First, allow me to state for the record that in my opinion, the best version of the song is not the slower one on the White Album, but the faux-live version of the single filmed in 1968 by Michael Lindsay-Hogg. That’s the one where George and Paul add in their shoop-de-do-wa backing vocals from the album version. (And in the linked clip, you can see George mouth “John’s mic is shit!” to Paul.)
The politics of the song are a little tougher to crack. Far-left revolutionaries of the time derided the song as being against revolutions in general, what with its insistence on presenting a plan and so on, but personally, I think it’s entirely reasonable. It’s all very well to stand outside an impressive edifice shouting about how corrupt everything is when you’re not in power, but you can’t govern that way if you get elected. Every outsider eventually becomes the insider, and if you can’t adapt, you’ll get thrown out when the next group of radicals comes along.
Oh, wait, hang on: I’m being told this is supposed to be a review of the Doctor Who winter special Revolution of the Daleks. Fuck, do I have to?
Fine, fine… here goes.
After a quick recap of the previous winter special, Resolution of the Daleks, we learn what happened next: 6 hours after the Doctor and friends blew it up with a microwave, government agents (or at least I assume they’re government agents) pick it up and take it to who knows where to be reverse-engineered. Along the way, a truck driver stops off to get some tea, which turns out to be poisoned. (The driver is black, and the camera lingers for a time on family photos he has pinned to his dashboard, showing our scriptwriter has learned absolutely nothing from his decision to kill off Grace O’Brien.)
Anyway, an undetermined amount of time later, Jack returns. (No, not that one. The other one.) It seems he’s had his presidential ambitions ruined by the toxic waste scandal from Arachnids in the UK, which seems downright cute compared to any number of scandals from the Trump White House, but it doesn’t see to have affected his reputation in the private sector, if he’s consorting with the British government to produce “defense drones.”
Ah yes, defense drones: take the recon scout Dalek from Resolution, give it a black and silver casing reminiscent of the iPhone, outfit it with a water cannon, a sonic deterrent, and a gas nozzle, and you have human-built Daleks. We first see them in Robertson’s initial scene, which depicts a role-played generic protest, into which the defense drone is sent to do crowd control.
Doing a story in which an alleged democratic government employs military tactics to put down protestors would’ve been a bad idea even in 2019, when this story was written and shot, but it’s noxiously bad in light of Black Lives Matter. What Doctor Who is presenting here is, in essence, the Ferguson and George Floyd protests but with Daleks instead of cops. And given Chris Chibnall’s easily apparent centrist political views, this cannot be a good thing.
Meanwhile, we have the Doctor, now just another face in a red jumpsuit, without any acerbic robot friends to talk to. Instead she has only herself, the other prisoners in the jail, (which include a Weeping Angel, an Ood, and to my great surprise, a Silent) and her photographic memory for Earth children’s books, in particular… Harry fucking Potter. Written by fucking Joanne Rowling, a known trans-exclusionary radical feminist, previously referred to in The Shakespeare Code, which was itself written by another TERF, the equally infamous Gareth fucking Roberts.
Godfuckingdammit, Chibnall. You had every fucking opportunity to cut the line or rewrite it entirely. What about, say, this one from Terrance Dicks? “Through the ruin of a city stalked the ruin of a man,” the first line of Doctor Who and the Dalek Invasion of Earth? If that’s a bit too meta for you, well, alright. Staying with the theme of 1990s children’s books featuring orphans, how’s this: “If you are interested in stories with happy endings, you would be better off reading some other book. Not only is there no happy ending, there is no happy beginning, and very few happy things in the middle.” But maybe, since it describes my personal opinion of your entire era, that’s a bit too on the nose.
Back on Earth, we finally get to see what the companions have been up to since we last left them in March 2020. Yaz has been hiding out in the TARDIS the Doctor liberated from Gallifrey, doing her best impression of Philip Anderson in The Empty Hearse, while Graham and Ryan (who are slated to leave in this episode) arrive to tell her to get back to reality, because Robertson’s got a Dalek. They try to extract information from him in a parking lot, and instead get harassed by his goons, walking off empty-handed.
In the Judoon jail, Jack returns. (No, not the other one. That one.) Mr. Barrowman acquits himself fairly well, but it’s fairly obvious it isn’t 2007 anymore, if you catch my drift. He breaks the Doctor out of prison with the power of technobabble and some fancy-looking sci-fi gear, including a vortex manipulator, and they make their escape, reappearing in the Doctor’s TARDIS.
Back at the ranch, Robertson’s latest underling/cannon fodder Leo tells his boss he’s created an alien lifeform from some leftover Dalek mutant DNA in the casing. Robertson reacts with disgust and horror and orders the creature destroyed, and in the act of doing so, the mutant possesses Leo and turns him into a puppet.
Together they go to Osaka, Japan, and it’s revealed that the mutant has been building a clone farm, while at the same time, Robertson’s been busy manufacturing casings, all in service of the new UK prime minister, Jo Patterson, an ersatz Theresa May. (Her party isn’t specified, but come on. She’s absolutely a Tory.) She gives a speech announcing that the drones will be posted on the streets of Britain (and everywhere else) in the hopes of creating a new “age of security.” Which doesn’t so much have fascist undertones as fascist overtones.
Anyway, the speech is interrupted when the cloned mutants are teleported into the casings, and of course, the inevitable happens. These may be different Daleks, designed by humans with different voices from the usual sort, but a Dalek’s gonna do what a Dalek’s gonna do: exterminate.
The Doctor’s solution? 57 years of combat against these genocidal space Nazis, and she goes for sending the bronze Daleks a transmission telling them to get to Earth to go “take care of” the human Daleks. She’s instigating a Dalek civil war, with Earth caught in the crossfire, so she can then swoop in and “solve” the problem THAT SHE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR IN THE FUCKING FIRST PLACE.
Last year, I wrote a book called Back to the Eleventh Hour, the first volume of a series looking back at the Matt Smith era of the show, starting with Series 5. In the chapter on Victory of the Daleks, I took Mark Gatiss to task for many things, but I’ll give him credit for this: he, at least, understands that when the Doctor is fighting Daleks and Earth is involved, the first you do is get Earth out of the line of fire. That’s Doctor Who 101. And it’s a class that Chris Chibnall apparently flunked.
Oh, and if that isn’t enough? The Doctor lets Robertson go, again, so he can join up with the proper Daleks and take over the world. Of course, that doesn’t happen exactly, (because the Dalek ship gets blown up while Jack, Ryan, and Graham rescue Robertson) but in the end, Robertson flat-out lies to the Doctor’s face (something about acting as a decoy) and the last we see of him, he’s being interviewed on British television talking about yet another run for president, spinning himself as the man of the hour.
There was one, and only one part of this episode that I can honestly say I liked: the departure of Graham and Ryan. If Chibnall’s been taking notes from Russell T Davies on how to write a companion departure, I’m glad he went with the Martha route: Graham and Ryan leave by choice. Not because they got stuck in a parallel world or a Weeping Angel, or one of them became a Cyberman, but simply because, with ten months to think about it, they think they’re ready to resume life on Earth.
True, they’ve changed a lot since we first met them, growing closer as step-grandfather and grandson, and of course they won’t be idle, what with planning to go save the world and all. I may not be fond of the man responsible for creating them, but I can’t deny they were a solid part of the last two seasons. I’ll miss them both, for sure.
And, as an avowed fan of bookends, I love that the last we see of them mirrors their first appearance: with Ryan on a hill, trying to ride a bicycle, while Graham shouts encouraging statements. The hill is the same, the camera angles, even the dialogue. So long, Ryan and Graham. Live long and prosper.
But… touching final scene aside… I didn’t like Revolution of the Daleks at all. True, it wasn’t like I was terribly excited for it in the first place, but as the closing scream of the theme music came in and the credits rolled, I have to admit: I don’t really want to watch this show anymore. Seven years ago, a statement like “THE DOCTOR WILL RETURN” would’ve filled me with joy and excitement. Now? Complete and absolute disinterest. Even the final shot of the TARDIS featuring two women in the console room, one of whom is the Doctor, should’ve set my lesbian heart aflame. But it didn’t.
Revolution of the Daleks is not the story that killed my love of Doctor Who. I don’t think anything could. I mean, the assortment of writing and blogging projects I’m working on devoted to it is proof enough of that, to say nothing of the fact that I am now an actual published author.
But, so long as Chris Chibnall remains in charge, it has killed my interest. I’ll still watch Series 13, of course, I have to. But only for the job. If I didn’t have that, I wouldn’t bother in the first place.
But enough of unlucky Thirteen. Eleven is calling my name.
PS: They hired John Bishop as the next companion. Because god forbid we let two women run the show for fucking once. Nobody wants a TARDIS full of bras, right, Chris?
Bastard.
Leave a Reply