The Mactíre Anthology: Series 12 Review

The good news about Series 12 is that, even if an entire year without new TV Doctor Who to watch sucked, the 18-month break seemed to be exactly what this production team needed to truly get its collective shit together. Series 11 felt like a group of people building a plane in midair with only a vague idea of how it should look, especially in relation to the scripts and direction. Series 12, by and large, managed to achieve a basic level of competence for most of the time it was on.

Of course, the good news (IT WAS USUALLY COMPETENT!) is also the bad news. There was only one real low (Spyfall Part 2), and while there were highs (Tesla and Haunting), those highs would, in any other season, be Gatiss historical romps: enjoyable, but not exactly terribly memorable.

And as good as Series 12 was compared to its immediate predecessor, it still contained a lot of the same flaws. The companions were all terribly underused this time, especially in the case of Yaz, but even Bradley Walsh and Tosin Cole had little to do except be different flavors of comic relief while Mandip Gill got to be Exposition, in the rare scenes where they actually got to share the screen with the woman credited ahead of them every week. Can You Hear Me seems like a last-ditch attempt to give everyone some backstory, but as ever it goes unremarked upon following the end titles.

The biggest problem with Series 12, of course, remains the guy in charge. It did not help that he wrote or co-wrote all but three of the episodes transmitted, but at least with those there were other writers there to make things bearable. It’s when the man is allowed to write his own scripts that things get problematic.

To take one example, consider his obsession with DNA. It’s popped up everywhere in his era, starting with Tim Shaw’s DNA bombs to the spiders in Arachnids in the UK to Lenny Henry’s Evil Silicon Valley Executive being only 93% human, and now we get to The Timeless Children and its big reveal that the Time Lords stole regeneration energy from the Doctor because she was genetically superior, a point she was clear to shout in the Master’s face. (Of course, seeing as how this is the same Doctor who threw the Master to the Nazis, who’s really surprised? She’d make a better poster child for the Aryan race than he would.) I’m not suggesting Chibnall secretly supports eugenics or whatever, but COME THE FUCK ON. HOW DO YOU NOT SEE WHERE THIS IS GOING.

There is very little about this era that I can’t praise without adding caveats. Yes, casting two female Doctors was an objectively good idea… but one is an ineffectual corporatist with no coherent morals, and the other isn’t even the star of the show, and she may never be. Diversity in casting and writing is also progress, but most of the good lines are given to the white guy, and all the writers of color get co-written by another white guy. The only reason it’s being done is to earn praise, but all the praise in the world won’t save you if your audience numbers keep dropping.

Doctor Who has been back for 15 years now, as of this month. To put it in perspective, as of March 2020, we are as far away from Rose as The Stones of Blood was to An Unearthly Child. But because time now moves apparently at warp speed, it feels like we’re a lot closer to the dark days of the Saward era, and yes, Pip and Jane Baker. Sure, according to Piers Wenger the show isn’t getting cancelled, but I’m not talking about if it’ll get cancelled. I’m thinking about whether it should.

To be honest, it’s not an easy question to answer. If you think about it, with the ascendancy of Chibnall, we’ve entered a new phase of the new series (if it can still be called that after a decade and a half). The first phase were the Davies and Moffat seasons, and while they were both wildly different in many respects, it still felt like the same show.

The Chibnall era is new, and even if this season was much heavier on continuity than Series 11 had been, it still feels like it takes place in a different show to the one we saw over the first ten seasons. And I am hesitant to say the show should be cancelled when something new is still taking place. (And anyway, Chibnall and Whittaker have both confirmed they’ll be back for Series 13, so it’s a moot point.)

I guess what I’m saying is, whether or not we continue to plunge into this festival of mediocrity is up to us. I’m going to, because I have blogs and books and shit to write. But you, my dear readers, are under no such obligation, so if I were you, I’d find something more constructive with which to occupy your time.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑