives us a gorgeously shot, beautifully scored, well-written episode that, while it doesn’t feel like a typical Doctor Who historical, is probably tied with Rosa for best episode of the season. I adored it, and I want him to come back next year.
Ranking: 10/10.
Leave a Reply