It is at times difficult to believe, but Doctor Who is, technically, a family program of some description, with an emphasis on children. The degree to which this is the case ebbs and flows throughout the show’s history, but in general, kids are considered the core part of the Who audience, though not the only part.
Children are also not stupid, they deserve to be treated with respect from the adults in charge. The Moffat years were great at this, the first and last scenes of that era (7-year- old Amelia Pond praying to Santa Claus and the Twelfth Doctor telling his future self about how children can hear their name, drawn from something Peter Capaldi himself said) are grounded in the experiences of children. If you’re going to work in children’s entertainment, you have to respect children. It really is that simple.
Which brings us to Fear Her, the worst story of what is usually considered to be the rockiest of the revival seasons, and certainly of the Davies years. According to Shannon Patrick Sullivan, Graham’s script was put in to replace a story by Stephen Fry, and the result was… well, a total clusterfuck. Matthew Graham is not exactly one of the show’s best writers (his two-parter from the 2011 run is awful for different reasons, but it’s still awful), and it does not help that the brief he was given would later be executed with more success by Jamie Mathieson in another 8 years.
But Fear Her also does something not yet seen in the revival era: it treats its most important viewers with contempt, as El Sandifer explained in her TARDIS Eruditorum entry in a discussion about Murray Gold’s soundtrack:
His brief was clearly the same as Matthew Graham’s, namely “kids episode,” and so he covers the episode with a sort of plinky music that screams “television adaptation of The Famous Five” and not “otherworldly horror consuming a neighborhood.” And this ends up smothering the episode in its grave, keeping it from ever getting any dramatic tension.
The music is working against it at every turn, saying “this is not actually a big deal at all” about every aspect of the drama. This makes the entire episode feel disposable and silly in a way it doesn’t have to. It’s the musical equivalent of that moment in Coupling where Jane declares that being a children’s presenter is easy because “you just have to waggle your head a lot and shout.” It’s making children’s television that doesn’t actually have any respect for children as an audience, and it’s painful to watch.
There is a better way to write for children’s television, and to illustrate this, I’m going to jump backward by a few years and to an entirely different medium from Doctor Who: the children’s book series A Series of Unfortunate Events.
First, some background: the books were written by novelist Daniel Handler, writing under the pen-name of Lemony Snicket. The series concerns the trials and tribulations of the Baudelaire children, who are orphaned at the beginning of the first book and sent to live with the disastrously inappropriate Count Olaf, an alleged actor with poor hygiene and fondness for abusing young children.
In the books, Snicket’s narration style is packed with humor and wit, including in- context definitions for certain vocabulary words and phrases, commentary on the proceedings, occasional digressions to his personal life as it relates to the Baudelaire story, and of course, continuous begging and pleading with the reader not to distress themselves by reading such a dismal book.
Much like Doctor Who, the series finds its origins in Victoriana, in this case the Gothic style of books, such as those published by Edgar Allen Poe or Bram Stoker. Also like Doctor Who, the books (as well as the Netflix adaptation) change locations with every installment, with the only recurring characters being the three leads and Olaf.
But one of the most important thing about the books, (as far as this discussion is concerned anyway) is how Snicket treats his readers. He explains complicated subjects (such as the feelings one has after losing a loved one) in ways children can understand easily, and repeatedly expresses sympathy for the Baudelaires and their plight. In a world where adults range from evil to good-intentioned but incompetent, his behavior is perhaps analogous to the Doctor, the difference being that he cannot rescue them from their fate.
The series’ themes of moral relativism and the increasingly indistinct lines between “good” and “evil” mirror, in some way or other, the Tenth Doctor’s character arc across his three seasons, with Series 2 being roughly analogous to the first six books in Unfortunate Events: the Doctor and the Baudelaires do unambiguously heroic things in their quests to defeat the monster of the week/unravel and stop Count Olaf’s latest plan.
In both cases, there’s a particular event that changes the trajectory of the story and breaks the established pattern: in The Vile Village, the Baudelaires are accused of murder, put on trial by the town that was supposed to be looking after them, and thrown in prison, which they then have to escape. Once they do they go on the lam, and the final six books have them on a frantic quest to clear their names and discover more about the secret organization that has been following them. In Doctor Who, this paradigm shift is the very next story, Army of Ghosts/Doomsday.
The key difference between the Baudelaires and the Doctor, however, is their response to their increasingly morally-grey decisions. The Baudelaires fret constantly about whether or not they are good or evil, and fight to stay on the “good” side of the schism, even as they are forced to do things like set a hotel on fire to escape the cops. The Doctor, as we’ll see, only has such considerations when it is entirely too late to do anything about them.
Fear Her, then, is something like The Ersatz Elevator: a last “normal” episode before the narrative restructuring that will come next, complete with a bit of foreshadowing: the Doctor portentously hints that a storm is coming in response to Rose’s suggestion that “They keep on trying to split us up, but they never ever will,” and the last page of Elevator contains an illustration of the Baudelaires sitting forlornly on the steps of an auction hall while a crow (representing the animal around which the titular village of the next book has built their society) flies by overhead.
The great irony is that Elevator is a much better example of a last normal episode than Fear Her can ever hope to be. While the plots of both revolve around children, Elevator has the Baudelaires rappel down and up and down an elevator shaft to rescue their friends, who were kidnapped by Olaf and his henchpeople at the end of the preceding book. Granted, their quest ends in failure (because after all, this is a book series that is opposed to happy endings) whereas the Doctor is able to free the Isolus from Chloe Webber, but that’s beside the point.
One of the book’s themes, in fact, relates to what Fear Her fails to do: treating children with respect. When meeting their guardian Esmé Squalor, she reacts like this when told of the Baudelaires’ problems:
“I’m very, very tired of discussing your little twin friends,” Esmé said one day, as the Baudelaires and the Squalors sipped aqueous martinis one evening in a living room the children had never seen before. “I know you’re worried about them, but it’s boring to keep blabbing on about it.”
“We didn’t mean to bore you,” Violet said, not adding that it is terribly rude to tell people that their troubles are boring.
“Of course you didn’t,” Jerome said, picking the olive out of his fancy glass and popping it into his mouth before turning to his wife. “The children are concerned, Esmé, which is perfectly understandable. I know Mr. Poe is doing all he can, but maybe we can put our heads together and come up with something else.”
“I don’t have time to put my head together,” Esmé said. “The In Auction is coming up, and I have to devote all of my energy to making sure it’s a success.”
Here we have the personification of why it is important to never dismiss children or the problems they face. Esmé treats them with contempt over and over across the story, and the one time she does listen to them, she tricks them into thinking they’re going to stop Olaf’s scheme, then pushes them down the empty elevator shaft.
Now, I am not suggesting that anyone involved intentionally made such a rubbish episode, nor am I suggesting that anyone involved is as awful as Esmé Squalor. But the failure of Fear Her is indicative of what can happen when a dedication to creating quality children’s entertainment falls by the wayside, a phrase which here means “falls apart due to a combination of scheduling issues, bad scriptwriting, atonal music choices, and other considerations.”
It’s funny that I elected to focus solely on the Tenth Doctor from an in-universe perspective when, in fact, a lot of the flaws of his era are present out-of-universe as well, as Fear Her illustrates. Going forward, the rest of the series will still be focusing on the Tenth Doctor (his next two series are rich in material, thankfully) but also Russell T Davies, the man who created the character in the first place. Thus, their stories are entwined.
Having brought Doctor Who back from the dead in 2005, by 2006 he is now at a point where he must outdo himself year over year, but at a cost: David Tennant was perceived to be so indispensable to the show’s continued success that according to an interview with Steven Moffat, in 2009 the BBC actually considered cancelling the show after Tennant’s departure, but Davies (thankfully) insisted they weren’t allowed to.
But before we get to all that, we have to talk about Rose. Because as we’ll see next time, the Davies years are built on her, and her departure will mean big changes are in store for Gallifrey’s finest.
Leave a Reply