The RTD Rewind: Partners in Crime

Hello, faithful reader! Welcome back to the RTD Rewind, now posting weekly once again as we get closer and closer to the beginning of the new RTD era. Since we last saw each other, I have moved to Ithaca, New York, where my girlfriend lives. So, welcome to the first post of the new era! Let’s get moving, shall we?

It’s rather fitting that I reach Tennant’s final regular season a little over a month before the 60th airs, since by all accounts, the upcoming trio of anniversary specials will serve as a sequel (or perhaps, a coda) to this run of stories from 2008.

To put this in perspective, consider the following piece of information: we are now almost as far from Partners in Crime as Rose was from Survival. Now consider that Millie Gibson, AKA Ruby Sunday, was less than a year old when Rose aired.

Kind of a head-trip, isn’t it?

When watched as a follow-up to series 3, Partners in Crime feels like a show that absolutely exudes confidence in itself – we have a proven Doctor in the form of David Tennant, and we have Catherine Tate back as Donna Noble, who’s been subtly reworked from the loud, opinionated bride that she was before. After a season in which the show visibly struggled to find its footing again in the wake of Billie Piper’s departure, this episode presents a refreshing return to form.

Let’s start with the obvious: this is Doctor Who as comedy. Coming from the much darker Voyage of the Damned, much less the Master trilogy of Utopia/The Sound of Drums/Last of the Time Lords, seeing Davies write something lighter is an excellent shift. I’m not entirely sure the diet culture satire has aged especially well, though. (Then again, fatphobia has long been one of RTD’s worst flaws as a writer. Just look at the Slitheen.)

Doctor Who stories where there aren’t any formal villains are always interesting to me – in a show that has, for 60 years, been defined by its antagonists, what do you do when there isn’t one? (I mean, okay, Miss Foster is kinda-sorta an antagonist, but only so far as the Doctor and Donna need someone to act against. In terms of threats, Foster is about as scary as Prisoner Zero.)

The answer is, focus more on the characters that you do have. Vincent and the Doctor did this by zeroing in on Vincent’s depression and general mental health issues, The Girl Who Waited did it with the Doctor’s relationship to Amy by depicting how quickly love can curdle into hate, and here we have an illustration of Donna’s home life. Spoiler alert: it is not good.

It’s funny how the passage of time can affect which characters you relate to most. When I was writing my original drafts of Back to the Eleventh Hour, back in 2019, I was 25 and still identifying pretty heavily with Amy: well into adulthood, still living in the home where I grew up, still not entirely sure of my place in the world.

Four years have passed since then. I’m 29 now. (In fact, I’m writing this the day after my birthday.) I’m aware of my approaching thirties, and that comes with a different set of priorities, especially now that I’m in a stable, lasting relationship. I’m not Rose Tyler living at home with Jackie anymore, I’m Donna, trying to figure out a life for myself and find a job that’s actually fulfilling, instead of more corporate drudgery.

About the only thing that separates me from Donna at this point, is that while we both have overbearing mothers who seemingly exist only to put us down in ways large and small, is that I have now moved out of that house once and fucking for all, and it’s all thanks to my girlfriend that’s even the case.

Granted, moving out isn’t the end of my problems: I still have to make money to feed not only myself, but my girlfriend too. I still have to pay rent, and bills, and all the other bits of financial obligation that one deals with in late capitalism. I am lucky to have a plan in place that will allow me to do that, but it’s not perfect, and it won’t be a lot of money.

But at least my own personal Sylvia Noble isn’t in my life anymore. Or rather, her presence in it has been significantly minimized.

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about escaping from bad environments lately, for obvious reasons. The Doctor has always provided such an escape, but it doesn’t come up as much as one would think. Sure, Rose had a humdrum existence she needed a break from, but Jackie genuinely loved her. Whereas what Donna gets stuck with? Genuine emotional abuse of the kind that I am very familiar with.

Tate’s acting in those scenes is a masterclass: here is a woman who, despite the front she puts on, (her line “How old am I?” is a slight flash of her usual fire) she is severely beaten down. Witness the way she barely moves during the lecture montage, and if you’ve ever been through a similar experience, you’ll feel pangs of sympathy. I know I did.

What Donna needs (and this is made abundantly clear in the sequences at her house) is an escape. Her mom spends time infantilizing her and lecturing her, and the only solace she’s got is with Wilf, the only person in that house who actually respects her. Then, by pure luck (and a series of amazing near-misses) she finally meets up with the Doctor.

What hurts about this episode is watching it with the knowledge of what happens to Donna at the end of the season: her memories are taken from her, and she loses all that character development to end up exactly where she started: stuck in a miserable existence with no way out, short of a miracle… and that miracle can never occur, because for her to remember would mean her immediate death.

Which brings me back to where I began: the sixtieth anniversary specials. Even with only a trailer to go on, it’s plain as day what RTD’s plan is for this year, and it goes far beyond a desire to win back the crowd after the previous era’s failures. (Though there is  that.)

Just as the 50th anniversary healed the wound of the show’s cancelation and amended the end of the Time War in such a way that the Doctor’s essential Doctor-ness is preserved, while making sure to respect the past, the 60th will find itself dealing with unfinished business of a different sort altogether, but no less damaging.

RTD has had the better part of fifteen years to rethink the rueful fate of Donna Noble, and I honestly believe that these specials will end with her safe, and her memories restored. How the Toymaker and Beep the Meep fit in I can’t imagine, but the bare essentials (A Doctor with Tennant’s face and Donna Noble) are all there. A chance like this doesn’t come very often, and what are anniversaries for, but to move the show forward?

The Doctor and Donna Noble, partners in crime, then and now.

Let’s go.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑