Wolf Trek: Justice

Captain’s log, stardate 78965.4: “When Wesley Crusher is condemned to die on an idyllic, primitive planet, Captain Picard must face breaking the Prime Directive to save the boy’s life.”


In which the Enterprise crew arrives on a planet that looks suspiciously like the clone compound featured in the infamously bad Robert Fiveson flick, Parts: The Clonus Horror. If you’ve seen Mystery Science Theater 3000, then you know what I’m talking about. Riffed late in the eighth season, the film (per TVTropes) tells the story of “the titular land of Clonus, a society of young, fit adults who seem endlessly happy. That is, until you see the armed guards that surround them. Everyone in Clonus dreams of being chosen to go to America, where the promise of an even happier, more fulfilling life awaits.”

The Edo planet isn’t quite as visibly authoritarian as the society depicted in the movie, but one imagines that Richard and Lena (the film’s romantic leads, and yes she shares my name) would be quite at home on such a world. Hell, they’d probably love it there, now that the army of guards and overseers are no longer watching them.

What “Justice” is most remembered for is being the first of TNG’s many “Prime Directive” episodes, in which the crew of the Enterprise spend an extended period of time debating and discussing that policy of non-interference… before ultimately deciding to say “fuck it” and interfere anyway, lending the impression that the PD mainly exists to be broken.

First of all, all cops are bastards, even if they’re wearing what amounts to glorified loincloths. Second of all, any society that decides putting someone to death for the “crime” of accidentally wrecking a flowerbed is deeply and profoundly fucked up. Obviously, Picard and crew are never going to say this directly, but you can tell that’s exactly what they’re thinking once they start trying to figure out what to do with Wesley.

On the plus side, this episode does give us an early Patrick Stewart Speech, in the form of the most famous line in it: “There can be no justice so long as laws are absolute,” he says, as he attempts to justify the crew rescuing Wesley from certain death. After that though, “Justice” is disposable.

Plot-wise, I honestly like “Justice” a lot better when it was called Star Trek: Insurrection, and featured Captain Picard and crew fighting to protect another idyllic world from corruptive influences, in this case a “Badmiral” (to use a Lower Decks term for a Starfleet admiral doing questionable things) and another alien menace, the Son’a.

Yes, it’s another Prime Directive story, but at least Insurrection is actually about something, and logically follows through from the characters we’ve come to know and love over the preceding decade, rather than simply being abandoned TOS-style plot lines that got given to TNG because they didn’t have any other ideas lying around.

This is the point at which where we really need to address the BTS history of TNG, and it is not pretty. Simply put, they were lucky to even get the first season made, let alone the renewals for seasons two and three. Roddenberry had hired a bunch of his old TOS cohorts to work on Next Gen, but between him being an interfering busybody with another interfering busybody as his lawyer, the good ship Enterprisealmost went down in its first year – thanks to that lawyer, all of the TOS-era staff had been chased away.

It’s funny to me that early TNG aired at around the same time as McCoy-era Doctor Who, because one gets the sense that even with the freedom provided to him by a BBC who wanted the show dead, Andrew Cartmel had a much better job running Who than Roddenberry ever did on TNG.

Part of this is just down to episode count: By 1987, Doctor Who was making twelve episodes a year, roughly half the standard TNG count of twenty six. The smaller episode count, coupled with the fact that Doctor Who stories in the classic era were designed to be multi-part serials rather than one-shots, meant that the stories themselves had more time to cohere. (Also, Cartmel-era Who had a vastly superior writing staff.)

When it’s good, TNG can be genuinely great – it’s no wonder the BBC looked toward it to fill gaps in its schedule, especially with Doctor Who on the decline. But on the other paw, I think Cartmel-era Who hangs together more consistently than early TNG does. Cartmel may have only overseen twelve stories, but it’s telling that the weakest one of the bunch, Time and the Rani, still has stuff going for it.

According to The Writer’s Tale by Russell T Davies, he briefly floated around the concept of a crossover between his Doctor Who and Star Trek, then continuing in the form of Enterprise. (Which featured fellow St. Louisan Scott Bakula as Jonathan Archer.) The crossover never happened since ENT got cancelled, but even so, there is something to the idea.

If only there had been room in the budget for Cartmel to write a Doctor Who story set on the Enterprise during the run of TNG. The Seventh Doctor and Ace are the last people to wind up in the middle of a Star Trek story, and you’d get all kinds of dramatic tension from figuring out how exactly you can merge two completely different storytelling styles, never mind characters as different from each other as Captain Picard and McCoy’s Doctor. Certainly, it would have made for more interesting television than “Justice” ever did.

“Justice” is what happens when TNG spins its wheels, and it’s why the received wisdom surrounding the show is, “Skip 1 and 2 and proceed directly to season 3.” “Naked Now” and “Code of Honor” were terrible as well, but at least they were terrible in ways that made it easier for me to get a thousand words out of them. “Justice” isn’t even that, it’s just boring, vapid, and empty. I’d rather watch an un-riffed version of Clonus than this episode again.

Because at least Clonus has Peter Graves. “Justice” doesn’t even have that.

Leave a Reply

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑