The Mactíre Anthology: Spyfall Review

Part 1

And we’re back! After a year away, Doctor Who has returned for its twelfth revival season, and to be honest, I’m glad to see it again.

As I’ve written previously, Series 11 seemed a bit too much “prestige streaming TV drama” than Doctor Who, with less-than-inspiring monsters and weaksauce writing from the guy in charge, to say nothing of its “centrist” (which, in this age of Trump and Johnson, is really more of a synonym for center-right) political leanings, and the general impression that under Chibnall, the show wasn’t entirely sure of itself.

The good news is, there’s a definite sense of a course correction going on here. Pre-series press statements and trailer clips have made it clear there are an abundance of returning monsters, from the usual Daleks and Cybermen to Davies-era creatures like the Judoon and (probably) the Racnoss. Segun Akinola’s score, while still in general realm of atmospheric, is also going in a slightly more of a “John Barry with shitloads of reverb” direction, which is very apropos since this is a Bond pastiche. The dialogue is better. The jokes are a little more numerous and not quite as bad as the infamous wifi line from Resolution. (My personal favorite is the Rubber SoulAlexa accent gag. Great album, that.) The danger feels dangerous. (Evil satnav scene, anyone?)

Suffice it to say, Spyfall feels like Doctor Who in a way we haven’t seen in a long time. There’s a confidence under there that hasn’t been seen from Chibnall since approximately Dinosaurs on a Spaceship. It’s hardly the greatest story in the world, but it’s serviceable.

Given the title, the episode is very obviously a pastiche of James Bond movies, (Good timing, considering Daniel Craig’s last movie comes out in April.) albeit the general cultural idea of 007 rather than a specific Bond, existing somewhere between Connery and Moore with, given Jodie’s blonde hair, a hint of Craig. Stephen Fry’s C is very obviously modeled on Bernard Lee’s M, and of course, there’s the whole MI6 thing. The birthday party stuff screams Casino Royale, there’s a definite sense of globe-trotting, and of course, three of our four leads are wearing tuxes. (The Doctor’s is the best.)

But of course, this is still Doctor Who, which means aliens. The unnamed species that Daniel Barton is working with seem adjacent to the Boneless from Flatline, in that they are fucking creepy, barely humanoid, and seem to be coming from outside the universe. One thing’s for sure, they’re a damn sight more terrifying than Timmy “Blue Tooth Fairy from Hell” Shaw.

If “James Bond with space aliens” wasn’t enough, we’ve also got a bit of contemporary politics at play. Lenny Henry’s character, Daniel Barton, is the kind of Silicon Valley executive villain that’s been a thing in pop culture since at least The Social Network. His company, VOR, (seriously?!) is obviously cast in the same mold as Google, Microsoft, or Facebook: a looming tech giant just begging to be brought down by Congress and/or a potential President Elizabeth Warren. Lenny Henry is quite adept at what he’s asked to do, playing Barton with an understated menace.

And in the middle of all this, we have Sacha Dhawan’s character, O. Presented as an ex-MI6 agent who moved Down Under to keep an eye on aliens, he’s strangely quite familiar with the Doctor, and even helps her out a bit in the episode’s back half. Then, on a plane, he reveals himself: he’s the Master.

With that reveal, we now have the final piece in what essentially amounts to Chris Chibnall paying tribute to the now-50 year old Pertwee era. His fondness for that period of the show is obvious: his Silurian story from 2010 was basically Doctor Who and the Silurians without the UNIT stuff, and The Power of Three was a classic Pertwee-style Earth invasion story with Jemma Redgrave’s Kate Stewart filling in for the Brigadier. For crying out loud, the guy even breaks out the ol’ TCE in place of a sonic screwdriver analogue. In so doing, Chibnall is taking the character right back to the 1970s, albeit with some Davies-style mania.

On the one hand, I’m genuinely glad to have a non-white actor playing the character for the first time. Michelle Gomez’s incarnation was instrumental in preparing the audience for Jodie Whittaker (in my estimation, anyway) and I hope that Sacha Dhawan’s casting does the same. If there’s any justice in this world, the Fourteenth Doctor will be a person of color too.

Taken on his own merits, Dhawan is a worthy successor to Gomez. If she was Mary Poppins’ insane evil twin sister, he’s a cracked mirror version of Matt Smith, and I’m not just talking about the bow tie. He’s got a similar hairstyle, and how he chooses to deliver his lines leading up to the reveal has shades of Smith’s own delivery. (Seriously, it’s very easy to hear Smith say “I told you to look for the spymaster, didn’t I? Or should I say the spy… Master?” in exactly the same fashion Dhawan did.) He even moves around the set in a similar way, complete with that little twirl thing Smith always did. Basically, he’s Mr. Clever.

But from a development standpoint, I can’t help but think it’s yet another rejection of the Moffat era. Missy’s character arc in the Capaldi seasons was one long slow-burn redemption arc, reaching its peak in World Enough and Time/The Doctor Falls. There is value in the Doctor trying to make her oldest friend good. Hell, My Little Pony spent the last ten years doing that every other season. But having the character make a quick return after just one season away, with the template set back to how it was prior to Missy, feels like a step backwards.

It has often seemed like Chibnall is trying to recapture the glory days of Russell T Davies, from casting an actor from the North of England as the lead, to bringing back an assortment of Davies-era monsters, and giving us a Simm-adjacent version of The Master. Which, on one level, makes sense. The Davies seasons were phenomenally popular, after all.

But here’s the thing: the world that era inhabited is long gone. The revival is now fifteen years old, and it’s an established part of the British television landscape. The imperial phase is over. TV viewing habits have changed, you’d be damn lucky to get audience share numbers of 8 million or so a season these days. It’s better, I think, to move forward and do new things, instead of trying to endlessly recapture the old days.

Part 2

Unfortunately, Chris Chibnall seems to have missed that particular memo. He also seems to have missed the memo that says, “FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IGNORE THE TOXIC FANBOYS.” You know, the ones who campaigned for a Ghostbusters film that didn’t have women in it, demanded that Warner Brothers release the “Snyder cut” of Justice League, and are the reason Rise of Skywalker exists.

The hard part about reviewing a two-part episode is that the revelations of the second part can color your perceptions of the first. I’ll say this: Part 1 of Spyfall is, genuinely, the best script Chibnall’s written since 2012.

But part 2 isn’t. It does some neat stuff, for example the Moffat-esque trick of having Ryan find a message for him from the Doctor that allows him to land the plane, even though she can’t have had time to record that yet. It’s a very Blink maneuver, that.

But the rest… the rest is a disappointment. Lenny Henry’s evil plan doesn’t make a lot of sense, the Doctor leaves the Master behind to get captured by Nazis, (did he seriously not consider the optics?!) then has her mind wipe Ada Lovelace and Noor Inyat Khan, AKA the Emergency Backup Fam. (Who have about as much to do with the plot as the normal Fam in a typical week. The Khans even get relegated to background character status!) They get mind wiped against their wills, I might add, as though the True First Female Doctor didn’t have this this exact conversation with 13’s predecessor 5 years ago:

CLARA: No. Doctor, whatever you’re about to do, don’t do it.

DOCTOR: It won’t hurt, it’ll be nothing. You’ll just pass out for a moment.

CLARA: And then?

DOCTOR: When you wake, you’ll be fine.

CLARA: But

DOCTOR: Clara, just listen to me.

CLARA: Just say it. Say it. Come on. Tell me.

DOCTOR: When you wake up, you will have forgotten me. You’ll have forgotten we ever even met.

CLARA: And why would I want that?

DOCTOR: Because it’s the only way. That stuff in your head, the image of me, they could use it to find you.

(Clara holds out the sunglasses.)

CLARA: I, er I used these.

DOCTOR: On what?

CLARA: That.

DOCTOR: What did you do?

CLARA: What do you think? Ashildr’s right, you see? We’re too alike.

DOCTOR: Tell me what you did.

CLARA: What else? What else do you think I did? I reversed the polarity. Push that button, Doctor, it will go off in your own face.

DOCTOR: You were trying to trick me?

CLARA: What were you doing to me?

DOCTOR: I’m trying to keep you safe.

CLARA: Why? Nobody’s ever safe. I’ve never asked you for that, ever. These have been the best years of my life, and they are mine. Tomorrow is promised to no one, Doctor, but I insist upon my past. I am entitled to that. It’s mine. Hell Bent (2015)

none

But of course, that conversation happened in the episode Hell Bent, a story that saw the return of Gallifrey following the events of The Day of the Doctor. Both of those episodes happened in the Moffat era, a period of the show that wasn’t Popular With Everyone. So, in Spyfall, Chris Chibnall shows us all where he stands on the issue by destroying Gallifrey. Again. For no reason, except to make all the people who didn’t like Hell Bent happy.

Truly, Spyfall is to the Moffat era what Rise of Skywalker was to The Last Jedi: a story that undoes all the interesting things instigated by its predecessor, so we can all pretend it didn’t happen. Even now, there are apparently people out there who say that new viewers should just jump from The End of Time to The Woman Who Fell to Earth,as though the near decade of television that exists between those two points never happened.

I say: fuck that. As far as I’m concerned, Clara Oswald got back to Gallifrey to return her TARDIS, saw the Capitol was a wreck, and went back in time to stop the Master from wrecking shit up, because there’s no way she’d let that stand.

There is something of a tradition now in new Who show runners responding to their predecessors. Under Moffat, the show took pains to fix the Time War by having the Doctors save Gallifrey, rather than burn it, while (at the same time) respecting what had gone before. Two years later, Hell Bent happens, and that entire mind-wiping conversation was Moffat responding to Russell T Davies’ decision to have the Doctor forcibly mind wipe Donna in Journey’s End.

And now, we have Chris Chibnall. In series 11, Chibnall was perfectly content not to engage with continuity very much, and when he did, most of the time it came from the Davies years. What mentions there were of the Moffat era (Stormcage and the fez) came from the slightly more popular Smith years, the Capaldi years weren’t discussed.

Until now. Because now, by choosing to destroy Gallifrey yet again and undo everything Steven Moffat did, Chris Chibnall has fallen on the side of the toxic “fans” who hated The Last Jedi and the 2016 Ghostbusters movie. He’s essentially decided that the Moffat years, especially the 3 Capaldi seasons, don’t count. All that matters is Russell T Davies’ era, and the type of character the Doctor was at that point in the show.

I get that Chibnall wants the show to be popular again. I get that he’s trying to recapture the glory days of David Tennant. But like I said before, that time is over. We have to move forward.

Let’s hope next week’s story actually does that.

Ranking: 5/10.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑