The RTD Rewind: Tooth and Claw

Building on my thing from last week about series 2 sequel-izing series 1, Tooth and Claw now serves as something of a sequel to The Unquiet Dead, taking place a decade or so after that story, and featuring an important British historical figure, in this case Victoria. But a key difference here is how Rose interacts with the historical world. In The Unquiet Dead she dressed in a period-accurate outfit, this time she doesn’t. At this point she doesn’t need to, becoming the Bad Wolf means she has ascended to the Doctor’s level. (True she wasn’t exactly fitting in Victorian Cardiff either, clothes aside, but then it was more out of being new to this whole time travel thing.)

In a way, it reminds me of the shift that happens for Clara Oswald in between, say, The Crimson Horror and The Girl Who Died: in the former, Clara and the Doctor both wear Victorian clothes and generally try to fit in, while in the latter, Clara spends most of the story in the Doctor’s orange spacesuit, even taking on his role in proceedings when she and Ashildr get abducted onto Odin’s ship.

Rose, in many ways, reminds me a lot of Clara: both characters start off as being perfectly ordinary women in their respective debut seasons, only to eventually break free of that and become the Doctor’s equal. The difference is how Davies and Moffat treat that shift: Moffat embraces it, giving Clara a TARDIS and a companion of her own to travel eternity with, while Davies shuts it all down, first by having the Ninth Doctor re-absorb the vortex energy Rose took, killing him in the process, then separating her from him permanently.

In effect, Clara’s arc across series 7, 8, and 9 is a more thoughtful version of Rose’s, and the show stretches itself (as Darren Mooney phrased it in a Twitter thread) to accommodate her. Not even Rose got that much. Davies believed only a man could be the Doctor, Moffat dared to ask, “Why not a woman?”

This separation is built up to slowly. In Tooth and Claw, this manifests in their attitude toward the adventure of the week, in this case a historical. It starts off with Rose making various attempts at having Queen Victoria say “We are not amused,” and continues throughout the episode, eventually reaching such a fever pitch that Victoria elects to exile both of them from the country and start up an institute to fight against alien monsters, including the Doctor themself.

The Doctor and Rose, of course, shrug it off. At episode’s end the two of them are walking back to the TARDIS joking and laughing as though they just had a splendid afternoon at a living-history museum, like a British version of Colonial Williamsburg, rather than spending an evening with (some) real historical figures who were all in some amount of peril. I mean, they were safe, and seeing as we’re following their adventures, isn’t that good enough?

I don’t think so. My personal belief is that the Doctor has a responsibility to treat their adventures with some amount of decency, whether they happen on contemporary Earth, the future, or the past. Sure, Nine was pleased to see Charles Dickens in The Unquiet Dead (set a decade earlier), but when the Gelth turned up, he didn’t pull the same type of Nightmare Fetishism that Ten does here.

To Davies’ credit, his script is very much aware of this. His intent is to show that the historical romps the Doctor and their companions engage in aren’t fun for the people caught up in the middle of it. From Victoria’s perspective, the Doctor and Rose are a couple of random people with some exceptionally weird ideas as to what constitutes a good time, and she is entirely right to punish them for it.

According to Shannon Patrick Sullivan,

“At one point, Davies contemplated surprising the viewers by having the werewolf kill Queen Victoria. This would then be the event which would cause the creation of the parallel universe to which the TARDIS would be drawn in the pivotal Rise Of The Cybermen / The Age Of Steel later in the season. However, Davies became concerned that this ongoing storyline would be too difficult for casual viewers to follow, and decided to drop the idea.”

It’s almost too bad this didn’t happen, it would’ve provided much colder dose of reality than merely being expelled from the UK. (Which means nothing in practice anyway, given that the Doctor is a time traveling alien who can change their face, and Rose is a British citizen by birth.)

If it sounds like I’m not being as hard on this story as my readers have come to expect, there’s a very good reason for that: it’s an enjoyable episode! Davies has a gift for writing compelling television, as the success of the revival and all of his post-Who projects will attest.

Early on in the story’s development process, (again from Sullivan)

“Davies suggested this concept to a writer new to Doctor Who to develop, resulting in a commission in early 2005. Ignoring the werewolf and monk elements, the writer developed a storyline set at Buckingham Palace involving an alien insect getting in Queen Victoria’s eye. This was not what the production team wanted and the storyline was rejected.”

Faced with this set-back, he went and wrote the entire episode himself at the last minute, and here we are. I have to admire his sheer skill at being able to hammer out a decent script at the same pace as a college student writing a six-page paper 6 hours before class and managing to make it look like he’d been working on it for two weeks.

Oh yeah, and it’s got a freaking werewolf. How can I not love it? I’m a wolf! Sure, the werewolf is the story’s antagonist, (this tends to happen in werewolf-themed productions, given humans and their centuries-old fear of wolves that is so deeply embedded into the culture that it’s more of a surprise when a werewolf is a good guy) but I’ll take what I can get.

As you might imagine, I’ve always been a big proponent of wolf activism and representation. The alien werewolf featured here is only the second one in the whole show, after Mags from The Greatest Show in the Galaxy. Mags later came back for some Big Finish audios that explored her character and home planet in greater detail, and I really wish RTD had done something similar for the Tooth and Claw wolf, but alas, it was not to be.

Next time: we move on from werewolves to our natural enemy, the vampire bat. And also, everyone’s favorite 1970s companion returns, and is rewarded with her very own spin-off series!

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑