It’s funny, watching Blink now that we’re six years removed from the end of the Moffat era. The answer to the question “Does it still hold up” is yes, of course. It shows beyond a doubt why he was the choice to take over for RTD back in the 2010s. Moffat has written, all by himself, 1780 minutes of Doctor Who across 50 episodes, the most of anyone in the revived series.
(That being said, it won’t take RTD very long to catch up…)
So, what is it about his stories that make them so good? Some might say his comedic background leads him to write dialogue that’s heavy on jokes, quips, and one-liners – the same kind of humor found on American comedy shows. Others might say how skilled he is at plotting: even when he’s not quite fully baked, for example with Let’s Kill Hitler or Wedding of River Song, there’s still enough logic and enough emotional content to carry the day, so you don’t notice the gaps.
But for my money, the biggest reason is the extent to which he completely understands the thing he’s writing for. And I don’t just mean, “He can pull out deep continuity references just for the hell of it,” like in The Pilot where he brings in some Movellans just for the hell of it. Obscurity of in-jokes does not equate to good writing.
(Because if it did, The Timeless Children wouldn’t suck.)
What I mean is, he understands how to craft a Doctor Who story, and how to do so in a way that never leaves you bored. Blink, perhaps, is a bit more atypical than most stories in the show, but that’s one of the great things about it: the perspective flip keeps things interesting.
Speaking of perspective flips, consider his very first TV Doctor Who story, The Curse of Fatal Death from 1999. Broadcast as a Comic Relief skit, the story essentially functions not just as a loving send-up of classic Doctor Who, but as a regular story with a larger-than-average number of jokes in it, as he explained in an interview from issue 510 of DWM:
“The brief Richard gave me was that people don’t necessarily like you utterly taking the piss out of their favourite thing. They want it to be loving and positive. My view at the time, which everyone was very keen on, was ‘Let’s just make it a funny Doctor Who, rather than a spoof’. So it could just about happen in a real episode, it doesn’t break any rules.”
It’s a good approach, honestly. The love he has for the series bleeds through the entire script, and not just there either. It’s in everything he writes. He loves the show and he dearly wants to express that love the best way he can, by making some of the best television he can. And he pulls it off with astounding regularity.
Blink, by some distance, is everything great about Moffat in microcosm, though I realize that’s a very subjective opinion – I’ve heard it said that some people prefer his RTD scripts over his own era’s, which is an opinion I admit I am somewhat mystified by. It’s not as if he’s writing the show any differently in Empty Child than he was for, say, The Eleventh Hour or The Husbands of River Song. It’s the same guy!
Is he perfect? God, no. The Space/Time sketches he wrote for Comic Relief in 2011, while every bit as Doctor Who-ish as Fatal Death, are also probably some of his most sexist work. The Doctor, the Widow, and the Wardrobe has that tiresome running joke about Madge Arwell not being good at driving. And it’s a bit depressing that the only two gay men in his entire era are the two marines in Good Man, who exist entirely to be killed off. They don’t even get real names! It’s almost Chibnallian, only with a bit more self-awareness.
But. None of that renders him the evilest thing in all creation, either. There are people in this fandom who’ve spent the last ten years dramatically declaring him to be the Spawn of Satan Himself, which I am sure would be big news to Satan.
What it makes him is human. He is imperfect, as are all of us. And I think his considerable hatedom out there either forgets that, or chooses to ignore it deliberately, in service of endless ad hominem attacks.
And that’s exhausting. I’m all for a reasonable discussion of a given writer’s faults and virtues as much as anyone, but I mean just that: reasonable. And Moffat discourse left the realm of reasonable a long freaking time ago. While I do hope he comes back to write for the new Davies era, I do not expect him to, nor would I want, him to return as showrunner. He had his moment, and it was a wonderful moment. His legacy can be the writers he influences in the future.
Leave a Reply