Wolf Trek: Lonely Among Us

Captain’s log, stardate 78946.2: “While transporting delegates, an alien life form wreaks havoc on the Enterprise computer – and begins to take over the minds of her crew.”


When I watched this episode for the first time back in 2022, I thought it reminded me of something: the 1977 Doctor Who story The Invisible Enemy, wherein the Fourth Doctor becomes temporarily possessed by an alien intelligence that forces him to do weird and unsettling things. It’s not exactly the best Baker story out there, but when I watched it for the first time at roughly the age of 14, I found myself spellbound anyway.

“Lonely Among Us” is kind of like the Star Trek version of Invisible Enemy, only instead of a giant virus that looks unsettlingly like a crustacean, there’s a subplot about a couple of disagreeable aliens that doesn’t really go anywhere. And also makes poor Tasha Yar look like she can’t handle them without running off to Riker, which is a little unfortunate considering SHE’S THE FUCKING SECURITY CHIEF!

Honest to god, Tasha has to be the worst-served character of the series so far. I thought that back in 2022, and I think so now. She was a genuinely great concept, and Denise Crosby did such a good job trying to get her to work. It’s not her fault the writers didn’t know how to make that happen.

On the plus side, the alien costumes are genuinely great. They look like… well, alien aliens, as opposed to the traditional sort of Star Trek design, which are functionally humans but with pointy ears, nose ridges, or both. Practical in the long term? Absolutely the fuck not. But it’s nice to see that the show can do genuinely out-of-this-world alien species every now and again.

But where this episode really shines, for me, is everything to do with Data and his newfound special interest of Sherlock Holmes. Brent Spiner has genuinely incredible comedic timing, and for an allegedly emotionless android, he infuses Data with newfound curiosity when first learning about Holmes, and then sheer joy when he pretends to be Holmes (complete with pipe) later on in the episode.

Sherlock Holmes, honestly, is the perfect character for Data to emulate. Particularly in Steven Moffat’s conception of him, Sherlock has genuine trouble relating to ordinary people, and frequently wonders what it’s like for John Watson (and various other characters) to just float along through life, not being nearly as smart as he is.

Data is similar, though rather than looking down his nose at people as Sherlock does, he wants to understand humanity, and become more human himself. I think in embracing the Great Detective to the extent that he does, Data finds in Holmes a kindred spirit – a human he can relate to. His fictionality, as far as Data is concerned, is immaterial.

Moving away from Data, I really like how Riker comes across in this episode. This is the story that illustrates exactly what his job is, other than sitting at Picard’s right hand and periodically giving orders to the helmsman. He’s kind of like the vice president: there to do the job of the captain in the event that the CO is incapacitated, or in this case, possessed by an energy being.

The best example of this comes during the scene where the rest of the senior officers plan a mutiny:

DATA: A mere change of direction hardly justifies mutiny.
CRUSHER: Exactly what do you believe you’re sensing from him?
TROI: It’s just a feeling that he’s, well, that he’s closed part of his mind to me. I just feel that the Captain has become, perhaps dangerous.
RIKER: If he’s dangerous. If.
LAFORGE: Then he’d have to be relieved of command. Which you could do, Doctor, but it’s beaucoup trouble if you’re wrong.
DATA: And at the moment it is all pure speculation. He has done nothing to subject the Enterprise to danger.
CRUSHER: I’d need a medical log citing clear evidence of incapacity. You could do it without that problem.
RIKER: Only if all command officers agreed it vital to do so. But he has not been showing any overt unusual behaviour.
TROI: Ultimately, I believe he will.
CRUSHER: As second in command, it’s still in your corner. I’ll order medical and psychiatric exams. You’ll have to back me up somehow.

I like Riker’s reluctance to go ahead with the mutiny here, given the scenario he faced while aboard the USS Pegasus, as revealed in season 7. But he does it anyway, because ultimately, his job is to safeguard the rest of the crew, from his captain if need be. (Having written plenty of Trek fics where my XO was forced to take over from my captain for a variety of reasons, I am very familiar with this dynamic.)

In summary, while “Lonely Among Us” will never win any awards for being a great murder mystery story, (TNG has plenty of better examples out there) or even being a good “bottle show,” I do kind of like it all the same. The shadowy nighttime scenes make it feel a bit like film noir, albeit in color rather than black and white. When I talk about early TNG having more highlights in it than people like to recognize, “Lonely” is what I mean – the actors, as noted previously, are obviously very comfortable with their characters by now, and each other.

One of the enduring bits of TNG, and why this show remains so beloved even three and a half decades later, is how close the regular cast were with each other. They’re a genuine family, and it didn’t take very long at all for that closeness and camaraderie to become evident on screen.

In his autobiography, Patrick Stewart tells the story of the time he gathered the main cast together on the bridge set and told them off for goofing around between takes, the most infamous line being “Denise, we are not here to have fun!” Frakes and the rest of them have roasted him for that moment many times since, but it was important: Stewart learned to loosen up, and become the captain of TNG’s main cast as well as of the Enterprise.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑