Oh, of course. This is where I come in.
Yes, dear reader, this two-parter from early series 3 was one of the first Doctor Who stories I ever watched. It was 2007, and I was thirteen years old. After reading some old Target books at the school library, I decided to check out the show itself, which led me here. (My copies, weirdly, had an audio track that kept drifting out of sync.)
And, okay, the imagery of this story, particularly the design of Sec after he merges with Donald Trump’s ancestor, does stay with you for a while. I can see why Teenage!Lena decided to stick with this weird-ass British sci-fi show as one of her hyperfixations, as opposed to something sensible like Star Trek. (That would come later.)
Here’s the thing about this story: it’s an hour and a half of Dalek design wheel-spinning. For all that we talk about the show being ever-changing, there are still a few things about it that will always remain the same: The TARDIS will always look like a police box, despite the best efforts of Anthony Coburn’s son to get them to stop. (Irritating little bastard. Leave our TARDIS alone, you piece of shit!) And the Daleks will always look like Raymond Cusick’s original design – art deco saltshakers with plungers and egg whisks.
That design is iconic for a reason, and you don’t change it unless you want mountains of hate mail sent in your direction. Witness, for example, what happened in 2010 when Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss tried it and wound up with the Rainbow Hunchdaleks of Notre Dame. There was a huge outcry, and when they returned in Asylum, most of the Daleks in that story were of the bronze variety.
And like, come on. Humans toting around Dalek gunsticks doesn’t really scream “ALIENS!” in quite the same way as a genocidal pepper pot flying around Central Park does. You want human Daleks? Just show a guy in a police uniform. That’ll get the point across.
So, that’s the Doylist reason for why the proposed change in Dalek design will ultimately be closed off. What’s the Watsonian reason?
Exactly what you’d think: the remaining members of the Cult of Skaro quickly realize this isn’t going to work when Sec starts showing way more humanity than Mr. Diaogras ever did. So they decide, fairly early on in part two, to kill him and move on to something else.
But it’s worth asking the question, what is it that makes a Dalek evil in the first place? Is it a matter of nature, or nurture? Evolution falls pretty hard on the “nature” side of the equation by introducing the concept of Dalek DNA. Daleks are evil because it’s all about the biology, and no matter what you do you can’t change someone’s biology. A Dalek is still a Dalek, even if they look human.
(Note for the cis people in the audience: this is the same argument people make when explaining that a trans girl isn’t actually female, because according to TERFs like Raynor here, we will always be ‘biologically male.’ Which is bullshit, considering that as I write this I am about seventeen and a half months on HRT. I’m a woman! Check my blood test results! You can change biology, you useless fucks!)
Except the entire existence of Dalek Sec after he transitions into a human undermines that very argument, as my friend Fruitbat pointed out when I told them I was watching this story. By making himself half human, he becomes something new, something that the rest of the Cult hates because he starts undermining their existing plans for mankind. And they can’t have that, so they kill him.
It’s funny, watching this story in the year 2023. It’s set in New York, where I’m due to move this year. (Not NYC. Too expensive.) It offers social commentary on the Great Depression and the after-effects thereof that hit even harder now, as inequality skyrockets and more people take to the streets to demand fair treatment from their corporate masters, be they Starbucks baristas, Apple Store employees, or TV writers.
But what hits home for me is the DNA angle. As a transgender woman living in America, I have been forced to watch as Republican politicians at the state and national levels do their absolute best to deny me my rights as a sentient being. Missouri’s attorney general released an emergency order in April that would have denied me my healthcare, had it not been blocked by the courts. The MO state legislature passed a bill taking gender affirming care away from kids.
In Montana, they censured a trans legislator, Zooey Zephyr, for having the audacity to speak out against similar anti-trans legislation in that state. This is on top of a veritable tidal wave of genocidal legislation coming out of red states all year. They want us dead, and they’re doing everything possible to ensure that happens.
So it’s not hard, in this time and place, for me to look at this story and see this as three TERFS executing a trans person. We are to them what Sec was to the Cult of Skaro: abominations that must be exterminated.
And the hell of it is, Raynor, a TERF, wrote a story that wound up being a perfect metaphor for this exact scenario, even to the ending. Just as the Daleks always survive, so do TERFs. The Doctor knows he will see the Daleks again someday. As long as people continue to preach purity of the species, so will we. TERFs are Daleks. Republicans are Daleks. Fascists in general are Daleks.
So in the end, it’s a shame they didn’t go with the human Dalek idea. Sure, maybe a future Dalek story where all the Daleks are humans would’ve cut a little too close for those of us destined to face the wrong end of the gunstick someday, but is that such a bad thing? Sci-fi’s always been great for allegory, and maybe there are people out there who need reminding as to what a Dalek really is: us.
We all have the capacity for evil, that much is true. Dalek Sec has a point. But we also have the capacity for good, as Solomon says, and as the Doctor reminds us with that little speech about music. But that capacity doesn’t come from what DNA you have in your body. No one is born hating people. All of that comes from what you’re taught. What your values are.
Some of us grow up learning that hatred is wrong, and that it’s better to spread love and kindness around than cruelty or intolerance. And some of us learn that Black people, or trans people, or Jews, or Black trans Jews, are all weaker than the white majority and deserve to die.
Dalek Sec is a fascist who, over the course of the story, realizes that his own ideology is wrong and will ultimately lead to its own destruction. The Cult’s plan to convert human beings into Daleks falls apart because, thanks to the Doctor giving them a bit of Time Lord DNA, they have the freedom to choose not to kill. And they do. They die shortly after, of course, because this is Doctor Who and Daleks are gonna Dalek.
And of course the Doctor offers Caan a chance to live. Because he’s the Doctor, and no one is truly beyond redemption. Not even Daleks.
But his fight against the Daleks goes on, as it must. Just as our fight against fascism goes on, as it must.
Funny, then, that this story was written by a TERF. And what is being a trans-exclusionary radical feminist but a very specific form of fascism?
Then again… write what you know.