Let’s just abandon all pretense and call the damn thing Resolution of the Daleks, because that’s the better title. You could’ve led with that and got a built-in audience, because everyone loves a Dalek story, especially in the first season for the new Doctor. But then, papering over the complete lack of substance in your product by saying as little as possible is basically Chibnall’s thing when it comes to Who. Remember, the Coming Soon trailer at the end of Woman Who Fell to Earth was a succession of famous names and little else (well, that and a long version of Akinola’s title theme); and the next time trailers were all basically 15 seconds of pointlessness.
Before I get started though, I’m going to admit something: I honestly wasn’t terribly excited for this episode, and well, you’ve read my reviews (I hope). It’s not hard to guess why. We were served ten weeks of undercooked, soulless, generic-looking sci-fi that was seemingly terrified of having anything of consequence to say or do, LGBT rep that consisted entirely of a vile historical figure and some dead lesbians, deeply unfortunate racial politics, morally repugnant Amazon politics, and most damningly of all, a Doctor who is so powerless, she somehow manages to be a guest character in her own show, because all the character development went to the old white guy. Again. I am glad Resolution is our only episode this year, because after such a vacuous first season, Chibnall Who just isn’t worth getting excited about. Or worth watching.
But it’s a new year, and who knows, maybe he made a resolution to actually try and write a decent episode for once. Woman was by far his best effort previously, so we might as well hope that this can claim to be about as good. So… here goes.
For starters, this is Chibnall doing a surface-level Moffat imitation. We have, for instance, a globe-spanning prologue with captions describing where and when we are and a narration, vaguely amusing relationship-based dialogue among the guest cast, and a TARDIS scene that looks a bit like the one from A Christmas Carol when they go to send the shark home. There’s even talk of them visiting every New Years Eve, again, like A Christmas Carol. If S10’s main cast had stayed, this is probably how S11 might’ve been, 10 weeks of Chibnall and his writers trying to be Moffat, Harness, Dollard, and Mathieson. (And Gatiss.)
This would be admirable… if imitating writers who are better at crafting Who scripts than him wasn’t Chibnall’s entire freaking deal. He did it in December with Battle and Davies (with a hint of Douglas Adams) and now he’s doing it with Moffat.
That’s really all I can think of to say about the episode. It was clearly Chibnall’s best script since Woman Who Fell to Earth, it was well-shot, the possession via Kaled mutant angle was genuinely interesting (and it gave Nicholas Briggs something new to do with Dalek vocals), and certainly Whittaker’s Doctor truly came alive when facing off against it alone. I got shades of Eccleston in Dalekthere, or the testimony sequence in Victory. As Dalek episodes go, it’s not a bad effort. It feels, to me, like a TV version of The Monster in the Woods, a Paul Magrs story that was also about a Dalek marooned on Earth for a long time that tries in vain to contact the fleet. Which wasn’t bad either, for Dalek stories.
And yet, this is still written by Chris Chibnall, and while it’s a better finale than The Battle of No One Cares, it also contains all the foibles of Chibnall scripts: gay people being used as cannon fodder and deeply unfortunate racial politics. As my good friend @Paciniworth pointed out on Twitter, (and I’m just going to quote her directly)“Y’know, maybe Graham being the center of Ryan’s story and having the brunt of the focus of Grace be about him rather than Ryan was fucked up and tonedeaf! It’s not that Graham was important to Ryan that’s the issue, it’s that his entire story revolves around him accepting Ryan, giving Ryan the things he wants, the other black family members being dead or deadbeat meaning his main and only relationship is to his white grandad.”
She is 100% right. It’s another huge example of Chris Chibnall actively refusing to think about the consequences of his writing. Grace should NOT have been killed off in the first place, but if we’re going to do that, THE ABSOLUTE LEAST he could have done was NOT center the white guy in the narrative of black pain. But he couldn’t even do that. (I also didn’t like how the Dalek was referred to as a “refugee.” Maybe not the best choice of words, seeing as how the American government has been shut down for the last two weeks over Trump and his fucking wall. If you can’t even do “Daleks are fascists” right, what exactly is the point of you?)
Am I surprised? Not at all. Failing to succeed at even the bare minimum of what counts as non-problematic storytelling is as part of this era as poor set design and fancy camera lenses. I mean for crying out loud, this is the same guy who said there was lots of LGBT representation this year, and then had every single non-James I example snuff it. It’s 20FUCKING19, and yet Chibnall is still writing for gay people as if it was 2003. God forbid he put a trans character in Series 12, he’d fuck that up even worse.
I had it pointed out to me that this is the last Doctor Who episode of the 2010s decade. The very first? Another New Years Day special, The End of Time: Part 2. For my money, 2010-era Doctor Who was, on the whole, good to downright some of the best television ever, period (Heaven Sent). And it was an era I’m going to miss. Or at least, the part of it that existed from April 2010 to December 2017. I watched Twice Upon A Time recently, and unlike the last time (when I wanted to go right to the regeneration scene), I found myself almost wishing that Peter Capaldi didn’t have to change. To paraphrase one of his predecessors, I didn’t want him to go.
2010s-era Doctor Who was made by people who cared. Everyone from the main cast of every series to the production staff, cared about putting out the best show they possibly could, even in spite of various production nightmares. And I had hope Chibnall-era Doctor Who would carry on that tradition.
By and large, it hasn’t. I place no blame for this at the feet of Jodie, Bradley, Tosin, and Mandip. Everything is Chibnall’s fault. His show is empty and devoid of joy and whimsy. It’s unnecessarily grim, as though it somehow equates grimness with seriousness. Yes it worked for the Nolan Batman movies, but Chris Chibnall isn’t Nolan, he’s more like a low-rent Zach Snyder. He doesn’t seem to grasp what the character of the Doctor is fundamentally about; instead of a heroic figure who helps people, we have a Space Policewoman with whatever morals Chibnall has decided to give her that week.
And I’m tired of it. I’m tired of watching this show week after week after week, looking for gold when all I can find is pyrite. I’m tired of writing angry scribes and shouting into the void about just how awful this show is, and I’m tired of this show I love so much being twisted into an empty version of itself by a centrist coward whose entire response to Trump is a stern glare, when it should be tearing down the entire fucking enterprise! I’m tired, I’m tired, I’m tired, I’m tired!
I have sometimes wondered what it would take for me to not care about Doctor Who anymore, for it to become just a show I watch, instead of one I think about constantly. I think I now know what that is. Doctor Who, or at least the version of the show as it exists under Chris Chibnall, is bland. It’s uninteresting. It has nothing to say. It exists solely to fill the 9/8c Sunday night time slot on BBC America and break up the monotony of TNG, Voyager, and X Files reruns. And it’s not a show I care about anymore, either.
Episode ranking: 6/10
Leave a Reply