Captain’s log, stardate 78870.4: “The crew of the Enterprise is subjected to an exotic illness that drives them to unusual manic behavior, akin to a type of alcoholic intoxication.”
The received fan wisdom regarding TNG is much the same as the received fan wisdom regarding the sequel series, Star Trek: Picard: skip seasons one and two, proceed directly to season three. I dislike statements like this because it feels reductive. It’s a bit like saying, “Skip all the Beatles albums before Pepper,” or “Don’t bother with Christopher Eccleston’s Doctor, watch David Tennant instead.”
In all these cases, there are genuine moments of quality in the early stages of a given thing, and those moments get missed if you tar them all with the brush of ignorance. It took The Beatles several albums to become true artists in their own right, but their earlier 1960s pop records still contain plenty of highlights, and in a lot of ways, are the foundation upon which Pepper, Abbey Road, or the White Album are built.
It’s a similar story with Doctor Who. Yes, we all love the more conventionally successful eras of David Tennant and Matt Smith, but even though Eccleston’s tenure lasted only a year, nearly every single one of his stories is a highlight, and the only one that isn’t is still really good. You can’t really get much better than “Doctor Who blows up Rupert Murdoch.”
TNG’s first season is slightly more complicated. There are some genuinely good stories in here, and when we watch them I’ll be sure to point them out… but there are also some incredibly bad stories in here, and “The Naked Now” is one of them.
My girlfriend had this to say when she watched it: “Wesley sure does a ton of uh, Wesleying. Also there are MANY horny women on this ship, and you can tell the script was written by a dude.”
And she was right, at least in part! The authorship of “Naked Now” is somewhat complex. “J. Michael Bingham” was a pseudonym used by D.C. Fontana, as she was very dissatisfied with the finished episode relative to the script she turned in. In the second Fifty Year Mission book, she writes:
“While the script was given a good reaction by almost everyone, the Roddenberry pattern of dealing with scripts befell it. After a staffer turned in the official second draft of the script, they were not allowed to touch it again. No matter how good a script appeared to be, it would be rewritten by Gene Roddenberry. If possible, scenes of sexual content would be inserted into the script. When two such scenes were put into ‘The Naked Now’, in addition to other scenes which I felt debased the female characters of the series, I put my sentiments into a frankly worded memo of comment on the script. My comments were ignored.”
Such was the way of writing for TNG in the late 1980s. Roddenberry was a deeply horny old man by that time, and the edits he made to Fontana’s script made “The Naked Now” a deeply problematic episode of the series. Quite a sobering comedown after how well “Farpoint” turned out.
Even Wil Wheaton, whose character of Wesley Crusher is the solution to the problem that crops up in act five, hated this episode. He wrote in 2006:
“‘The Naked Now’ has some genuinely funny moments, but it was only the second time that audiences had seen us, and this episode was not the best way to introduce the audience to a new show, with a new cast, especially when we all knew we were standing on the shoulders of giants.”
They have a point. The mystery of the Tsiolkovsky would have been compelling enough without exposing the crew to the polywater intoxication. But even if that was necessary, why on Earth is it all the women who come on to the male characters, while the men are left to act like children? It makes no sense to me.
Then again, this is the 1980s we’re talking about: the era of John Nathan-Turner and Eric Saward in Doctor Who, where they put Peri in a succession of low-cut v-necks “for the dads.” Nathan-Turner and Saward would’ve been right at home in the TNG production office under Roddenberry.
Worst-served by this train wreck is Tasha Yar, in only the first occurrence of something that will go on to define her character for the remainder of her time on the show. Let’s call it The Tasha Problem. Here we have a character who is given a truly horrifying backstory: left alone on a planet somewhere, fleeing from the rape gangs that torment the place…
And all of this is justification for her to fuck Data. And, the whole rape gang thing is bad enough by itself. Obviously the show is never going to deal with that in detail, so why fucking include it?! The TNG book line (which, incidentally, begins in July of 1988, during the break between seasons 1 and 2) gives her some background in the book Survivors.
In fact, that book (I am reading it now in fact) does more with Tasha and her life story in 253 pages than she ever gets on the show. Which is a crying shame. Tasha is a wonderful character, but much of that wonderfulness comes from how Denise Crosby played her. Both Tasha and Crosby deserve better than to be turned into titillation fodder to soothe Roddenberry’s giant ego. Did the man think with his groin?!
The episode’s trope pages don’t help. Under the “What Could Have Been” bullet, we’re told:
“The story went through various stages of wackiness in its early rewrites. At least one draft played it more seriously, using the polywater virus as an opportunity to explore the new characters and what makes them tick (as per the TOS original), but the shooting script dropped most of this character background in favor of massive amounts of Denser and Wackier instead.”
Which pretty much says it all right there. This story, if you ask me, is the Star Trek equivalent of Doctor Who’s The Twin Dilemma. We’ve barely gotten to know these characters, and you’re forcing them into a position where they become unlikable. I honestly wonder how many people, in October 1987, tuned into this episode and never watched another episode of TNG again.
If I didn’t already know how the story goes, I wouldn’t blame them for stopping.
Leave a Reply