I write this post at an interesting historical moment: since I began these rewind blogs, David Tennant has returned to the show as the Doctor, and Russell T Davies is again showrunner, just as they were when this story was made. One does wonder what the LINDA crew would make of that first development, the Doctor wearing the same face twice.
But it’s not quite the same. Tennant is the Fourteenth Doctor now, an appropriately older version of the Tenth, and all indications suggest that even he has realized something has gone horribly wrong. What Neil Patrick Harris has to do with it is undetermined, little yet how Catherine Tate and Ncuti Gatwa fit into things. Maybe by the time this post goes up publicly, we’ll have a clearer idea… but maybe we won’t. Who knows?
The historical moment is interesting for other reasons too, ones more directly related to the episode we’re supposed to be discussing. Much like LINDA gets taken over by Victor Kennedy, Twitter is now owned by Elon Musk, taking what hadbeen a place for queer leftist Doctor Who fans to congregate, as Tumblr had been ten years ago, and turning it into a corporatist hell hole. Musk is the Victor Kennedy of social media, but you know what else? I also have a LINDA.
But we’ll get to that in a bit. For now, the actual episode:
Love & Monsters is not a complicated story, as far as the plot goes. While the Doctor and Rose are busy having their own largely off-screen Scooby Doo romp, the action focuses on Elton Pope, a Doctor Who fan with no friends of his own until he meets Ursula, who is also a Doctor Who fan. Together they form a little club that starts being about the Doctor, but gradually becomes a general weekly hangout spot as the five of them form friendships.
This kind of scenario isn’t as far-fetched as it sounds. Hell, it’s happened to me! I’m in a Discord server with a bunch of people from various countries of varying ages, and while we all initially came together because of our shared love for Doctor Who, we’ve gotten closer and talked about other things too, like music, writing, other TV shows, movies, you name it! We even play truly ridiculous games of online Werewolf! It’s a great little group, and LINDA reminds me a lot of it.
But there’s another, darker reason for the formation of the Discord group, and it relates to this episode’s antagonist: Mr. Victor Kennedy.
He arrives with a big flourish, announcing himself as LINDA’s salvation, and all at once the whole tenor of the meetings changes. It becomes like school as he puts the group to work, making them search for the Doctor rather than do any fun things like playing ELO or what have you. He’s a smug bastard with an ego the size of a planet, and he represents the worst kind of Doctor Who fan imaginable: the entitled kind.
In a previous Discord server I was in, Pandorica, there were two of these sorts of “fans”: One was David McCormack, Twelve impressionist and showrunner of a Doctor Who fan audio series you haven’t ever heard of because he made it virtually inaccessible. He wanted to be showrunner, and somehow thought that hosting a bunch of amateur fan fiction audios on fucking Mega would get him there. He was wrong.
The other one was Sam Maleski, whom I’ve mentioned before: a two-faced “friend” who wanted to be the best of everything, and got super pissed off when Arcbeatle chose to publish my work as well as his. Both of them saw the Pandorica group as a stepping stone to greater things, and both were perfectly ready and willing to stomp on anyone who got in their way. And watching Victor Kennedy again, I’m reminded especially of Sam’s reign of terror.
That’s what the Victor Kennedys of the world do to fandoms. They poison them. They kick out all the people who aren’t like them to give themselves a “safe space”. All of a sudden, it’s not about getting together and knitting Tom Baker scarves or singing along to the theme tune in its many permutations or writing fan fiction or anything like that. It becomes all about them, their wants, their needs and desires, and to hell with what anyone else might want.
Both Sam and David were eventually kicked out, (the story is very long and for the most part not mine to tell) and a new Discord server was formed. It’s a very tight-knit little space, just like LINDA, and our members come from all over the world. We talk, we play games, we have a grand old time. It’s the kind of thing Pandorica wanted to be but ultimately never became, for a variety of reasons. And the best part about the new server is, there’s no chance of a Victor Kennedy type springing up on us.
That’s what LINDA is: a safe space for Doctor Who fans to congregate and discuss the thing they love, and form bonds with each other. People who would otherwise never meet come down to London every week and spend a few hours in each other’s company. Who doesn’t want something like that?
I mean, look at me, I’m a transfemme enby wolf from the American midwest. My LINDA is the new Discord server and the leftist Who fans I follow on Twitter, from Freezing Inferno to Jack Graham to Christine Kelley and Scarves ’n’ Celery and Scriptscribbles and so many others. I can be myself with these folks, and they accept me for who I am. And they love me. (And I love them too.)
So I find it so wonderfully ironic that this story has such an awful reputation among the wider fanbase, because of course it does. It’s a reflection of this community, in a good way and a bad way. We’re all Elton and Ursula and Mr. Skinner and Bliss and Bridget.
And we’re here because we’re Doctor Who fans. We’re here because we love this show that, in spite of it being about an ageless alien who can change their face, it’s so very human. It has virtues and vices. Some parts of it are utter perfection, other parts are irredeemably vile, and still more are somewhere in between. Doctor Who is as good as the people who make it, because like the fandom, it is a reflection of who we are. And it’s ours.
One of my favorite quotes was never said on the show, but by Peter Capaldi, the biggest fanboy this side of Gallifrey, when he was announced as the Doctor in 2013. He said: “The big reason that ‘Doctor Who’ is still with us is that every single viewer who ever turned in to watch this show, at any age, at any time in its history, took it into their heart – because ‘Doctor Who’ belongs to all of us. Everyone made ‘Doctor Who.’”
Every kid whoever pretended to be the Doctor while someone else was a Dalek? They made Doctor Who. Anyone who ever wrote Doctor Who fan fiction? They made Doctor Who. Anyone who ever wrote a blog post, or perhaps an entire book series, all about critiquing Doctor Who? We made Doctor Who.
And the world is a much darker, madder, and better place for it.
Leave a Reply