Recently, I’ve been re-listening (and now, thanks to Netflix, rewatching) to A Series of Unfortunate Events. The series tells the story of the Baudelaire children, three wealthy people who are suddenly orphaned when their house burns down and their parents are killed. After receiving news of the fire from a kindly if idiotic banker, they are sent to live with Count Olaf, a greedy and repulsive man who wants their fortune. The series’ schtick (a Yiddish word which here means “one of several recurring gags”) is that no one should read the books, because they are too awful to serve as entertainment.
Lemony Snicket has obviously never watched the Series 12 finale.
There is a definite sense that Chris Chibnall is trying to recreate that which worked before with regard to his two predecessors. Bringing back the Master and Captain Jack and a story with a chameleon arch are all hallmarks of Series 3, the Doctor leaving Ryan a pre-recorded video with instructions on how to land the airplane is lifted right out of Blink, a focus on the Cybermen is reminiscent of Series 2, and Ascension feels like an attempt to remake at least the first half of the Series 10 finale, but the addition of Gallifrey and the Master in the closing minutes is not unlike what would happen if you watched World Enough and Time but follow it with Hell Bent.
Ascension, taken by itself, is 50 minutes of Chris Chibnall spinning his wheels. Up until the reveal that the Boundary is connected to Gallifrey, the episode plays like a remake of Earthshock, what with the huge army of Cybermen about to massacre a group of human rebels and everything. That part of the story sucks as bad now as It did back in the 1980s, but especially when you factor in the Moffat-era version(s) of a Cyberman story with the Master, it feels like a step backward.
Then we get to part 2, which feels like Chris Chibnall listened to all the people who said that the biggest problem with Hell Bent was that it didn’t have enough lore, so he wrote this: an episode split between an Earthshock remake meshed with the Cybermen Titan Comics arc where they stage a takeover of Gallifrey, and… LORE. Lots of series destroying, continuity wrecking lore, delivered in the most boring way possible: Sacha Dhawan gets to menacingly tell a bedtime story.
Seriously. Why does this story exist? What purpose does it fill? Given the story the Master tells, it serves to make the Doctor The Chosen One, of the Harry Potter/Luke Skywalker/Joseph Campbell school of characterization. And it sucks, because that really isn’t who this character has ever been. Making the character a Chosen One type figure strips them of their uniqueness, and into just another cookie cutter sci-fi character.
I say, No More. I am not interested. I said last year that it would take a lot for me to stop watching the show, and I feel as if that day has finally arrived. Chris Chinall’s Doctor Who is a vapid, soulless, 100% magic-free, corporatist, capitalist, empty black hole from which neither light nor the sense of being entertained can escape, and I am done with it.
At this point it is plainly obvious who Chris Chibnall’s Doctor Who is for. It’s for people who thought The Rise of Skywalker was a good movie. It’s for people who thought Hell Bent should’ve been about Gallifrey and Lore. It’s for people who thought the show got better after Steven Moffat left, rather than changed into a generic piece of sometimes competent television. It’s desperately cynical middle of the road television made to fill a slot on a schedule and little more. It’s functional, and without heart.
And it’s not the show I love, anymore.
Leave a Reply