First, something that actually relates to the episode in question, albeit tangentially: I write this post at a moment of happy coincidence. On May 10th, “Here Comes the Sun” from the Beatles album Abbey Road became that band’s first song to cross the billion streams marker on Spotify. The track, written by George Harrison on a sunny day at his friend Eric Clapton’s house, is also the most popular Beatles song on the platform, with “Strawberry Fields Forever,” “Come Together,” and “Yesterday” in second, third, and fourth place respectively.
Why mention this? Because of a trivia question asked during this episode about who had the most pre-download number one hits, according to the UK charts: The Beatles or Elvis? (Elvis, with 21 number one singles. The Beatles had 17. However, albums-wise it’s the Beatles with 15, and Elvis with 13.) Also, the Doctor namedrops “Sun” in his dialogue, so I felt like I should mention that.
This concludes the content that actually involves the episode 42, an otherwise forgettable action story that feels like a limp remake of series 2’s Satan two-parter, only with the Doctor in mortal danger for once. Let’s move on, shall we?
Part of the point of the Rewind is to observe how the RTD era has aged nearly 20 years after it began. Which means this episode, more than any other, exists at an interesting historical moment: it is an episode of Doctor Who written by Chris Chibnall, the first one I’ve seen since his era officially ended last October. This will not be a post about his considerable faults as a writer or his bewildering devolution between the RTD and Moffat eras and his own: that ground has already been covered.
Instead, I want to focus on the liminal space in which we now find ourselves, that extremely weird time between eras: the gap between the final episode of the last era, and the first episode of the new one.
And this time is perhaps stranger than most: for the first time, the incumbent Doctor in 2007, and the incumbent Doctor in 2023, are the same person. And even that is strictly more temporary than usual – by Christmas, it’ll be Ncuti Gatwa in control of the TARDIS rather than David Tennant. The Fourteenth Doctor will go on to have the shortest TV tenure of any series lead since Christopher Eccleston. Indeed, the sentence “Eccleston was the Doctor for longer than David Tennant” is a true statement. (With qualifiers, of course.)
In any other context, casting a previous Doctor to serve as series lead would be not so much an indicator that the show is running out of ideas as a GIANT FLASHING NEON SIGN indicating the same. But as this is the sixtieth anniversary year and anniversaries tend to come with a giant dollop of Nostalgia attached, certain things can be allowed.
First, let’s get something straight: the only reason we’re here having this discussion is because, a little over 18 months ago, RTD announced he would be returning to Doctor Who as showrunner, replacing Chris Chibnall. Had that not happened, the show would’ve been canceled outright and the anniversary year would be marked with… probably nothing.
Instead, we have anniversary specials that, judging by the trailers, are interrogating the concept of nostalgia. It’s not something I could imagine the RTD of the late 2000s writing, but it is something I could see Steven Moffat doing if his own anniversary special (The Day of the Doctor) hadn’t been more concerned with healing the lingering trauma from the cancellation. (Twice Upon A Time is closer, but still not quite it – no one was pining for the glory days of Hartnell-era Who, after all. Because he’s been dead for 48 years.)
This is an intriguing thread to follow, given that the immediately preceding episode of Who was Chibnall’s own The Power of the Doctor, a story that trades in very heavily on nostalgia of the past: in particular, the mid-late 1980s. And as with everything else with Chibnall, there was never any element of interrogation at hand in his nostalgia-chasing. Everything was, “Weren’t the 1980s great? Except Colin Baker, obviously?”
And you know, given he thought the show was going to be canceled, I can give him that. He’s not in charge anymore, so I’m not going to rake him over the coals for that particular decision. Instead, what I’d like to do is return to a theme from a post of mine that I wrote last October: not just nostalgia, but the reasons for it. And that means, once again, talking about Star Trek.
Star Trek: Picard, for most of its three seasons, actively avoided the nostalgia-chasing that plagued series 12 of Doctor Who and Power of the Doctor. Yes, we had Riker, Troi, and Data back in season one, and then Q and Guinan in season two, but the primary focus in both those seasons was on the crew of La Sirena.
Not so with season 3. Here, the focus returns to not just Picard, but the entire Next Gen crew he served with: Riker, Troi, Geordi, Worf, Beverly, Data, and of course, the 1701-D herself. The goal behind season 3, according to Terry Matalas, was to give that crew the send-off they didn’t get in 2002. And it is that: the show ties a nice bow around the Borg by having Jean-Luc face the Queen one more time, following up on Janeway nuking the Collective at the end of Voyager, while Geordi, Data, Troi, and Bev are on the newly restored Enterprise-D kicking ass and taking names. It’s exactly what you want from a TNG finale, which is quite something considering this is like their third one in a row.
And admittedly, I am probably warmer to the reunion concept than most people of my generation seem to be, having finished a TNG watch through the same week PIC 3 began airing. These characters were very fresh in my memory as I sat down to watch each episode.
Meanwhile, Tumblr viewers and some internet commentators framed the season as an indicator of a more conservative style of Star Trek, along with things like Strange New Worlds existing after fans called for it, (the same thing is happening with a potential Star Trek: Legacy show) the hero ship of PIC 3 being renamed from the Titan to the USS Enterprise, and the cancellation of Discovery, the only live-action Trek show not to feature a legacy ship, lead character, or be run by a white guy. Hell, it’s the only Trek show to have a Black woman as the lead protagonist.
And to be completely fair, I can see their point. Modern television production these days, much like movies, relies on established IP in order to attract viewers, the days of experimental projects that Netflix was doing back in the mid-2010s are long over. Star Trek, along with the Yellowstone Cinematic Universe, is pretty much the reason Paramount+ is still going strong, between SNW’s popularity and PIC appearing in the top ten Nielsen streaming charts twice in a row, the first of any Trek show to do that.
Nostalgia is inherently conservative, after all. That’s part of what was behind the slogan “Make America Great Again” – there was an earlier halcyon period of American history that we have moved away from, and should return to by any means necessary. And if that means exterminating minorities, well, then, that’s the cost of doing business.
However, I think there’s much more going on here than just the desire to wheel out old characters. PIC 3 is about a reunion with Team TNG, but notably, it comes after two seasons of denying that same nostalgia rush – part of the reason the reunion feels as good as it does is because the show spent its last two installments earning it by doing new things.
And that desire to do new things was part of Picard from day one, it’s why Patrick Stewart signed on in the first place. If the show had been about a TNG reunion, as some Trek fans have wished was true, he would’ve said no and left it at that.
Crucially, however, even with the reunion there are still new things going on: everyone’s gone up in rank since the movies ended. Geordi isn’t exactly thrilled to see Picard when he pops up in episode 5, and even he and Riker get into a tough spot at points in episode 3. Most crucially of all is Beverly, who makes it abundantly clear to him that what he is has an unfortunate habit of placing people in danger. There’s real character drama here, allowing the reunion to serve a purpose other than fan service.
And that, I think, is key. It’s far, far better to have nostalgia and use it to push characters forward than to have it for its own sake. As I wrote in October, nostalgia for the sake of itself is poison to a franchise – witness Doctor Who in the mid-1980s or Star Trek in the early 2000s. Picard starts the series as a cynical old man, alone but for his Romulan housekeepers, nursing his offended dignity, and ends it sitting around a table with his best friends, playing cards, content in the knowledge that the galaxy is safe.
This brings me back to Doctor Who, a show that is now beginning to engage with its own relationship with nostalgia. There has been some concern that David Tennant’s return, along with Catherine Tate and Murray Gold and the rest of the 2008 team, is pulling a similar “nostalgia for nostalgia’s sake” move that Chibnall did with Power.
I don’t think that’s what’s happening here. Reading between the lines, I feel like there will be an interrogation of nostalgia, not a whole-hearted embrace of it. Davies is an insanely compulsive viewer of television, and he, no doubt, has seen the nostalgia-heavy reboot culture that TV has been living in for the last several years, a culture that he was at the forefront of when he revived Doctor Who in the first place.
If, in 2005, he’d gone with the “safe” option and tried to do Doctor Who as it had been done in the mid-late 1970s, the show would’ve bombed. He knew the show had to be rethought from the ground up, and that’s what he did.
What’s funny is that now, in 2023, he has essentially gone back to where he was in 2003. Doctor Who right now is not in the same place it was in ten years ago for the fiftieth: back then, it was still reasonably popular and well-regarded in the press. Now? It’s become creatively stagnant. But Davies has made it abundantly clear he’s going to do things differently. Ncuti Gatwa is the start of that.
Whatever happens in November though, I’ll say this: I trust RTD to do what’s right for the show, long-term. That’s always been his goal, going back to when the BBC tried to cancel the show after series 4 and he told them they weren’t allowed. Bringing back Tennant and Tate will get eyeballs on the show, and once that’s done he can launch the Gatwa charm offensive.
Leave a Reply