Wolf Trek: Where No One Has Gone Before

Captain’s log, stardate 78927.2: “When an experimental engine modification throws the Enterprise to the edge of the known universe, the crew must rely on a mysterious alien to guide the ship home.”


You may not know this, but I have actually done two watchthroughs of TNG. The one I’m blogging about is the second one, the first one was carried out over most of 2022 and into early 2023, which I watched on my own. (Compared to now, where I’m watching it with my girlfriend.) Then and now, “Where No One Has Gone Before” remains, for me, a highlight of the series. Admittedly, the Wesley subplot is a bit annoying, but at least he is part of the solution to the problem of the week and not, as usual, the reason for it.

And here, I must admit my own naiveté. A very long time ago, before I got into Star Trek and identified more strongly as a fan of Doctor Who, I used to think that Trek was a serious sci-fi show for serious people. It had rules you had to follow, as opposed to Doctor Who where pretty much anything goes.

And then I watched “No One” for the first time, and my mind was changed. All of a sudden, I realized that while Doctor Who and Trek are still very, very different, there were still moments when one could almost intersect with the other. The scenes of the Enterprise in M33, or that weird blue nebula with the floating white things in it, are the kinds of things one might expect to see a blue police box tumbling around in, and not a Galaxy class starship. And yet, here we are!

The scenes where the various crew members aboard the Enterprise hallucinate things, be it secret passions, (the ballet dancing ensign, or that one guy in ops gold playing Mozart as part of a string quartet) horrors, or even that amazing moment where the turbolift door opens and Picard almost steps into space itself, are some of my favorite sequences in the entire story. But there’s one in particular that, for me, is the most heartrending of them all.

I speak, of course, of the scene in which Picard, as he walks down a corridor, is suddenly confronted by an elderly woman – his mother. We know from Picard’s reaction, even before he says as much, that she’s supposed to be dead, and yet here she is, alive as can be, pouring Jean-Luc tea:

MAMAN: (french accent) You look tense, Jean-Luc. Come and have a cup of tea.
PICARD: Maman?
MAMAN: I’ll make it good and strong, the way you like it. We will have a nice long talk.
PICARD: This can’t be. You’ve been
MAMAN: Dead? But I’m always with you, you know that.
PICARD: Yes, I’ve felt that. But why now, suddenly.
MAMAN: You mean out here? At what you say us the end of the universe? Or do you see this as the beginning of it?
PICARD: We believe it the outer rim. Maman, do you understand these things? Can you tell me where my ship is? What is this place?

This is the part where I talk about how, having now seen all of JLP’s televised adventures, watching the second season of his eponymous show changed how I looked at this portion of the episode. Over the course of season 2, we learn the exact circumstances under which Yvette Picard passed away, and they are heartbreaking.

Quoting from Memory Alpha:

Yvette had a turbulent relationship with her husband Maurice, which proved a traumatic part of Jean-Luc’s childhood memories. While Jean-Luc had long assumed this was due to abuse on the part of Maurice, he later realized that Yvette suffered from severe mental illness that she refused to treat, and that Maurice was actually trying to help her. This struggle with mental illness would eventually lead Yvette to suicide in the 2310s, something which Jean-Luc blamed himself for.

A lot of people, in my view, give the first and second seasons of Picard short shrift, believing them to be overly messy and not reflective of the character we know and love. But for my money, Picard gives our favorite captain more depth than we’ve ever had before, especially in those first two seasons. The Yvette subplot, and the way in which her suicide helped turn Jean-Luc into who he is, is tragically beautiful, a tender exploration of mental health in a time where that is receiving increased amounts of prominence in our world.

As the man himself says: “There are moments in time we wish we could travel back to. Memories. Pieces of life better lived in reverse. In those moments, tragic endings might rewind into joyful beginnings. Moments of loss into those of gains.”

And I understand exactly what he means. In my case, it was the loss of a cherished friendship. I wish dearly, like Picard and his unwitting role in his mother’s death, that I could take it all back. Undo the things that led me to this friendship ending. But I can’t, any more than he can bring his mother back to life. We just have to sit with the hurt and the pain, and vow to grow, and become better people in the future.

The story of Picard, from “Farpoint” to “The Last Generation,” is about Jean-Luc making his way through life, carrying the traumas he suffered when he was younger, and save worlds with it. We are imperfect people, Jean-Luc and I… but then, that’s true of all of us. We are all growing, all learning. I may not be on trial by Q, but I still get his mission, more clearly now than I did a year ago.

Ultimately, at some point, we do have to make our peace with the past. And I know I will with mine soon enough. It will take time, and there will be bumps in the road, but I know where I’m going. I’m on that journey now, even as we speak.

It’s moments like these, when I am going through hard times, that I am thankful that Picard exists. His words, even now, still have the power to soothe and comfort, and they speak to me more clearly now as I finally enter true adulthood. He is the person I would most like to be when I grow up, and I hope I can get there. I learn best by example, and for my money, there’s no better example to follow than his.

Jean-Luc Picard: the 24th century’s Atticus Finch.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑