This week on Doctor Who, I suffer a sudden case of middle school flashbacks! Overhead projector behind the Doctor in the physics class scenes? Yup. Animal dissection? Got it, but that was American high school and we did jellyfish and frogs. Giant headphones that are uncomfortable to wear for extended periods of time? Yup. Detention instead of recess? Yup. Giant non-flatscreen desktop computers? Oh yeah, and they probably ran the professional version of Windows XP, since that was the Windows OS du jour back in 2006. And lest I forget, spectacularly unhealthy school lunches that would’ve given Michelle Obama an aneurysm had this aired 3 years later. Sounds like my school days, alright!
Anyway, moving on: in the first Back to the Eleventh Hour book I wrote that this story was better than Vampires of Venice, albeit mainly because of Sarah Jane Smith. That was some time ago though, and in that time I’ve since revised my opinion: Reunion is actually a somewhat worse version of Vampires, albeit one enlivened by the aforementioned return. (I kid you not, I teared up. Thanks, estrogen!)
Let’s do a quick rundown of what both stories have in common: the Doctor and his lovebird companions investigate strange goings-on at a school run by creatures who, for budget reasons, appear mainly human. They’re even somewhat vampiric! (The Krillitane look like giant bats, the Saturnians have big fangs and drink the blood of the innocent.) The Doctor even has a one-on-one chat with the vampiric creatures’ “human” faces, respectively Mr. Finch and Rosanna Calvierri. So, given all the similarities, why is one bad and the other isn’t?
For me, the sticking point is the biggest thing the two stories share: a love triangle in which the Doctor is involved. In Vampires, the Doctor spends the bulk of the story trying to repair Amy and Rory’s relationship, which Rory believes is on the rocks because the Doctor took his fiancée away on the night before the ceremony andkissed her. The Doctor, in his eleventh incarnation, has the emotional intelligence to realize he fucked up and so does his best to make amends, culminating in Amy inviting Rory to join her on the TARDIS with the Doctor, which Rory accepts.
In School Reunion, it’s the complete opposite: the Doctor is the middle of the triangle, while Rose and Sarah Jane are both competing for his affections. Which from Rose’s perspective makes sense, she’s been framed as the Doctor’s significant other since they held hands in The End of the World, but Sarah Jane? Not our Sarah Jane. She is his best friend, and that’s that.
If there is a way in which Sarah’s part of the triangle can be said to work, it’s this: by returning to the show and confronting the Doctor about leaving her behind for so long, she becomes the original Girl Who Waited. Amy met the Doctor as a young girl and then waited 12 years for him to come back, Sarah waited 30 and had to somehow get from Aberdeen to Croydon. And, both times, Amy and Sarah Jane castigated the Doctor for keeping them waiting so long. (And if that wasn’t enough, it crops up next week too…) Shame they never met on screen, they would’ve gotten along instantly.
And speaking of Sarah Jane: it is impossible to watch this episode, and the themes it deals with, without remembering Elisabeth Sladen’s death in April 2011, a few days before the series 6 premiere. It was a heart-breaking moment that sent waves of sadness throughout the fandom, even more than Nicholas Courtney’s death two months earlier, because she’d touched every generation of fandom: from the older crowd who’d been there to see her with Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker in the 1970s, to those who’d grown up on the new series and saw her not just in this story, but in the spin-off series that bore her name. Her death was huge.
What this story is ultimately about, leaving aside the romantic undertones and the British Buffy aesthetic of the plot, is the Doctor finally comes back for someone, and he has to deal with the consequences. In a way, this is kind of what would happen if the Doctor ever came back for Susan, but that story will never be told: no one but the anorakiest anorak is asking for it, and if The Timeless Children and Attack of the Cybermen taught us anything, it’s that pleasing the anoraks never ends well. That, and Ford is primarily remembered these days for being one of the last remaining links we have for the show’s earliest years, she hasn’t been relevant since 1964.
Sarah Jane, at least, had popular appeal: she was the companion of the classic series, to the point that when he took over in 1980, producer John Nathan-Turner asked Sladen if she’d like to come back to appear with Peter Davison. She said no, but still: it says something that after such a seismic shift as the Baker-Davison transition, JNT figured the audience would need someone familiar to latch on to, and also take some of the heat off Davison. Who better than her?
And make no mistake about it, bringing her back for the revival was one of the smartest things RTD ever did. She’s clearly glad to be back, and her chemistry with David Tennant really makes you yearn for an alternate universe where it was her, Rose, and Ten traveling together for the remainder of series 2. Swap this and New Earth in the running order and it could almost work as a season premiere! (Also, watching Sarah get possessed by Cassandra would be absolutely hilarious. It really is like the 1970s again!)
But alas, it was not to be. Sarah Jane stays home on Earth and becomes a mom to an alien genius boy, then winds up investigating all things alien and strange, crossing paths with the Doctor only rarely. Her companion days are over, as she tells the Doctor toward the end, when he’s coming within a hair’s breadth of deciding he doeshave the right to crack the Skasis code: “Everything has its time, and everything ends.”
Seven words that have cut even more deeply since April 19th, 2011. All things must pass, but some things pass too swiftly, and too soon.
But one thing will never change: she’ll always be our Sarah Jane Smith.
May she rest in peace.
Leave a Reply