Captain’s log, stardate 78907.8: “In pursuit of Ferengi marauders, the Enterprise and its quarry become trapped by a mysterious planet that is draining both ships’ energies.”
At last, some good fucking food! At least in comparison to “Naked Now” and “Code of Honor,” which were abysmal. This one actually has quite a bit going for it, aside from the fact that the Ferengi are terrible villains. We get Armin Shimerman making his Trek debut, several years before he played Quark on Deep Space Nine.
But what sticks out to me about “Outpost” is just how comfortable everyone seems to be in their roles at this point. Maybe it’s just in light of how flat they all were last week, but Patrick Stewart here doesn’t just seem like “Patrick Stewart in red Spandex,” but Captain Picard. More to the point, the Picard we get in “Outpost” is the closest we’ve seen of Picard in cultural memory – that is, the man we see in the third season and onward.
And it’s not just him, everyone else is on fire too! I would particularly like to highlight Geordi La Forge, who we see in Engineering for the first time, and absolutely shines in those sequences. It’s the natural place for him to be, and the writers pick up on this at the start of season two, where his promotion is explicitly depicted. Certainly, it makes a hell of a lot more sense than the rotating cast of “chief engineers” that they have now.
Basically, if you have to point to an episode of early TNG where the entire main cast is firing on all cylinders, I’d pick this one. The only flaw it has, of course, is the Ferengi themselves: not so much in concept, but in execution.
The Ferengi, as presented here, are explicitly dark mirrors of humanity – they are now what Q accused humans of being back in “Farpoint.” And that, by itself, is an interesting concept, but it’s all wrecked with the decision to make them short guys with giant ears, small hands and nail polish who jump around like crazed gerbils. Even my girlfriend, who has never seen a Ferengi episode of Trek before now, realized that as villains go, they are fucking terrible.
But I want to emphasize that they are terrible villains. As the answer to the question “What would society look like if we allowed capitalism to control absolutely eery detail of our lives, and take it to a near unrecognizable extreme,” they are honestly brilliant, and it’s no wonder that they’re a huge part of DS9.
One of my favorite bits of DS9 is a conversation between Quark and Garak, the resident Cardassian tailor on the show, as they discuss the omnipresence of the Federation (and by extension, Earth) within the Alpha Quadrant:
QUARK: Take a sip of this.
GARAK: What is it?
QUARK: A human drink. It’s called root beer.
GARAK: I don’t know.
QUARK: Come on. Aren’t you just a little bit curious?
(Garak sips)
QUARK: What do you think?
GARAK: It’s vile.
QUARK: I know. It’s so bubbly and cloying and happy.
GARAK: Just like the Federation.
QUARK: But you know what’s really frightening? If you drink enough of it, you begin to like it.
GARAK: It’s insidious.
QUARK: Just like the Federation.
Replace the word “Federation” with “America,” and you could have an accurate summation of not just capitalism, but in particular American capitalism that gets satirized so heavily in the Rammstein song “Amerika.”
Illustrating the Ferengi as capitalists, for me, is nothing short of brilliant, not least because of how history has unfolded since this episode aired in late 1987. As much as we all want to hope for a world in which something like the Federation becomes real, the truth is, the future is going to look a lot less like TNG and more like… well, the opportunistic profit-chasing pirates of the Mirror Broken comic book series.
Specifically, Elon Musk.
It is perversely hilarious to me that Discovery name dropped Elon Musk in the same sentence as Zephram Cochrane, and not just because it was Mirror Lorca who said it. The man is an out and out fascist, as anyone who’s watched the collapse of Twitter in the past year can attest to. If we ever terraform Mars or send a manned mission to an alien planet, the future we get is going to look a lot less like the Federation and more like the Terran Empire.
I don’t want that future. I want to live in a world where people work because they want to – all their basic needs have been met, and now they have an opportunity to give back and help keep the good times rolling, instead of working because they have to appease some corporate overlord who only wants to make the shareholders happy.
I want to live in a world where actors are properly compensated for their work, and not turned into computer programs so they can continue to “appear” in movies made long after their death. (See: Peter Cushing in Rogue One.)
Like, it’s one thing if you use previously recorded elements, combined with new material, to make something, as with the new Beatles song, “Now and Then.” Despite what early media reports suggested, generative AI never appears in the song. It’s all made of previously recorded material, along with new parts. But to “create” a new performance that John Lennon, or George Harrison, never actually had anything to do with? Beyond the pale. The same goes, say, for a hypothetical scenario in which a digital ghost of Patrick Stewart “appears” as Picard in some future episode of Star Trek – it’s uncanny valley to the extreme.
Which is why it’s so important that SAG-AFTRA is able to procure protections against unlicensed use of AI to recreate an actor’s performance, among other things. Because if the studios had their way, we’d be watching AI generated slop until the sun goes out. The Ferengi would be all over this, and we know it.
But all of that is in the future. For now, we still have to deal with early TNG and its utterly nonsensical decision to play the Ferengi as antagonists. At least the next time we see them, it comes with a side of “Exploring Picard’s life before the Enterprise.”
Leave a Reply