If you’re reading this on my blog or on the Patreon, then this is just another in a series of weekly posts about the Davies era, but I’m writing this in October 2022. I started the series 2 blogs in fucking March. When I started, Queen Elizabeth was still alive, and now she’s been dead for a month. Point is, it’s taken me a long time to get through series 2 for various reasons, but the end is in sight now. Let’s see if I can get there before history repeats itself and David Tennant is officially the Doctor again. (She did not.)
So, this week, we have a two-parter: The one where the Doctor boldly goes where he has never gone before and matches wits with, as TV Tropes puts it, SATAN HIMSELF. (There’s a joke about Captain Kirk shouting at God in there somewhere.) As Doctor Who episodes go it’s somewhere between The Sensorites and The Daemons, another story where the Doctor finds himself faced with something that should be impossible.
And it’s good, or at least I think so. Good performances from all concerned, especially Gabriel Woolf (once the voice of Sutekh the Destroyer in Pyramids of Mars) and both of the regulars. Great visual effects, wonderful score, and just the right amount of scares to set the tone for Halloween. But there’s something fucked up buried underneath the surface here, and you might be able to guess what.
DANNY: Oh, come on. Where have you been living? Everyone’s got one.
ROSE: Well, not me, so, what are they?
DANNY: They’re the Ood.
ROSE: The Ood?
DANNY: The Ood.
ROSE: Well that’s ood.
DANNY: Very ood, but handy. They work the mine shafts. All the drilling and stuff. Supervision and maintenance. They’re born for it. Basic slave race.
ROSE: You’ve got slaves?
SCOOTI: Don’t start. She’s like one of that lot. Friends of the Ood.
ROSE: Well maybe I am, yeah. Since when do humans need slaves?
DANNY: But the Ood offer themselves. If you don’t give them orders, they just pine away and die.
ROSE: Seriously, you like being ordered about?
OOD: It is all we crave.
ROSE: Why’s that, then?
OOD: We have nothing else in life.
ROSE: Yeah, well, I used to think like that, a long time ago.
Pretty ethically fucked up coming from the GODDAMNED ETHICS OFFICER. To her credit, Rose is pretty justifiably not thrilled when she learns this, but the episode never gives her a chance to speak on the subject more than this, because within five minutes the Ood become agents of the devil. Literally. So, let’s drill down into whythis is so screwed up, not just because slavery is wrong (and it is) but also because why it jars so much with the Doctor’s gushing about humanity’s exploratory daring later in the same scene.
To do that, I’m going to switch gears and talk about my new favorite sci-fi franchise, Star Trek. In the Next Generationepisode “The Measure of a Man,” Commander Data is put on trial by Bruce Maddox, a Starfleet scientist, who aims to prove that Data is just a machine, not a person, and so cannot be said to have legal rights as we understand them. In this he is assisted by Commander Riker, who is reluctantly serving as the prosecutor:
RIKER: The Commander is a physical representation of a dream, an idea conceived of by the mind of a man. It’s purpose is to serve human needs and interests. It’s a collection of neural nets and heuristic algorithms. Its responses dictated by an elaborate software programme written by a man. Its hardware built by a man. And now. And now a man will shut it off.
(A flick of the hidden off switch, and Data slumps across the table)
RIKER: Pinocchio is broken. Its strings have been cut.
Later, Picard goes to visit Guinan, and they have a conversation about what might happen if Data loses his case:
GUINAN: Do you mean his argument was that good?
PICARD: Riker’s presentation was devastating. He almost convinced me.
GUINAN: You’ve got the harder argument. By his own admission, Data is a machine.
PICARD: That’s true.
GUINAN: You’re worried about what’s going to happen to him?
PICARD: I’ve had to send people on far more dangerous missions.
GUINAN: Then this should work out fine. Maddox could get lucky and create a whole army of Datas, all very valuable.
PICARD: Oh, yes. No doubt.
GUINAN: He’s proved his value to you.
PICARD: In ways that I cannot even begin to calculate.
GUINAN: And now he’s about to be ruled the property of Starfleet. That should increase his value.
PICARD: In what way?
GUINAN: Well, consider that in the history of many worlds there have always been disposable creatures. They do the dirty work. They do the work that no one else wants to do because it’s too difficult, or too hazardous. And an army of Datas, all disposable, you don’t have to think about their welfare, you don’t think about how they feel. Whole generations of disposable people.
PICARD: You’re talking about slavery.
GUINAN: I think that’s a little harsh.
PICARD: I don’t think that’s a little harsh. I think that’s the truth. But that’s a truth we have obscured behind a comfortable, easy euphemism. Property. But that’s not the issue at all, is it?
20 years later, Starfleet builds an entire army of androids to work in places like the shipyards on Mars, and all of them resemble (but are manifestly not) Data. And they were treated like equipment, disposable machines that weren’t even given names. Everything Guinan tells Picard here came to pass, leading to the ban on synthetic life that runs through the first season of Picard.
So, getting back to Doctor Who, it’s really not hard to see the parallels here: the Ood are basically androids, and smarmy little bastards like Danny here are the people who stand by and treat them like cattle or livestock, as the episode terms them. At least Zack, (who, I should mention, is black) has the decency to give them posthumous honors after they die at the end.
And the Doctor? He doesn’t do anything about the Ood situation short of demanding to know who it is that’s possessing them, adding at the end of the story he wasn’t able to save them. In series 4 he goes to the planet of the Ood and is able to do what he couldn’t here, directly acknowledging the events of this story to Donna, but while that’s great, it doesn’t erase the original fuckup.
Because here’s the thing: Slavery is wrong. And the Doctor has a responsibility, as a good and upstanding person, to do everything possible to free those who are caught in it. “But the Ood offer themselves. If you don’t give them orders, they just pine away and die,” says Smug Bastard Danny. I was like, “THEY’RE NOT OFFERING THEMSELVES FOR SHIT, YOU SON OF A BITCH! THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU?!”
And again: the Doctor, the title character of the fucking show, does nothing about it. He gets his TARDIS back at the end, he had every fucking opportunity to save the Ood and didn’t take it. Yes, I know, he makes up for it later, but the original fuckup is still there, the Doctor even refers to it four seasons later in The Doctor’s Wife! “Another Ood I failed to save,” he says, after he and Sexy materialize where Nephew had been standing a second earlier.
The Ood are another sentient race, and should be treated with respect, just like any other creature in the universe. For god’s sake, even as I write these words the 6-3 Republican majority on the Supreme Court is hell bent on taking away basic existential rights, from abortion care to gun control laws. They might even do away with same-sex marriage. Meanwhile, Republicans in state legislatures are busily trying to genocide trans people.
Let me end this piece not with the words of the Doctor, but the words of Captain Jean-Luc Picard, a man who has very rapidly displaced the Doctor as my favorite television hero:
“Your Honour, the courtroom is a crucible. In it we burn away irrelevancies until we are left with a pure product, the truth for all time. Now, sooner or later, this man or others like him will succeed in replicating Commander Data. And the decision you reach here today will determine how we will regard this creation of our genius.”
“It will reveal the kind of a people we are, what he is destined to be. It will reach far beyond this courtroom and this one android. It could significantly redefine the boundaries of personal liberty and freedom, expanding them for some, savagely curtailing them for others. Are you prepared to condemn him and all who come after him to servitude and slavery? Your Honour, Starfleet was founded to seek out new life. Well, there it sits. Waiting. You wanted a chance to make law. Well, here it is. Make a good one.”
It’s our challenge just as much as it was Captain Louvois’s, or the Doctor’s. She tried, but it didn’t stick. He tried, eventually, and it did stick. Now it’s our turn.
I hope we can.
Leave a Reply