So, here we are: after a truncated run of only ten episodes, the first series of the Chibnall/Whittaker era has come to an end. Obviously, there was a lot riding on this series, given the importance of Whittaker’s casting. But was it a success?
To be honest? Not really. At least, not for me. The General Public seemed to like it, with an average of 7 million Brits tuning in to watch on BBC One every week. That’s not bad, and puts it in good company with the Moffat/Smith era (S5-7) and the first year of Moffat/Capaldi (S8). The world will not end because Doctor Who no longer caters to the tastes of one American trans girl. The only problem is, she’s still watching, and she doesn’t really like what she’s seeing.
To explain why, let me talk about something completely different first: The twelfth and most recent season of my other favorite show,Mystery Science Theater 3000, came with a subtitle: The Gauntlet. The main arc was that villainess Kinga Forrester would subject host Jonah Heston and his robot companions to six bad movies one after the other in an attempt to encourage binge watching among the audience, and while I haven’t done that, (I’ve been going one at a time) I would still say getting through the Gauntlet is an easier experience than watching Series 11 of Doctor Who. Because at least MST3K has humorous commentary. With Doctor Who, all you have is the increasing suspicion that the heart of the show has been ripped from its chest, leaving a hollowed out shell in its place.
I will say that the MST comparison is quite apt, as series creator Joel Hodgson has repeatedly referenced Who when comparing how his show’s format allows it to live beyond one host, just as Doctor Who regenerates itself with every change of Doctor and showrunner. For a point of contrast, Hodgson said the reduced episode count of 6 (half of S11’s 14) was done partly out of a desire to make more MST3K more quickly. Meanwhile, Doctor Who has just gone on break until 2020, meaning the New Years Special will be our only dose of TV Who between now and then. I mean, if it keeps Jodie from suffering the same injuries her predecessors have, fine, but… oh brother, way to wreck what remaining shreds of goodwill I had left, Chibs.
If you were to ask me which recent series best pulls off the “How to reboot the show after a dramatic change in production”, the only answer is Series 5, because Series 1 was basically rebuilding the show from scratch after 16 years, and Series 11… well, we’ll get to that.
Series 5 is the answer because Moffat stuck to the template provided for him by Davies: a trio of stories set in present day Earth, the future, and the past, a couple of two-parters situated near the beginning and end of the series, and then a two-part narrative collapse story at the end. Every Davies series followed this model (though S2’s take works only if we say The Christmas Invasion is basically Episode 0, which it is), so it was only natural that Moffat, wanting to ease viewers in gently, would follow that outline while changing around everything else: the modern-day Earth story is set in Leadworth, not London, the narrative collapse at the end is allowed to happen instead of being prevented, and so on. If you’re a new show runner and you’re going to reboot this show, this is basically how you do it.
To be fair to Chibnall, there’s not really a “traditional” Moffat season, because that would imply Moffat believed in formulas. Series 6 and 7 were split in half and structured as miniseries, Series 8 was all one-parters plus a two-part finale, Series 9 was mostly two-parters (though it required expanding your definition of such to make it work), Series 10 mostly returned to the Series 8 model save for its midpoint, which wasn’t so much a 3-parter as 3 stories with a common enemy. So Chibnall’s chosen structure (10 self-contained single-part stories) makes a certain amount of sense.
Of course, structure is only half the equation, the stories your series contains have to be good too. Series 5 had 4 Moffat-penned ones, two of which were two-parters, with the rest farmed out to returning writers (Heterosexual Life Partner Mark Gatiss among them, Toby Whithouse, and Chibnall himself) plus new writers like Simon Nye and Richard Curtis. All the scripts (except maybe Victory of the Daleks, but let’s not go there) were solid, and gave the impression that while the major production team may be new, the core of the show remained unchanged.
The most important part of Series 5, of course, was how it sold its new Doctor. Matt Smith was unknown and untested, no one knew if he could anchor the BBC’s flagship drama in the way David Tennant had done. He was, in essence, the revival’s Peter Davison to Tennant’s Tom Baker in that respect. Fortunately the gamble paid off, and Matt’s Doctor led the show to new heights, especially in the United States. The Eleventh Hour will, for my money, always be the pinnacle of Doctor-introduction stories. Sure, the plot is rail-thin, but that’s not the point; you want to see Matt Smith in as many scenes as possible! It was a bright, witty, confident start to a series that, in my opinion, still holds up as one of the best.
So: if Series 5 was an example of the show taking a risk and getting everything right, would that make series 11 an example of the show taking a risk and getting everything wrong? Well, not quite. On paper, this should have been one of the best seasons of Doctor Who in at least the last ten years. And, according to the ratings, it was. But it doesn’t feel good, and there’s a reason for that: The problem, mainly, is the writing by the show runner. The evidence at this point suggests Chibnall got the job because of Broadchurch’s success on ITV, and the BBC were likely looking for a safe, reliable pair of hands to bring the show back to its flagship, ‘popular with the general public’ status that it had during the Davies years.
To be fair, that particular gamble has paid off. The ratings, and the general critical reception of the series is largely positive in a way we haven’t seen for a while. While The Woman Who Fell to Earth is nobody’s idea of the best possible post-regeneration script, it does at least accomplish its goals with a decent amount of competence. It’s not trying to be Steven Moffat or Russell T Davies. If anything, it’s like the two Columbus-directed Harry Potter movies: what you see is what you get.
Basic competence, however, can only get you so far. It gives you stories like Arachnids in the UK, which, like Woman, is one of his best scripts even in light of its many gaping problems. On the other hand, not meeting that low bar results in The Ghost Monument, The Tsuranga Conundrum, and The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos, three episodes that aren’t so much stories as a random collection of interesting plot ideas thrown into a blender and set on purée. He’s even more frustrating than Mark Gatiss, whose stories are either really good or really bad, but always well-constructed. Chibnall can’t even manage that, he’s like the new series version of Bob Baker and Dave Martin from the 1970s: lots of concepts that on their own would make for good stories, less than stellar execution on a good day.
There are many, many problems with Chibnall’s writing style, beyond what I’ve already mentioned. Firstly, for all his admirable dedication to adding much-needed diversity to the cast and crew, he doesn’t seem terribly interested in allowing non-white voices to be focus characters. Of the three companions, Graham is the one who gets most of the comic relief lines, and has the most background. Sure, some of that is shared with Ryan, but it’s Graham who is seen visibly mourning Grace in Arachnids. Of the ten episodes this year, only the two written by people of color (Rosa and Demons of the Punjab) go toward fleshing out the non-white characters! Graham got more character development than every other person in this team, including the Doctor. Good god.
It’s not just a racial problem either: Prior to the premiere, Matt Strevens would tell anyone who would listen that this series would have more LGBT representation than ever before. Given we were coming out of the era of Vastra, Jenny, and Bill, I was pretty thrilled. What we actually got: two dead lesbians and fucking King James I, whose obsession with Ryan smacks of Shakespeare and Martha in all the worst ways. If that’s representation, then why on Earth did they bother?!
And then there’s the Doctor. Let me be clear: I am 1000% on board with a female Doctor. As a transgender woman, I am kind of invested in having a female Doctor be a successful concept that can be repeated later. And Chibnall’s handling of the gender issue (a few one-off jokes scattered throughout the series) is smartly done. The problem is that while he’s giving us a female Doctor, he’s also giving us a Doctor who is ridiculously passive to an extent not seen since the 1980s, with Peter Davison.
You can count on one hand the number of times the Doctor has been allowed to be the Doctor: Woman Who Fell to Earth, The Tsuranga Conundrum, Kerblam, and The Witchfinders, and that third one was in an episode that in all respects was perfectly good, it just suffered from infuriating political viewpoints. In all other cases, she has been passive. In Ghost Monument she didn’t care about the race that killed people, in Arachnids of the UK she let the Trump stand-in wander off the set without once standing up to him as her predecessors would have, and in Kerblam she didn’t even comment on the titular company’s abusive policies toward its workforce. I haven’t mentioned Rosa and Demons because in those cases, the writers used the passive Doctor factor to their advantage, they made it impossible for her to interfere even if she wanted to. In those cases, the passivity served to enhance the story, not detract from it.
The question is not, “Why is the Doctor being so passive?” Instead, it’s “Is the Doctor being written as a passive observer because she’s female?” I would say the answer is yes. In a patriarchal society, women are not allowed to act like men do. You saw this in the 2016 American presidential election: Hillary Clinton was not allowed to be even half as aggressive as Donald Trump was being, because if she had been, the theory was that would’ve turned off large swaths of the electorate, ensuring a Trump victory. So, in Doctor Who terms, David Tennant can wander around the set declaring himself to be the Oncoming Storm and be absolutely fine, but if Jodie Whittaker does it she’d be labeled as too aggressive. It’s a double standard, one that Chibnall was playing into, whether he recognized it or not. In other words, Chris Chibnall was being sexist, whether he knew it or not.
Yes I know, Steven Moffat is supposed to be the sexist old dinosaur who can’t write women to save his fucking life. But Steven Moffat gave us Doctor-like figures in the forms of River Song and Clara Oswald, without forcing them to act anywhere near as passively as the 13th Doctor. And while we’re at it, Missy didn’t stop coming up with evil plans because she regenerated from John Simm into Michelle Gomez. Anybody still claiming that Chibnall is better at writing women than Moffat was really needs to compare how the Doctor was being written this series with Clara, River, and Missy. There’s a huge gulf of difference between the four of them.
The worst part is? I really wanted to like Jodie’s Doctor. And right up until this trainwreck happened, I did! But now? All I have is a Doctor who doesn’t actually seem to get what being the Doctor is supposed to be about. Which is really depressing, seeing as 12 literally died giving her advice. This Doctor is the kind of person who doesn’t react, and when she does, upholds corrupt systems rather than destroying them. Wilkinson, Hime, and Juno Dawson (author of The Good Doctor, a tie-in novel I will recommend to anyone who is feeling dissatisfied with 13 this year) all seem to get the character than Chibnall does. I feel so bad for Jodie. We know from her other work that she’s a really good actor, WHEN SHE IS GIVEN GOOD MATERIAL. And there’s been very little of that. She’s being utterly wasted in the role, I can’t say I’ll be surprised if she ends up leaving after 3 series.
Another thing that bothered me about this series: its politics. While nobody would ever describe Steven Moffat as being a Corbynesque Labourite, certainly Chibnall’s idea of what Doctor Who can be is quite a few points to the right of anything Moffat put out. In other words, Chibnall’s Doctor Who is perfect for people who shout about “civility” when Mitch McConnell gets yelled at in a DC restaurant, even as the actual honest-to-god President of the United States does things like having the American military tear gas children on the Mexican border. The Doctor even sums it up with her “If you kill him you will be just like him” line in the finale, it’s the same “both sides are evil” problem that led America to where it is now, and here’s the Doctor endorsing it.
But 13 being a passive Doctor is problematic not just because of the character’s gender, but for another reason too: At a time when the real world is in genuine peril; between climate change, rising authoritarianism, and Brexit, when the show can use its unique voice to shine a light on issues and give people a certain amount of hope, the Doctor says and does nothing. Rather than tear down the status quo and build up something better in its place, she supports it. Actions speak louder than words, and while “When people need help, I never refuse” is a great line, her actions suggest otherwise.
Of course, right-wing Doctor Who wouldn’t be a bad thing if it was actually funny. The Sunmakers was written as a way for Robert Holmes to bitch about the British government’s taxation policies and wound up accidentally endorsing communism. Series 11, however, isn’t anywhere near as funny. This has been an astoundingly dour series, lacking in humor or warmth, or even a scene depicting why traveling in the TARDIS is so much fun. It’s all boring cynicism, like Zack Snyder’s DC movies. As I wrote in my Kerblam review, the Chibnall era’s ethos seems to be “Things are terrible right now. And they’re just going to keep on being terrible. Sure, it might get better in the future, if enough people work to make it happen, but don’t hedge your bets.” It’s not only cynical, it’s downright nihilistic! What a horrible message to pass on to children of the UK, and in particular, the young girls who are watching Jodie right now! Chibnall should be utterly ashamed of himself.
The Moffat era was not perfect, by any stretch of the imagination. But you at least knew that a Moffat season stood for something, and was about something. You knew that Steven, for all his flaws, tried to learn and improve himself every year; the Steven Moffat of 2017, tired and on autopilot as he was, is a better writer than the Steven Moffat of 2010, and certainly the Chris Chibnall of 2018.
It would be wrong of me to say the show is failing, or is in danger of cancellation. Who has suffered worse periods than (presumably) 5 years of a guy primarily known for writing various types of police procedurals being behind the wheel. And like I said, the general public seems to favor Chibnall’s material over Moffat’s, especially Capaldi-era Moffat.
But there’s more than the general public here, long-term fans of the show are important too, and at least among the circles of Who fandom I’m surrounded by (specifically El Sandifer and people in her orbit), we all agree that the show has lost something. The magic simply isn’t there. The humor has been replaced with dry, po-faced seriousness, the showrunner’s grasp of character dynamics is apparently absent. He is so intent upon delivering an inoffensive product to all potential viewers that he winds up robbing the show of its soul.
It didn’t have to be like this. A series with a female Doctor could have been transformative, giving us new spins on old formulas, and even inventing new storytelling formats. It could have met, or even exceeded, the bar set by Series 5. It could have been one of the best runs the show has ever had. But it wasn’t. It was a dry, voiceless, dull miasma with occasional moments of brilliance. It wasn’t the worst, by any means, but it was also very far from the best.
In the end, this was the first time I had to compile a playlist of episodes similar to the ones featured this year, if only to remind myself of what the show is like under someone who cares. Steven Moffat, no matter what you may think of him, definitely cared about the show. Chris Chibnall, on the other hand, doesn’t seem to.
Final ranking (an average of the 10 episode rankings): 6/10.
Leave a Reply