The last time I watched this one, I spent most of the post complaining about the ending. But I was new to this whole media criticism bit back then, and while I’ve always been one to let my feelings influence my writing, looking back on the old post, I kind of cringe a bit. I still don’t like the ending, but I can see where Rose is coming from: she hasn’t got her own father anymore, and doesn’t want Tommy to experience life without a dad. She has good intentions.
Despite that though, Tommy was absolutely right to say good riddance, and no amount of kind words of rebuke from Rose or judging stares from the Doctor will change that. But let’s move along, we have bigger fish to fry.
The last time I wrote about this, I described the story as being underwhelming, but watching it now for this project I’ve come away with a completely different opinion on it: rubbish ending aside, it’s still a very good episode about domestic abuse and the rise of fascism in places where we least expect it.
I want to focus on a couple of key scenes here: first, the scene inside the Connelly house where the Doctor and Rose show up to investigate, posing as government officials. Euros Lyn absolutely saturates this story with Dutch angles, and this scene is a particularly good example, making Eddie look big and imposing while making his family look small and trodden-on. This is not a happy family home, it’s like a twisted version of the Cleaver house on Leave It to Beaver.
But then the Doctor shows up, and all of a sudden things start to shift: the Doctor is shot from the waist up more often than not, while Eddie is shot from above. He’s not in control anymore, the Doctor is, and he knows it. The dynamic in the house has changed, and he doesn’t like it one bit.
Then there’s the dialogue:
EDDIE: All the warnings I’ve given you, and every time, every time, you disobey me.
TOMMY: We can’t just lock her away.
EDDIE: Excuse me, sunshine. I am talking. You can forget that college nonsense. You’re going to come and work alongside me. Get your hands dirty for once.
(Thump.)
RITA: Oh lord, won’t she ever stop?
EDDIE: There, there, Rita, my sweet. Business as usual. Now let’s get these up all over the house in honour of her Majesty.
RITA: But Eddie, what if she’s dying?
EDDIE: I am talking! That’s better. A little bit of hush.
Not gonna lie, this sequence was difficult to watch. I was raised in an abusive household growing up, and while the circumstances are very different (in my house it was my mother who did the abusing) I can still see something of my childhood in this: my mother, looming over me and shouting in my face, while I felt like the smallest person in the world. It’s an awful way to grow up, and unlike Tommy here, I didn’t have the Doctor to come to my rescue… at least not in person.
Here’s the thing about abusive parents, for those of you who didn’t have any: at the end of the day, it’s all about control. Control of what you do every day, control of what you’re allowed to say, control of who you hang out with. And if you dare to talk back or do anything that goes against the rules, you’re swiftly punished for it.
I’ll give you a quick example: Unlike the kids I knew when I was Tommy’s age, I never went to anyone’s house. If I saw my friends at all it was at school, the rest of the time I was expected to be back at home, working on homework or whatever else. I learned pretty quickly there wasn’t any point in asking my mom if I could go over to someone’s house, because if I did she’d just tell me no. So, I went through my school days pretty much completely isolated from my peers.
But that changed when I got to high school and got my first iPod touch. Around that time, I discovered messaging programs (AIM and Skype were the biggest) and since my iPod could install apps, I now had a way of connecting with people I met online, and more to the point, a way of doing that without parental knowledge or involvement. My family computer privileges were strictly limited to two hours at a time, but the iPod? Not at all. That thing became more than just a music player, it became the social outlet I never had in elementary and middle school.
So of course, whenever I got in trouble at home, my mother would take my iPod away from me for a few days, until she decided I’d learned my lesson. Sometimes she’d do that and ban me from the computer unless I needed it for schoolwork. She may not have physically abused me, but she’s damn good at emotional and psychological torment.
All of this is to say that it felt extremely cathartic to watch the Doctor and Rose take turns calling Eddie out on his bullshit, and doubly so when Rita puts his suitcase on the ground and tells him to GTFO. I hope I can channel similar energy when I move out of my mother’s house in a few months.
Moving along, let’s take a look at the other scene in the episode I really liked: the one where Tommy finally calls Eddie out and accuses him of being a coward:
EDDIE: Shut your face, you, whoever you are. We can handle this ourselves. Listen, you little twerp. You’re hardly out of the blooming’ cradle, so I don’t expect you to understand. But I’ve got a position to maintain. People round here respect me. It matters what people think.
TOMMY: Is that why you did it, dad?
EDDIE: What do you mean? Did what?
TOMMY: You ratted on Gran. How else would the police know where to look, unless some coward told them
EDDIE: How dare you! Do you think I fought a war just so a mouthy little scum like you could call me a coward?
TOMMY: You don’t get it, do you? You fought against fascism, remember? People telling you how to live, who you could be friends with, who you could fall in love with, who could live and who had to die. Don’t you get it? You were fighting so that little twerps like me could do what we want, say what we want. Now you’ve become just like them. You’ve been informing on everyone, haven’t you? Even Gran. All to protect your precious reputation.
RITA: Eddie is that true?
EDDIE: I did it for us, Rita. She was filthy. A filthy, disgusting thing!
RITA: She’s my mother. All the others you informed on, all the people in our street, our friends.
EDDIE: I had to. I, I did the right thing.
RITA: The right thing for us or for you, Eddie? You go, Tommy. Go with the Doctor and do some good. Get away from this house, it’s poison. We had a ruddy monster under this roof, all right, but it weren’t my mother!
This, honestly, is my favorite part of the whole episode. If anything, it speaks to me even louder now than it did in 2019, now that we live in a world where Roe v. Wade is dead and state governments across the US are now empowering ordinary people, like our Eddie here, to inform on their neighbors if they’re suspected of having an abortion. That’s not the kind of thing that happens in democracies, but it definitely happened in Stalin’s Russia and Hitler’s Germany, and is now happening in post-Trump America.
This is how fascism grows. It starts with people informing on other people, and goes on from there. It starts off slowly then happens all at once, as those doing the evil consolidate their power. People like Eddie join in, convinced they’re doing the right thing, and ignoring anyone who says otherwise.
But we don’t have to roll along with it. We can stand up, and defend ourselves however we can. Because fascists, like abusive parents, are all about control. Our task is to become uncontrollable.