I’ve always had a soft spot for Doctor Who’s many book lines. This goes back to around 2006 or 2007, when I was in middle school. My school’s library had three of the classic series Target novelizations available: Doctor Who and the Cybermen, Doctor Who and the Green Death, and Doctor Who and the Curse of Peladon. Long before I ever saw an entire episode of the series, I discovered the show through the printed word, and ever since, a Doctor Who book has always been one of my favorite things to read.
So, The Good Doctor then. First: it’s the first ever piece of Doctor Who anything to be written by Ms. Dawson, who is (like me) a trans woman. Her conversational, humorous prose style found in her own books translates well into Doctor Who terms, and her grasp of the four leads is impeccable. It’s very easy to hear Jodie, Bradley, Tosin, and Mandip read their characters’ lines, no one seems out of character.
The official summary is: On the planet of Lobos, the Doctor halts a violent war between the native Loba and human colonists. Job done, the TARDIS crew departs – only for Ryan to discover he’s left his phone behind. Again. Upon returning, the Doctor finds that the TARDIS has slipped hundreds of years into the future – and that something has gone badly wrong. The Loba are now slaves, serving human zealots who worship a godlike figure known as The Good Doctor. It’s time for the Doctor to face up to the consequences of her last visit. With Lobos on the brink of catastrophe, will she be able to make things right?
So, already we have an intriguing premise, a satire exploring how religions get started, and how simple statements can get taken entirely out of proportion, even commentaries on the cruelty of humanity, and our tendencies to look down upon that which is different from us. In other words, it’s the kind of plot that has been done in Doctor Who before, but now with a new twist: the Good Doctor in the title isn’t who we think it is, but Graham!
I know! Dawson subverts our expectations, but plays to our traditional mental picture of who the Doctor is: an older white man, and putting the Doctor herself on the back foot, as she has to deal with sexism for the first time, fighting against priests who have based their entire religion around her and her companions, but chose Graham as their figurehead. It’s an inspired move, and one that only would’ve worked with this Doctor anyway.
I love how Dawson writes for 13, having her talk about the Time Lords and making reference to the Doctor’s status as not just a traveler, but the Oncoming Storm of the Moffat and Davies years, a character to be feared as well as celebrated. It’s the kind of thing that Chibnall hasn’t done yet in series 11, in his insistence to make a continuity-free season of the show.
Dawson even finds time to hang lampshades on things like Bradley Walsh also serving as host on The Chase (suggesting that Bradley Walsh exists in the universe of the series) and Yaz’s tendency to be the Asking Questions One, and even mentions Ryan’s dyspraxia at a crucial point in chapter 11. And when she isn’t doing that, she’s skewering the tendency of Earth religions (such as Christianity) to distort the word of their worship figures for their own ends.
Another thing I like is the scene where the Doctor is made to fight against Tromos. If you’ve seen it, this sequence should call to mind a similar scene in “The Curse of Peladon,” where the Doctor is again made to fight a warrior in a fight to the death. In that instance, the Doctor used Venusian aikido (as Pertwee was big on physical combat), but what does 13 do? She talks Tromos out of attacking her and survives without so much as a scratch.
I won’t say how the book ends of course, but it is a happy ending, concluding with a very sweet epilogue that proves, when all is said and done, that we are all stories in the end. Dawson’s book is a splendid read with plenty of humor and drama, and a good amount of satire mixed in. If you, like me, have been spending this series waiting for this era to feel like Doctor Who already, your prayers have been answered. Praise the Good Doctor!
Leave a Reply