Captain’s log, stardate 78888.6: “A mission of mercy is jeopardized when a planetary ruler decides he wants an Enterprise officer as his wife.”
Where do you even fucking begin with this episode? It’s appallingly racist dreck, and I am stunned that it made it to the screen. I’d almost be tempted to compare it to the late-70s Tom Baker story The Talons of Weng-Chiang, except that Talons has people who actually like it despite all the yellowface and general vile attitude toward Chinese people. “Honor,” meanwhile, is pretty universally agreed to be awful, and no one in their right minds would bother defending it.
Enter Rod Roddenberry, son of Gene. In The Fifty Year Mission, he said, “Code of Honor’ is the one that people say is the most racist, but I just didn’t see it. Is it the best episode ever? No. But did I enjoy the episode? Sure. I just saw them as people on a planet that happened to be of dark skin that evolved in this certain way.”
First of all, Rod, you’re white as cream cheese, so I don’t think you get to have an opinion on whether or not something is racist against Black people, because it fucking is. The director, reportedly, was a flaming racist. The costumes the Lingonians wear? Racist. The accents they speak with? Racist. There is racism baked into every frame of this misbegotten train wreck of an episode, and if Roddenberry here can’t see that, that’s his problem.
And this isn’t just a case of people “applying modern attitudes to old TV shows,” as happens whenever the Talons boosters get mad at people pointing out their favorite story is racist. Even in the late 1980s, when this was being shot, it was abundantly clear how bad this is. Even watching it now, you can clearly see just how much the cast hates the material – it bleeds into their performances. Frakes and Spiner in particular are visibly uncomfortable, and do the absolute minimum required of them. They’re very flat here, even something as batshit stupid as “Naked Now” has better work from both of them.
On the other end of the scale, you have Crosby and Stewart heroically attempting to salvage bad material – Crosby just tries to muscle through it as best she can, while Stewart plays his scenes, especially when talking to Lutan, with surprising amounts of sarcasm, bordering on derision at times, salvaged entirely because he plays Picard with a received pronunciation accent that he learned during acting school in Yorkshire.
But even Stewart, Shakespearean though he is, isn’t capable of completely carrying the weight of this shit on his own. But I have to give him points for trying.
So, with the episode’s awfulness pretty well covered at this point, what do we do about it? Different actors have proposed different things: Jonathan Frakes, for example, suggested that if taking the episode out of the rotation was a non-starter, then the prudent thing to do would be to have a warning label: “Maybe it should be included with an appropriate statement of reason. A proof of concept. This is not who we are. This is not what we stand for. It’s an embarrassment to the franchise and Gene [Roddenberry] would want us to do this. Something like that.”
Gates McFadden, meanwhile, offered the point of view that “Honor” can work as a teaching episode about latent racism:
“I think we talk about them. All of us have talked about it at every con, practically. I think that’s what informs people. On the other hand, you don’t need to see Little Black Sambo the book, they can take that out. I think if it becomes painful for people to watch, then it’s a stupid episode anyway, so you can lose it, but it could be a very good teaching episode because I think when you’re talking about latent racism, when you’re talking about that deep racism, I think that’s a perfect example.”
“Here’s Star Trek, Gene Roddenberry, he did so much to have Uhura, and George Takei, then you start to realize, ‘Yeah, but even people who were on the forefront, you get this latent stuff that surfaces and it’s damaging,’ and it’s good to reevaluate and look at all those things. And it’s just like what they did with Gone with the Wind, I think it’s really great that they have something that talks about it. That’s what it’s needed.”
I think there’s room for both approaches. Acknowledge the episode exists, say that it doesn’t represent Star Trek’s values or what Roddenberry would have wanted, and then use it, combined with Rod’s brilliant comment at the top, (that was sarcasm) and talk about how even the most well-meaning people allies can do or say something that’s shitty and racist.
What makes it all so much worse is that it didn’t have to be this way. The original storyline for this episode, according to TrekMovie, “The original story for this episode called for a reptilian alien race with a culture more like Japanese samurai.
The African theme and casting of Black people for the roles were brought in by director Russ Mayberry,” a man who was apparently so incredibly racist that he managed to get himself fired right before filming of the fight scene between Tasha and Yareena. He was replaced with Les Landau, then the first assistant director.
The best thing that can be said about “Code of Honor,” in the end, is that TNG never gets racist like this again. It becomes problematic in other ways, (most of Troi’s episodes spring to mind) but at least it doesn’t step on the easily-avoidable rake of “Don’t be racist against Black people.”
It doesn’t matter that it was made “in a different time.” Anti-Black racism was wrong in 1987, and it’s wrong in 2023, in the same way that anti-Chinese racism was wrong in 1977 and wrong in 2023. Honestly, Doctor Who could learn from the way the wider Trek community has responded to “Honor.” Rod Roddenberry might be an ignorant dipshit, but he’s very much in the minority when it comes to this episode. Everyone else is on the right side of history.
And there’s nothing more Trek than that.
Leave a Reply