With this episode, we arrive at something of an important landmark, at least where I am concerned. Way back in 2011, I attempted a watch-through of the entire New Series of Doctor Who, a task that was much easier considering there was only five and a half seasons out. This was back in the day when the show was still on Netflix, then the only streaming game in town, and even that was a recent development. (Before there was an app, there was a disc I had to insert into my Nintendo Wii in order to actually watch anything. Two years later I could watch it on my iPhone.)
I got through series one and two pretty well. Eccleston’s sole TV season is absolute perfection, and remains the standard by which the later ones are judged. Series two, while rougher in a considerable number of places, at least has David Tennant’s charisma and magnetism to carry the day to at least minimum watchability.
But series three was where I stopped, and this episode specifically was the one that made me give up. I can’t remember exactly why I did, only that it happened. While I’ve seen some of the back half of the season (mainly Blink) I haven’t seen the whole thing straight through.
Series three, by some distance, is in my opinion the weakest of the original Davies era. Yes, the back half being so strong makes up for it, but actually getting to that point is a struggle. In six episodes, there are exactly two that I would call straightforwardly good: Smith and Jones and Gridlock. Manhattan/Evolution at least has Daleks being Daleks, even if it also has Penishead McGee, while Shakespeare Code has Rowling shout-outs and this is…
Well. Action Sequences, the episode. And we haven’t even gotten to next week yet.
Seriously, what is there to talk about with this episode? Not much. Mark Gatiss is pretty excellent in it: I may not be super fond of him as a writer a lot of the time, but the man is very good at acting, especially if he’s playing a villain. All he has to do is speak in that posh RP accent of his, look menacing, and that’s pretty much it. He has wonderful chemistry with David Tennant, so any scene with the two of them (but especially the cathedral scenes in the last quarter) are a good watch.
True, we get to see more of Martha’s family here, but they don’t really come off well. Well, alright, her sister and brother are okay, it’s really her mom that doesn’t work. Her three identifying traits are “cranky,” “doesn’t like the Doctor,” and “nosy as all get out.” It’s like watching my mother pop up in Doctor Who, minus the infantilizing condescension. At least with Jackie, effort was made to make her sympathetic. Francine Jones doesn’t even get that much!
And then, of course, there’s poor Martha herself. She gets to be Doctorish again this week, as she has been for a good chunk of the season so far, but even so, there are problems. As I said in the Smith and Jones post, she’s a similar archetype of the character that Clara Oswald will fill, but the primary issue with that is the show she’s in: Doctor Who is simply not built to accommodate two hyper-competent leads.
She’d get along just fine in something like Stargate or Star Trek, where hyper-competence is a requirement for entry, but on Doctor Who, a TV show that fundamentally resists the regimented world of military sci-fi, she’s at sea. The Doctor is the highest authority there is, and as it’s his name in the title, he’s supposed to be the Hero.
To be fair, this is not a criticism of the Davies era specifically: the show has always been like this. Martha just has the unfortunate luck of appearing in an era where the concept of being a junior Doctor is portrayed as an invariably bad thing, rather than a good and noble thing that can be aspired toward. Which gets at the difference between the Davies and Moffat eras: cynicism vs optimism.
Look at how the Doctor is framed in the Davies era: he is the Lonely God, a being of unimaginable power, a few rungs down the evolutionary ladder from the Q Continuum, and you piss him off at your peril. Whereas in the Moffat era, all of that drops away pretty much immediately, starting from The Beast Below: he becomes about as normal as it is possible for the character to be, and it’s worth noting that the one time he goes back to trying the “Lonely God” schtick out again, Hell Bent goes out of its way to deconstruct that entire line of thought. Again.
It’s funny to me that people describe the Moffat Doctors as being more fundamentally alien than the Davies Doctors, because in my opinion, it’s the exact opposite. The Davies Doctors, relatability-wise, are closed off from the audience, as I mentioned above. You can’t relate to Nine and Ten because for all that they make jokes and pop culture references, they are still deities who choose to hang around humans out of the goodness of their hearts.
Whereas Eleven and Twelve, for all their god-like attributes, so much of what animates them is so very, very human. Which is why the Moffat era goes so hard in the direction of decoupling the role of the Doctor from the Time Lord: we all have the capacity for goodness, and doing what’s right in the world. The Doctor just happens to have a few advantages that his human companions lack. (By which I mean regeneration.)
Martha, as I said, is something of an embryonic version of Clara, but equally, she is Rose’s successor as well. Rose spent most of series 1 being introduced to, and becoming part of, the Doctor’s world, to the point that she shares in his untouchability: she goes from dressing in period clothes in The Unquiet Dead to wearing a t-shirt and overalls in Tooth and Claw. When she does finally meet her match, it’s not because of anything she does, just bad luck.
Martha, of course, is the only one of Davies’ companions to leave the show without something bad happening: Rose gets banished to Pete’s World, and Donna has her memory wiped. Martha? She just decides, of her own free will, to stop traveling and move on to joining UNIT and Torchwood. That’s as close to enlisting in Starfleet as you’re gonna get in the Doctor Who universe.
(Now there’s a spinoff idea… Freema Agyeman as captain of a medical ship…)
Next week, 42. AKA, the final time I will ever watch an episode of Doctor Who with a Chris Chibnall writing credit.
And it’s his very first one.
Leave a Reply