First things first: despite the fact that she’s a huge part of the episode, don’t expect me to talk much about Agatha Christie. That ground has already been pretty well covered by my friend Audrey Armstrong, specifically in these two posts. So, I’m going to do something entirely different instead.
One gets the sense, now that I’ve seen all of Roberts’ episodes, that as far as TV writing went, the man was an absolute hack who got extremely lucky with The Lodger, since he was A) adapting his own work rather than attempting to write something new from scratch and B) had the good fortune to be working with Matt Smith and James Corden, two actors with spectacular chemistry and the comic chops necessary to turn what could have been a disaster into a standout of the season. The same pairing doesn’t exactly save Closing Time, but it does make that story somewhat more bearable.
But his other stories on the show? Not only are none of them as good as Lodger annoyingly is, they should have been warning signs that this man was simply not cut out for TV. For all that his novel work is good (at least going by his novelization of Shada, most of which was Douglas Adams anyway) his TV work is rather revealing in a way the books are not.
He’s racist, for one thing. The infamous opening scenes of Shakespeare Code, with its line about how Martha should walk around like she owns the place, is appalling, to say nothing of the way Shakespeare himself treats Martha.
Nor does he seem to terribly understand his subjects – when faced with the task of doing a Shakespeare story, Roberts decides to gush generically (via the Doctor) and compare him to JK Rowling, in a sequence that was cringe in 2007 and depressingly prophetic now, given how both of them are more well known for virulent transphobia than any previous creative work.
Likewise, here he writes that Christie’s books tend to be very formulaic and that all murder mystery novels are the same, which is exactly what I’d expect someone who’s never read a fucking mystery novel in his life to say.
As Audrey says: “This, ultimately, is why parody and satire are among the most difficult to pieces of writing to pull off, because it can be so easy to aim for the simplest of routes. One must only scroll through the Twitter profile of the Babylon Bee to see what I mean – there’s a skill to mockery that few possess, because it requires putting in hours of research, and perhaps more importantly, an understanding of what it is you are trying to poke fun at it.”
This is part of what made The Curse of Fatal Death so funny – it’s not just the fact that it’s a spoof of Doctor Who, but a spoof made with genuine love and appreciation for classic Who in a time when the show was a dead duck with no apparent chance at ever returning to screens. Similarly, this is what makes Star Trek: Lower Decks the best of the streaming-era Trek shows – the writers on that series deeply love Trek and all the various facets of it. It’s not mean-spirited bullying, but good-natured ribbing.
And I think that’s what’s wrong with The Unicorn and the Wasp. It’s a murder mystery story written by someone with not only no understanding of the genre beyond glancing at a TVTropes page every now and then, but thinks them pointless wastes of time. Yes, the criticisms are delivered humorously, but that doesn’t make them jokes.
I have no patience for writers that insult the viewer’s intelligence. Hell, I have no patience for bullies in general, and that’s what Gareth Roberts is: a bully. In his final story, The Caretaker, we saw this rot and ugliness clearly for the first time – you can almost tell which jokes were his and which were Moffat’s. After that came the public falling out as he went mask-off TERF, and since then he’s been left high and dry, forgotten. Even his Shada novelization has since been supplanted by the animated reconstruction.
And that’s the best fate for him, if you ask me. He has no place in Doctor Who, certainly not now, in an era that contains one actual trans woman in its first broadcast episode, a drag queen in the regular series, and a mayfly incumbent who has made no secret of his own support for the trans community. No doubt, Roberts is apoplectic with rage at the news of trans-positive Doctor Who, when all his own biases are telling him that we are a menace to be destroyed by any means necessary.
Fuck him. Fuck Gareth Roberts, fuck Graham Linehan, and fuck J.K. Rowling. Fuck all the TERFs. Doctor Who is our show now, and you can’t take it from us.
Leave a Reply