The Mactíre Anthology: Kerblam Review

I had such high hopes for the episode. And to be fair, from a construction standpoint it’s fantastic. It doesn’t suffer from the lack of resolution issues so many episodes of this series have. From a plot standpoint it’s somewhere between Planet of the Ood with echoes of The Beast Below in the design of the delivery bots. For crying out loud, it gave us a scene featuring Jodie in a fez, and that was wonderful. The killer bubble wrap idea was clever (not least because it was used in the show for the Wirrn back in the 1970s). It had the same political bent that gave us stories like Kill the Moon, Oxygen, and The Zygon Invasion/Inversion. The scene with Yaz and Dan was genuinely touching (even if I could tell from the moment we saw his necklace he was going to die).

There’s just one thing keeping it from being one of the best episodes of the season, and that’s something that was pointed out in the Whovian sections of Twitter: the last seven minutes. More specifically, the scene in the parking garage.

Let’s lay things out: Charlie the maintenance boy has just been revealed as the guy responsible for killing his own crush, Kira. Why? Because he’s angry about automation taking away the jobs of ordinary people, and he’s afraid that soon, no one will have work. He states, “People of my generation, we change things. We make things happen.” His actor, Leo Flanagan, looks to be about my age, so he’d be a millennial. He knows Kerblam is corrupt, much like its real-life counterpart Amazon, and he wants to change it. But the narrative casts him as the villain.

I mean, what the hell?! It’s screamingly obvious Kerblam is the problem here, not the workers! Sure, Charlie’s plan was extreme, and the Doctor rightly calls him out on that, but that doesn’t negate his point! Look at Dan, he only gets to see his daughter about twice a year because of how much of his life is taken up by his job! Or Kira, who has resigned herself to a life utter misery if it means making sure other people are happy. If Mathieson or Harness were writing this, the Doctor would’ve had Kerblam shut down.

But no. The narrative decides that it’s my generation who are the problem, and the Doctor makes a speech against it. She, the champion of the dispossessed, who once brought down a police state simply by showing up (The Happiness Patrol) and inspired a rebellion among the workers on a planet that was taxed to death (The Sunmakers) decides to instead stand on the side of Jeff Bezos and Amazon, AND ENDORSES IT. This is, to paraphrase someone on Twitter, the equivalent of letting a member of the Thatcher administration write the last episode of Happiness Patrol. It’s even worse than writing a Trump stand-in and then just LETTING HIM WALK OFFSCREEN WITH NO PUNISHMENT.

It’s funny that this episode happened to air on Steven Moffat’s birthday. Because for all the criticisms people have about his writing style, you at least knew what he stood for. You knew that the Doctor, no matter what the circumstances, would always be the Doctor. Series 10, and his entire era in general, was all about the Doctor taking down corrupt systems. More to the point, it was about (as El Sandifer likes to say) rejecting one story, and telling a different and better one. It was about hope.

But this story was not about hope. It didn’t feature the Doctor taking down Amazon, as she would’ve done if this were a Moffat or a Harness or a Mathieson script. It wasn’t about rejecting one story and telling a better one. It was about sucking up and dealing with the shitty situation that you’re in, because “We’ve all got to work, right?”

So, yeah. It’s funny this aired on Moffat’s birthday, because this episode was 100% the antithesis of everything that era, and Doctor Who in general, stands for.

It is, in other words, the pinnacle of the Chibnall era. It is, perhaps, the episode that best communicates what this period of the show will be about: “Things are terrible right now. And they’re just going to keep on being terrible. Sure, it might get better in the future, if enough people work to make it happen, but don’t hedge your bets.”

This is Doctor Who in 2018. This is fucking atrocious. I mean, Fear Her was better than this. FEAR HER.

All I can say is, next week had better be good, because I am very close to writing off this entire era.

Ranking: 0/10.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑