First, let’s get something straight: this is not going to be a blog post comparing Human Nature the TV story to its original prose incarnation – I haven’t read the book, and anyway, that ground has been well covered by Elizabeth Sandifer. So instead, I am going to write about something else.
Let’s start by returning to a theme I explored back in the Lazarus post: the Davies era’s monstrous view of the Doctor versus the Moffat era’s far more humanized take.
Family of Blood concerns itself with a question: What, exactly, is the Doctor?
To answer this question, the story decides to have the Doctor turn himself into a human named John Smith, and drops him in the middle of England in the early 1900s, the year before World War I begins. He does have dreams of his actual life, which he records in his Journal of Impossible Things, but they’re just that: stories he tells himself.
As Joan frames it a little later, “The Doctor is the man you’d like to be, doing impossible things with cricket balls.” Indirectly, this gets at a central theme of the Moffat era: the Doctor as a title to live up to, rather than a specific person, decoupling the name from the Time Lord.
But this is not the Moffat era. As I noted a couple weeks back, the Davies era has a far more negative view of the Doctor than the Moffat era does, and Family is the clearest expression yet of that difference. In part two, Martha is framed as mad for wanting the Doctor to return, and the Doctor himself is framed as something Other. Briefly, John says a bit of Doctorish technobabble and reacts with horror: “Is that how he talks?!”
Then the inevitable happens. He opens the watch and becomes the Doctor again, and the final defeat of the Family is detailed via voiceover: “He never raised his voice. That was the worst thing. The fury of the Time Lord. And then we discovered why. Why this Doctor, who had fought with gods and demons, why he’d run away from us and hidden. He was being kind. […] We wanted to live forever, so the Doctor made sure that we did.”
But wait, there’s more. The Doctor’s final damnation comes from Joan, as he goes back to 1913 to say goodbye. She asks him a question: “If the Doctor had never visited us, if he’d never chosen this place on a whim, would anybody here have died?”
This question, in a way, ties all the way back to Rose, when the eponymous character goes to meet Clive, who tells her something pivotal about the Doctor: “The Doctor is a legend woven throughout history. When disaster comes, he’s there. He brings the storm in his wake and he has one constant companion. […] Death.”
That sentence, right there, is the Davies era’s view of the Doctor summed up, and the entire era keeps that frame up. The Doctor is a monster who just happens to be on the side of good. But even that, as the final defeat of the Family demonstrates, is not set in stone. The Doctor’s original plan (hide away as a human and let the Family die naturally) was born from his own fear of what he could do to the Family if pushed far enough. Their final defeat indicates he had every right to be afraid of himself.
The Moffat era, by contrast, pushes against this viewpoint pretty much from the word go. In The Beast Below, his plan for the Star Whale is basically a microcosm of his decision to end the Time War by using the Moment to destroy Gallifrey. Very specifically, he says: “Look, three options. One, I let the Star Whale continue in unendurable agony for hundreds more years. Two, I kill everyone on this ship. Three, I murder a beautiful, innocent creature as painlessly as I can. And then I find a new name, because I won’t be the Doctor any more.”
And then Amy takes a fourth option, just as Clara does at the climax of The Day of the Doctor. Kindness returns here, but it’s working in a different register compared to how Son of Mine framed it: “What if you were really old, and really kind and alone? Your whole race dead. No future. What couldn’t you do then? If you were that old, and that kind, and the very last of your kind, you couldn’t just stand there and watch children cry.”
Kindness, in the Davies era, means running away and hoping the Family will just die before he has to do something really horrible, and let the monster within come to the fore. Whereas in the Moffat era, it becomes something that the Doctor essentially is, what separates him from the monsters he fights. They are darkness, and he is light.
The challenging of this “the Doctor is a monster” view never really stops either. It’s omnipresent, from the Doctor’s enemies building an inescapable prison box to contain him at the end of Series 5, to the Great Intelligence changing the Doctor’s timeline at the end of Series 7, or the exploration of “Am I a good man” that animates Series 8.
Even the War Doctor, presented as the most monstrous of his incarnations because had to forsake the title in order to end the Time War, is ultimately still kind, and thus, still the Doctor in the end.
In Series 6, after spending the entire season deconstructing the Doctor, River Song desperately reconstructs him by pointing out exactly why he can’t allow himself to be killed: “You’ve touched so many lives, saved so many people. Did you think when your time came, you’d really have to do more than just ask? You’ve decided that the universe is better off without you, but the universe doesn’t agree.”
For my money, nothing illustrates the dichotomy of the Moffat and Davies eras quite like that exchange when compared to Son of Mine’s closing monologue at the end of Family. And as good as Family is, (and it really is a fucking masterpiece) the stark difference of how it views the Doctor when compared to something like The Beast Below or The Day of the Doctor keeps it from being a story that I unabashedly love.
Remember, I came to Doctor Who right at the very beginning of the Moffat era in 2010, when Matt Smith was the Doctor. I wavered a bit when Capaldi came on, but 11 urging Clara to give 12 a chance led to me doing the same, and I’m so glad I did, because I’ve grown to love the Capaldi era almost as much as Smith’s. And Moffat’s view of the Doctor, for better or for worse, is the one I prefer. As good as the Davies era has been, I will always disagree with its fundamental premise.
Having said this, I am also keenly aware that this is the RTD of the mid-late 2000s I’m dealing with here. This is the era of Daniel Craig’s first two Bond movies, two thirds of the Nolan Batman trilogy, and early Breaking Bad – byronic and anti-heroes were all the rage back then.
But times have changed. We don’t know yet know what Davies’ views on the Doctor have become now that he’s had roughly 14 years off to consider the question. However, this is RTD we’re talking about: he’s a Doctor Who fan, he’s queer as all get out, and he doesn’t so much watch television as take it intravenously. And with that said, I think we can figure some things out.
My guess, going by what he’s seen of the Moffat era, is that he’ll want to move away from the monstrous take he offered back in the 2000s, toward something more… kid friendly, so to speak. There’s been precious little of that in Doctor Who of late.
My friend Bren O’Shea (who is, incidentally, about to start a look at the Troughton era) floated the possibility of taking the Doctor into more of a found family register: in this hypothetical, the Doctor would be positioned as a father figure or mentor to Ruby Sunday, played by Millie Gibson. This is very similar to early Moffat era Doctor Who, which presented the Doctor as a part of the Pond family: River, Amy’s daughter, is his wife, making Amy and Rory his parents-in-law.
But the key difference is that the Doctor married into an existing biological family. In the queer community, biological connections are a bit more complicated. (She said, with a spectacular amount of understatement.)
We instead have found families: a group of queer people who consider themselves to be family, even though none of them are biologically related to each other. (Because, surprise, a lot of our blood families don’t necessarily react well to their kid coming out as queer.)
And Davies, being a gay man, has extensive experience in writing about found families: for crying out loud, that’s the cast of It’s A Sin. And because of how far things have shifted with regard to queer rep compared to the mid 2000s, he’ll be able to be a lot more blatant with any queer allegories than he was back then, in an age of deeply ingrained heterosexuality for lead characters and things like George Bush winning in 2004 over the fear of gay marriage laws being passed.
The notion of the Doctor as a family man is also very different from his first era, where the Doctor was explicitly described as “not doing domestics,” even if Sarah Jane eventually described him as having “the biggest family on Earth.” But it could work! We have evidence both within Doctor Who, and out of it.
As we know from a recent column in Doctor Who Magazine, RTD watches Star Trek: Picard. In the context of the letter he was excited because one of the characters in that show said the title of one of Series 14’s episodes, but even so, the broader context of the season itself got me thinking.
What does season 3 of PIC do? As well as reuniting the admiral with his former senior staff from the Enterprise, it presents him a new wrinkle in the form of Jack Crusher, his son. Born shortly after the events of Nemesis, Jack’s existence was kept secret from Picard for 20 years. The season then asks itself: what happens when the man who once admitted to Riker that he wasn’t good with kids, and only reluctantly made Wesley Crusher an acting ensign, is suddenly forced into the position of father?
The answer to that question is somewhat beyond the scope of this post, so I’ll just say this: by the end of the season, he has not only learned to embrace Jack, he has grown into a warm and loving man in general, a galaxy away from the cold and distant person he was in early TNG.
And while obviously, certain aspects of Picard’s journey aren’t directly applicable to Doctor Who, (we all remember what happened when we tried the “give the Doctor a biological child” line in series 4) I think the basic premise – placing an old man in father/mentor type role – could translate pretty well. If we’re trying to move away from monstrousness, that’s a pretty good way to go about it.
But to get there, Davies will have to tangle with something else: by which I mean, the end of series 4, and the rueful fate of Donna Noble. At the end of Journey’s End, the Doctor wipes her mind of her time with him, to keep her mind from exploding thanks to her becoming part Time Lord. (Long story.) And he does this even as she begs him not to.
It is, quite blatantly, assault. And for the last 15 years it’s stood as a black mark on that era of the show. Moffat tried responding to it in 2015 with Hell Bent, by putting the Twelfth Doctor and Clara in an identical position, but with the roles reversed: this time, it’s the Doctor who gets his mind wiped, though only of what Clara looked like, not their adventures together.
But the only one who can truly heal this particular wound is RTD himself. The 60th, by all appearances, seems to be doing exactly that: yes, the Doctor has David Tennant’s face again and here he is with the Noble family, but time has passed and this isn’t a happy reunion story. There’s a point here, and that point may be the fulfillment of unfinished business. Just as the fiftieth anniversary special healed the wound created by the Time War, the sixtieth specials may do the same thing for Donna’s memories: their restoration, and his regeneration.
The best anniversary specials, after all, move the show forward. The Three Doctorsgave the Doctor the ability to travel in time and space again, freeing him from the confines of UNIT and the military sci-fi show that Doctor Who had become in the early 1970s. The Day of the Doctor, as said, restored Gallifrey and allowed the Doctor to move on from his Time War angst by giving him the chance to save his home world, rather than burn it. Davies, I hope, is going in a similar direction.
Only time will tell.
Leave a Reply