Through sheer coincidence, this post is going up on the date of the 60th anniversary of Doctor Who. Hopefully, I will have a proper anniversary post ready to go, regarding the story that Stef Coburn doesn’t want you to see. Watch this space.
There’s an episode, pretty late in the run of Star Trek: The Next Generation, where Captain Picard is revealed to have a son: Jason Vigo. Jason is nothing like our Jean-Luc, but that doesn’t stop the two of them from bonding over the course of the episode.
Eventually though, it’s revealed that Jason isn’t actually Picard’s son, he was just used by a Ferengi to get revenge on Picard for something that happened in season 1, and the plan fails. Jason departs the show as suddenly as he entered it, and the concept of Picard having a child he didn’t know about is left to be ignored for nearly 30 years.
Jenny, unfortunately, is the Jason Vigo of Doctor Who. She’s never going to last past this episode for the same reason the Timeless Child arc will never be mentioned again, and the Doctor will eventually reset to being a Time Lord: Status Quo is God, and even in serialized television like Doctor Who, the basic facts about the character will remain in place, and those facts do not have time for female (grand)children not named Susan.
For crying out loud, the Doctor’s gotten married a bunch, but even someone as totemic as River Song never gets seen again after the Moffat era. Every new Doctor is a completely different show from the one that preceded it. In essence, Doctor Who isn’t one show, it’s fifteen different ones that all share the same title.
The sad thing is, there’s the germ of a good idea in the character of Jenny: someone who, like the Doctor, was once a soldier but is learning to give that up to pursue peace, A person with two hearts and the presumed ability to regenerate, except she’s not the Doctor and so has room to grow and expand and become her own character, circumstances of her birth aside, but that requires a commitment that even Big Finish isn’t really capable of anymore.
So the question becomes, what could Jenny be if she was allowed to exist past this episode? For that, we have to pivot to Star Trek, specifically the third season of Picard.
In that season’s story, Picard is given another secret son, only this time it’s allowed to stick. His name is Jack Crusher, and he was conceived somewhere in the gap between the end of Nemesis and Picard’s promotion to admiral in 2381. His mother, Beverly, deliberately kept him hidden from Jean-Luc, leading to tension between them when Jack arrives on the Titan and his parentage is revealed.
Over the course of the season, Picard, who once admitted he was deeply uncomfortable around children, grows closer to Jack, and at the end of the season, deliberately returns to the Borg Collective long enough to rescue Jack who is now Locutus 2.0, from being burdened with the same post-assimilation PTSD he struggled with. It’s genuinely arresting television, and I dearly wish Star Trek had the equivalent of Big Finish to explore the ramifications beyond the confines of ten episodes of television.
(The book line is probably close, but they’re busy with prequels and filling in chronological gaps within classic Trek to really explore the TV universe, so we’re left with hoping that Star Trek Legacy happens instead. Which would be nice.)
Part of the reason that Jack’s storyline works where Jason and Jenny failed is that, barring Paramount deciding to do a Picard film, (which Patrick Stewart has been asking for) season 3 of PIC was, in all likelihood, the last time that we’ll see Picard as played by his original actor. So, faced with that, they actually have room to do things like give him a son, because it’s highly unlikely there will be more Picard stories.
Doctor Who, by contrast, can basically run forever as long as there’s sufficient interest in continuing to make the show. True, the previous era was almost the one that got the show canceled, but I think Doctor Who can keep going for a while longer. Gatwa’s second season is already being shot as we speak, and his third won’t be too far behind.
Past that, it’s anyone’s guess. But I have a theory that behind the scenes, RTD is already thinking ahead, searching for candidates who could take over for him as showrunner. The show is in Bad Wolf’s court now, so unless I’m misunderstanding the terms of the deal that brought him back, that means succession is in his hands, not the BBC’s.
But I digress. There’s no room for a character like Jack, or Jenny, on Who for the same reason that the Daleks will stay pretty close to Raymond Cusick’s original concepts: Status quo is everything in a franchise as long-lived as this. It’s inescapable, much like a black hole. Poor Jenny is consigned to spinoff media, be it comic books or Big Finish audios.
Speaking of wasting a perfectly good character, pour one out for Martha Jones, who spends half of the episode being cut off from the main plot, and when she does rejoin the Doctor and Donna, contributes exactly nothing to the story beyond confirming the obvious: that Jenny is dead, and there’s no saving her. And then she leaves, again, to the strains of exactly the same piece of music that she left to in series 3.
During her incumbency, I said she was a prototype for Clara, down to the whole “temporarily evil” bit. During this encore performance, she’s not even that much. Instead, she’s an embryonic version of Yaz. Ironic, considering that Greenhorn wrote this script, not Chris Chibnall. All that’s missing is the middle aged white guy for comic relief.
This is Greenhorn’s final script for the show, and while it would be tempting to discuss which of his two stories was the best, there’d be no point. Both of them suck. About the best thing that can be said about this story, in the end, has nothing to do with Greenhorn at all. This is the story where David Tennant met his future wife, whose father was Peter Davison. Making Georgia Moffett, quite literally, the Doctor’s Daughter… and the Doctor’s Wife.
How’s that for timey-wimey stuff?
Leave a Reply