The RTD Rewind: Planet of the Ood

And after two seasons of waiting, here we are, the long-awaited sequel to the Satan two-parter from… well, series 2. As you might have guessed from the last time I talked about the Ood, I was not a fan of how they were treated in their first appearance. To illustrate this, I talked about the TNG episode “The Measure of a Man,” and how it succeeded at doing in 1989 what Doctor Who failed to do seventeen years later – argue for the rights and personhood of a minority group.

Now, at long last, we have the Doctor’s mea culpa.

What’s refreshing about this story compared to Impossible Planet is that, for once, the slavers of the Ood are framed as villains. Which, being slavers, they fucking should be. The Ood, meanwhile, are portrayed far more positively here than they were back in 2006 – yes, there are plenty of scenes where a bunch of pissed-off Ood endanger the Doctor and Donna, but even that is explained away by the Ood rebelling after years and years of mistreatment.

Crucially, the Doctor and Donna don’t actually do much in this story, aside from irritating the employees of Ood Operations. Their main role is to support the Ood in their entirely-justified revolution, starting from when they attempt to care for the fallen Ood at the start of the episode, all the way to the scene in Warehouse 15 where the giant Ood Brain is hidden.

What I love about this story is that, dark though it is, it’s on the side of the Ood the entire time, while making very sharp points about consumerism and the kinds of things one is referring to when we say, “there is no ethical consumption under capitalism.” For example: I am typing this sentence on a 2022 MacBook Air that was assembled in China, where factory employees are forced to work long hours for little pay. The people who made my Mac, quite frankly, wouldn’t be able to afford one of their own.

As Simon Le Bon observes in the Duran Duran song “Paper Gods,”:

Hey, you’re gonna want it all the talking man declares

Go running to be first in line for what? Nobody cares!

The next thing you must have find peace with matching bag

It’s nothing to be glad about or sad when you forget about it

And while the race is on the rest will run the streets

The slaver in a sweatshop,

Putting trainers on your feet

I’m walking through the rain, oblivious to pain

To shelter from the blame without a reason to complain about it

These are the kinds of tradeoffs we have to make in a society that has not yet reached the point of a post-scarcity economy that you have in, say, Star Trek. To live in a wealthy western country like the United States is to be keenly aware, at all times, that virtually everything you use on a daily basis was made by someone in a Chinese sweatshop. To get the latest gear, you have to participate in a society that is inherently exploitive. Not participating isn’t an option either, because of the way our society is designed. We are exploiting people, even as we are also being exploited.

All of this is to say that, as the story’s TV Tropes page observes, “revolutionary violence against an evil system is morally justified.” Hell, even something like this past summer’s writers and actors strike is a form of revolution, as are the innumerable stories we have of Starbucks employees unionizing over the objections of their employers, or the stories about pharmacists at Walgreens walking out in protest over understaffing, workload, and low pay.

The society depicted in Planet of the Ood, by and large, is not dissimilar to our own. Once again we have a race of people being exploited to feed the Money God, and it takes a full-on revolution for any change to be made. And we’re seeing this exact dynamic play out now: it took months of striking and picketing for Hollywood writers to make their occupation a viable job, even as the studios and streamers they worked for wanted to outsource everything to AI. Yes, deals were reached, and one hopes that in three years they won’t have to do this again, but everyone has to play fair for that to be the case, and in a capitalistic society, “playing fair” is anathema.

Capitalism is inherently unequal. There is always an underclass, whether they are Ood, people of color, or hourly employees who don’t get benefits or any form of compensation whatsoever aside from wages. I used to be one of those employees! And it sucked! Nothing, and I mean nothing, will put you on the train to socialism faster than being forced to ring out entitled idiots for hours at a time.

So when I sit here, and I watch the humans of the 42nd century lobotomize the Ood so they can have alien slaves as opposed to African ones, I am entirely on board with the Ood rebellion. I am glad that the Doctor and Donna didn’t really have much to do except be the support team, because this isn’t their fight. This is the fight of not just the Ood, but every single person who’s had to give entirely too much of themselves to a society that can never have enough.

This is the fight of actors, writers, baristas, and pharmacists. This is the fight of everyone who has ever looked at a CEO and the obscenely huge amounts of money they make, and goes, “This is unfair.” Bob Iger makes more money in an hour than most retail employees do in a year. Does that not strike anyone else as being inherently unequal?

I live in the richest country on Earth. We should not have a homeless problem, and yet we do. We should not have a student debt problem, and yet we do. “The economy is going great!” say writers in The Atlantic, while cheerfully ignoring the fact that prices on everything are going up everywhere, we’re overworked, overtired, and generally unable to even scrape by, much less thrive.

“The acquisition of wealth is no longer the driving force in our lives. We work to better ourselves and the rest of humanity,” says Captain Picard in First Contact. If only his particular brand of twenty-fourth century morality would make its way to the twenty-first.

But on the plus side, the Ood are free. And I do love the smell of liberation in the morning.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑