The RTD Rewind: The Sontaran Stratagem/The Poison Sky

So, stop me if you’ve heard this one before, but: Freema Agyeman appears in a two-part Doctor Who story featuring some villains from the show’s classic series period, written by Helen Raynor, and there’s a bad American accent. And credit where it’s due, while there was a lot about Raynor’s Dalek two-parter that sucked and isn’t her fault. There is some interesting stuff in there… not good stuff, but interesting stuff.

Sadly, this Sontaran story is a bit lacking in the interesting ideas department. Part of the problem is the choice of villain: Sontarans, in general, can be fairly accurately described as what the Klingons would be had they not received a more in-depth examination during the middle seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation – a one-note warrior race with little to define them that’s actually half interesting.

I mean, at least Klingons have opera. The Sontarans don’t even have that!

Here’s the thing about Sontarans: they’re supposed to be rubbish. They were first introduced in 1973’s The Time Warrior, a Pertwee story written by Robert Holmes. Linx, the first Sontaran ever, is supposed to be a guy who talks a big game and promises to send Irongron more gear with which he can start making some conquests… but as it turns out, Linx is no better at being a military supply depot than Irongron is at being a warlord.

So why is it that, when it comes to Sontarans in the modern era, everyone is obsessed with making them out to be a significant threat? In this story at least, it makes sense – this is their first outing in a long time, but even so, it doesn’t quite wash for me.

On the plus side, this is the Doctor Who debut of Dan Starkey, who will go on to play Sontarans for both of RTD’s successors. Under Chibnall, he pops up in series 13 as various Sontaran characters, but most people remember him as Strax, the Sontaran nursemaid from A Good Man Goes to War. While Strax was mainly a comedic character, Starkey does put in a nice villain turn as Commander Skorr, particularly when acting against Freema Agyeman. Nice to see he’s got some range, at least!

Moving away from the Messrs. Potato-Head for a bit, let’s talk about Martha Jones. I genuinely loved her as a character, even if she got herself shoehorned into that tiresome unrequited love plot line with the Doctor. I see her as a forerunner of Clara – someone who is naturally very good at the companion thing. It’s a shame, then, that she was wasted so heavily on series 3.

And, it must be said, she’s not terribly well utilized here either. I’m glad they brought her back, but why on Earth did they have to make her an evil clone?! And even then, they don’t really commit to the bit much beyond having her smile evilly when no one’s looking and brush off the Doctor’s concern for her family! Whatever else you might think about series 9’s Zygon two-parter, at least Jenna Coleman got to actually flex her acting muscles and give us Evil Clara for part two of that story. Martha’s clone, toward the end, just ends up being Martha 2.0 instead.

And then there’s the Doctor himself, who spends most of this story being a giant asshole toward the UNIT solders – his ceaseless bitching about guns is only the start of it. I mean sure, this was par for the course in the early 1970s, but at some point it stops being amusing and starts being genuinely insulting. Good on Col. Mace for shutting that shit down during the gas mask scene.

Finally, we have Luke Rattigan: the most annoying kid in the world. As TVTropes observed, this guy makes Wesley Crusher look good by comparison. Make him a few years older and, if he hadn’t blown himself up on the Sontaran ship, he’d probably be posting on the incel subreddit while plotting a school shooting or something.

If it reads like I’m grasping at straws for things to complain about here, it’s because I am. It’s ironic that a story with as much stuff going on in it as this, what with the Sontarans, UNIT, global warming, Donna’s family, Martha Jones, and so on has so little that’s interesting enough for me to spend a thousand words on.

Honestly, I haven’t struggled on an essay this badly since the dark days of the Chibnall era, which ended a year ago yesterday as I write this. It definitely feels like the kind of overstuffed thing he’d write – hell, Sontarans and UNIT facing off again is more or less the plot of the series 13 finale, or so I’m told. (I’ve never actually seen it, and never will.)

So maybe, instead, I’ll turn my attention to the writer. Of the two stories Raynor did, which is better?

It’s genuinely a tough question, because while neither of the two stories is what you’d call Good Doctor Who, both stories have their strong points. Poison is better realized, especially when it comes to the design of the Sontarans themselves, but then again, doing better than Penishead McGee isn’t all that difficult.

On the other paw, Evolution at least had the whole “Why is a Dalek evil” thing going for it. You could do something about the military mindset and any commonalities that the human soldiers have with the Sontarans, or the military way of problem solving vs what a civilian like the Doctor usually does, but the story never focuses in that direction. It just jumps about between one of a million different set pieces, never quite cohering to an actual point.

I mean, I don’t know. I came into the show during the Moffat era, where even stories like The Power of Three or The Almost People managed to fail interestingly. And it’s not like the Davies era is lacking for background material to base a story off of – the strongest bits of this story have everything to do with Donna and her family, if you ask me.

So, in the end, I think I’ll have to give this one to the Daleks. Which leaves this story in much the same position as its titular alien menace: full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑